answersLogoWhite

0

A:There are several dimensions to this question. First of all, the four New Testament gospels were all written anonymously and only attributed to the apostles whose names they now bear, later in the second century. In spite of its attribution, John's Gospel is not authentic in terms of authorship by the named apostle - and biblical scholars say that it could not have been written by an eyewitness to the events portrayed..

The Gospels of Matthew, Mark and Luke are called synoptic gospels, because they are reasonably consistent in their content. John's Gospel differs significantly from the other three. The essentials are there, especially the crucifixion and resurrection of Jesus, but are told very differently than in any of the other New Testament gospels.

The reason for the close similarity among the synoptic gospels is that the Gospels of Matthew and Luke were largely based on Mark's Gospel. When they agree with Mark, they do so with a good deal of consistency, although often with elaborations. Matthew and Luke also contain essentially similar material attributed to the hypothetical 'Q' document. However, it has been demonstrated that John is only loosely based on Luke, with some material taken direct from Mark. The differences are such that it is not possible to say that John is authentic without discounting the synoptic gospels.

The early Church Father Origen, in defending John's Gospel (Commentary on John), said "Although he does not always tell the truth literally, he always tells it spiritually."

User Avatar

Wiki User

13y ago

What else can I help you with?

Related Questions

How many disciples are in johns gospel?

Actually all 12 were there.


What has the author Johns Varghese written?

Johns Varghese has written: 'The imagery of love in the Gospel of John' -- subject(s): Bible, Commentaries, Love, Biblical teaching


Encountering Jesus in the New Testament chapter review answer?

List three ways johns gospel Differs from the synoptic gospels


What was Johns life like before he wrote the gospel?

John--the beloved disciple--had a tough life after Jesus. He was captured by the Romans and sent to the Island of Patmos.


Was John's Gospel the only gospel from authentic apostolic authorship?

A:Until the earlier years of the twentieth century, scholars continued to believe that John's Gospel was independent of the synoptic tradition, regardless of who wrote the Gospel. By the second half of the twentieth century, research was beginning to make it clear that the fourth gospel was dependent on Luke's Gospel and, to a lesser extent, Mark's Gospel. Scholars now say that John's Gospel could not have been written by an eyewitness to the events portrayed. It is loosely based on Luke's Gospel, with some material taken direct from Mark. New Testament scholars have long established that Matthewand Luke were copied in large part from Mark, and for that reason Matthew could not have been written by one of the apostles. They now also realise that John is not from authentic apostolic authorship.


Did John write anything else other that the Gospel of John and the Book of Revelation?

These were two different Johns, attributed to two different books.


What was johns in the bible?

John was the most beloved disciple. Like the rest of the disciples, he was commissioned to preach the gospel and to heal the sick. John also received the revelation of the end days.


What has the author Pamela Sheldon Johns written?

Pamela Sheldon Johns has written: 'Pizza- 50 Authentic Italian Recipes' 'Gelato!' 'Risotto (Williams-Sonoma)' 'Williams-Sonoma Collection' 'Italian Food Artisans' 'Italian' -- subject(s): Cookery, Italian, Italian Cookery 'Risotto' -- subject(s): Cookery (Rice), Risotto


What is the birth name of Val Johns?

Val Johns's birth name is Valjean Johns.


What was the main purpose of writing johns gospel?

The main purpose of writing John's Gospel was to present Jesus as the divine Son of God and to strengthen the faith of believers in his identity and teachings. John also aimed to show how Jesus fulfilled Old Testament prophecies and to invite readers to believe in him for eternal life.


What is the birth name of Daniel Johns?

Daniel Johns's birth name is Daniel Paul Johns.


What is the birth name of Margo Johns?

Margo Johns's birth name is Jessie Margaret Johns.