0
Do religious displays on public property violate the establishment clause?
Wiki User
∙ 11y ago
In 1984, in the Supreme Court case Lynch v. Donnelly it was determined that no, it does not. However in subsequent cases the Supreme Court Justices ruled differently based on the Lemon Test.
Wiki User
∙ 11y ago
Religious displays on public property can be seen as a violation of the establishment clause if they promote or endorse a particular religion. The U.S. Supreme Court has ruled that such displays must have a secular purpose, not primarily promote religion, and not excessively entangle the government with religion.
Add your answer:
Earn +20 pts
What amendment would be violated if the government established an official religion?
The establishment of an official religion would violate the First Amendment of the United States Constitution, which prohibits the government from making any law respecting an establishment of religion.
What are the activities that violates secularism?
Activities that violate secularism include government favoritism towards a specific religion, religious discrimination in public services or employment, imposition of religious beliefs on individuals, and funding religious organizations with public money.
Can a Muslim girl dye her hair black?
Yes, it is permissible for a Muslim girl to dye her hair black as long as it does not violate religious guidelines, such as being done for the purpose of imitating a specific non-Muslim group or culture. It is important to consult with a religious scholar or authority for specific guidance.
What was the result of the 2004 case that argued the phrase under God in the Pledge of Allegiance violated the First Amendment?
The Supreme Court ruled in 2004 that the phrase "under God" in the Pledge of Allegiance did not violate the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment because it served a secular purpose and did not establish a religion.
When is it acceptable for the government to limit the practice of people's religious beliefs?
The government can limit religious practices when they pose a threat to public safety or violate established laws, such as banning harmful practices like human sacrifice or stopping discrimination against certain groups in the name of religion. Such limitations should be necessary, proportional, and non-discriminatory.
Does Thanksgiving violate the establishment clause?
no
What is the constitutional argument of the Wallace vs Jaffree case?
Did Alabama law violate the First Amendment's Establishment Clause.
Why can't you not do public displays of affection?
Because it's not appropriate for a school setting.If you violate this rule,you face disciplinary action.
What does organized prayer in public school violate?
Organized prayer in public school violates the First Amendment Establishment Clause.
What rights King George violate?
Life, Liberty, and Property it was on my test today!
What are the laws for an employer entering an employees property to retrieve company owned property.?
Depending on the property and what the job is, the employer is sometimes allowed to enter their property. However, in most cases, they are not allowed to violate the property.
How does the US government protect property?
By having laws in place that protect owners from those who seek to violate their property rights honorably or illegally.
Does the creationism act violate the establishment clause of the first amendment?
Yes, as determined by the Supreme Court of the United States of America in 1987 (Edwards vs. Aguillard), creationism cannot be taught in public schools as doing so would violate the US constitution.
Does it violate antitrust laws to pay other bidders to not bid on a property at a foreclosure sale?
ha! no! it's not okay!
Should religious practice be allowed in school?
Yes. The school, as a government institution, may not sponsor or solicit any religious practice because doing so would violate the First Amendment's establishment clause. However, the school also may not prohibit a student from reasonable religious practice without violating the same amendment's Free Exercise clause. Practically, this means that the school can't sponsor an official prayer or have any required religious practices, but it must allow students to pray individually (and even aloud if they so desire).
What are the difficulties in using the wall of separation principle?
The first problem is that a wall of separation would violate the establishment clause itself by establishing secularism/atheism as the National Religion. Since the purpose of the establishment clause is to prevent Congress and thus all branches the Federal government from establishing a National Religion, a wall of separation between church and state violates the establishment clause. The second problem is a wall of separation could only be imposed by denying religious citizens the free exercise of their religion so it runs contrary to the free exercise clause as well. The third problem is that the Supreme Court itself began using a religious test to prevent aid from going to Catholic schools while allowing it to go to protestant schools. The court used the test that when the majority of schools are of a particular denomination, it appears to be an establishment of religion. Of course, the Justices fooled no one. The particular religion denied aid was always the Catholic church and in some of the earliest cases they even deliberately mentioned the Catholic church. Also, the Court began changing the religious test to exclude all religious speech which violated the prohibition of a religious test and violated the free speech rights of religious citizens.
Is it against the law for an apartment complex to deny religious service at your apartment?
It may not violate any laws if they do so. There are the terms of the lease for the apartment, which may restrict numbers of visitors and use of the property. Often it is not allowed to run a business or non-profit organization from an apartment as it is disruptive to the other tenants. Music and noise restrictions can also have an affect. Organized services are probably going to be against the terms of the lease. A regular religious study is probably not going to violate it. You will probably need to consult with an attorney and be sure to bring your lease and any rules for the complex with you.
