answersLogoWhite

0


Best Answer

The miracle of the draught of fish occurred when Jesus told the disciples to cast out their nets, and they then were overwhelmed by the abundance of fish that were caught. In Luke, this occurs before the crucifixion, but in John, it occurs as the last appearance of the risen Jesus.
In John's Gospel, much of the account of the resurrection appearances of Jesus can be seen to have been sourced from Luke's Gospel and embellished, including this pericope. If the author of John's Gospel was so clearly dependent on Luke's Gospel for this narrative, then we can at least say that the episode did not occur after the resurrection.


However, we also know that the author of Luke's Gospel was dependent on Mark's Gospel for his information on the life of Jesus. Whenever Luke describes events and sayings described by Mark, the Greek text is almost identical. Moreover, a "Missing Block" of text from Mark, but not found in Luke, results in the curious conjunction in Luke 9:18 "And it came to passas he was alone praying, his disciples were with him: and he asked them ..." These clauses are found in Mark at the start and end of the Missing Block - indisputable evidence that Luke copied Mark. Since Mark knew nothing of the miracle of the draught of fish, we can reasonably say that this did not really happen.

User Avatar

Wiki User

8y ago
This answer is:
User Avatar
More answers
User Avatar

AnswerBot

1w ago

The miracle of the Draught of Fish happened before Jesus' resurrection as recorded in Luke Chapter 5. In John Chapter 21, after his resurrection, Jesus again manifested a similar miracle with the disciples while they were out fishing.

This answer is:
User Avatar

Add your answer:

Earn +20 pts
Q: Did the miracle of Draught of Fish happen before Jesus' resurrection as in Luke Chapter 5 or after the resurrection as in John Chapter 21?
Write your answer...
Submit
Still have questions?
magnify glass
imp
Continue Learning about Religious Studies

What did the Apostles stress before the religious council?

The Apostles stressed that they must obey God rather than men and proclaimed the message of Jesus' resurrection before the religious council. They were bold in their faith and did not waver in their commitment to spreading the Gospel.


Did Moses ever speak of a Resurrection from the dead?

No, there is no record of Moses directly speaking about a resurrection from the dead in the Old Testament. The concept of resurrection was more explicitly developed in later biblical texts and in the teachings of Jesus in the New Testament.


What time period does the gospel of Matthew cover?

The book of Matthew starts with the birth of Jesus which occurred around 4-5 BC and the last chapter finishes with Jesus' last words before being taken up in the air and returning to heaven. Jesus was 33 years old when He died on the cross and rose 3 days later. It was 40 days after His resurrection when He was taken up into heaven. Therefore the time period is approximately between 4BC to 33 AD.


Did Jesus change water to wine before he was baptized?

The Bible does not mention Jesus changing water to wine before his baptism. The first miracle of turning water into wine at the wedding in Cana is recorded in the Gospel of John and occurred after his baptism by John the Baptist.


How many days before anyone could touch Jesus after his resurrection?

A:This depends on the passage being read:In Matthew 28:9, the women touch Jesus, holding him by the feet, on the morning of his resurrection. Jesus allowed them to worship him thus.In John 20:17, Jesus says to Mary Magdalene, "Touch me not; for I am not yet ascended ..." In this gospel, not only could Mary not touch Jesus, but no one could before he rose to heaven.Eight days later, still in John's Gospel at verse 20:27, Jesus forgets his earlier concern and tells Thomas to touch his wounds.

Related questions

Does the book of Mormon reference the resurrection of Jesus?

Yes! The Book of Mormon references the resurrection of Jesus Christ long before the event actually took place. In 2 Nephi chapter 9 (estimated to be written in 559 BC) we learn that it has been the plan of God from the beginning that there should be a resurrection brought about by the atonement of a Savior, who is Jesus Christ. In Jacob chapter 4 (estimated to be written in 544 BC), the atonement and resurrection of Jesus Christ is also mentioned. In the book of Mosiah, chapter 15 (estimated to be written in 148 BC) the doctrine of resurrection is discussed. Here, we learn that Jesus Christ will break the bonds of death, that He will be resurrected, and that through Him all others will be resurrected. Jesus' resurrection is also discussed in chapter 18. In Alma chapter 40 (estimated to be written in 74 BC), the doctrine of resurrection and the event of Christ's resurrection is discussed in further detail. Helaman chapter 14 (estimated to be written in 6 BC) teaches that "the resurrection of Christ redeemeth mankind." and foretells what those on the American continent will experience at the time of Christ's death and resurrection. The 3 Nephi tells of the events that occurred in the Americas at the time of Jesus Christ's death and resurrection, but does not repeat the Bible story of the Resurrection of Jesus Christ. It describes a period of three days darkness taking place during the time Christ was in the tomb, and tells the story of the resurrected Christ visiting the Book of Mormon peoples several months after His resurrection. The later books of Mormon and Moroni, written a few hundred years after the life of Christ, remind us that we should have hope in the power of the resurrection of Christ.


Where are the saints who died before Jesus coming?

Paul was inspired to write Hebrews 11 - called the Faith chapter - listing many who died in the faith and are awaiting their resurrection to life again.


Did Jesus perform the first miracle before or after he was baptized?

The first miracle was performed after Jesus' baptism.


Did the resurrection come before the accension?

Yes, the ascension of Jesus was 40 days after his resurrection.


Who was not a disciple before Jesus' resurrection?

paul


What five ways did God act through Jesus before his resurrection?

God did a lot through Jesus before His resurrection. It's all in the Bible


Can you delete a chapter on Pottermore?

No you can't. If it isn't an important chapter you can skip it, but if it is a compulsory chapter you have to do it before you move on.


What was the last miracle Jesus perform before he died?

Attached an ear


Was Jesus passive when He performed His first miracle although He performed it before His time?

Jesus was not passive when He performed his first miracle. Everything was at the right time.


What is post resurrection faith?

The faith that the believers had after the physical resurrection of Jesus. Before this they did not seem always to understand what He spoke about but later, when they had received the Holy Spirit, they were different men.


What is the night- watch of Resurrection?

The Night Watch of the Resurrection is Holy Saturday, otherwise known as Easter Vigil, which occurs the night before Easter Sunday.


Can you quit your job before filing chapter 7?

Only if you have filed chapter 6.