0
Why did Jesus tell his disciples not to tell others of what they had seen at the Transfiguration?
Wiki User
∙ 8y ago
Mark 9:9 - Now as they came down from the mountain, He commanded them that they should tell no onethe things they had seen, till the Son of Man had risen from the dead.
Jesus didn't command them not to tell anyone what they had seen; He commanded them not to tell anyone YET. It was quite common for Jesus to teach his "inner circle" something that they were not to proclaim until later; after either His resurrection or ascension.
John 16:4 - But these things I have told you, that when the time comes, you may remember that I told you of them. And these things I did not say to you at the beginning, because I was with you.
It's also quite easy to understand why Jesus sometimes told people to remain silent about His miracles; sensationalism could actually hinder His ministry, so He occasionally took steps to avoid it. There's nothing "strange" about it. It was simply a matter of prudence.
[Quotes from NKJV]
Wiki User
∙ 8y ago
Jesus instructed his disciples not to tell others about the Transfiguration until after his resurrection because the full impact and understanding of his divinity needed to be revealed at the appropriate time. It was a pivotal moment in his ministry that needed to be kept secret until the right moment for the fulfillment of his mission.
Wiki User
∙ 8y agoJesus frequently instructed those He healed and also His disciples who witnessed the Transfiguration not to tell anyone because He did not want to be known as a miracle worker only. He also did not want His primary "business", spiritual healing, to be obscured by physical healings. He knew that if word spread about His supernatural power, many would come to Him for short term solutions to disease but miss long term solutions to sin. They would seek physical relief prior to and exclusive of the deeper needs of the soul. Keeping silent about His miracles and the Transfiguration would reduce sensational public acclaim and promote the God centered ministry Jesus wanted.
One of the purposes of the Transfiguration was to strengthen the faith of the disciples in the divine nature of Christ before they experienced the shock of the difficult days ahead. Peter never forgot it. It gave him a sense of certainty as he was facing his own martyrdom (2 Peter 1:14-18).
Wiki User
∙ 8y agoThis is the transfiguration, when Peter, James and John saw Jesus change his appearance and then saw him taking to Elijah and Moses.
There is no reason given in The Bible for this strange request. However, it is a feature of Mark's Gospel that Jesus asked people not to tell others, when they witnessed a miracle.
Another view, held by some scholars, is that if no one had heard about the transfiguration when Mark's Gospel was written, then the author's credibility might have been questioned. The author could avoid this by writing that the disciples, the only witnesses to the transfiguration, were warned by Jesus not to tell anyone else until after he had risen. Jesus' permission to tell others after the resurrection would then be seen as fulfilled by the gospel itself.
Wiki User
∙ 8y agoJesus took Peter, James and John up into a high mountain, where his appearance changed, and they saw him talking to two strangers. Somehow, the disciples knew without question that the strangers talking to Jesus were Moses and Elijah. Read literally, the sole reason for this journey was to let the three disciples see Jesus talking to Moses and Elijah, yet they learnt nothing from the experience and were even instructed to tell no one.
It is hard to imagine why Jesus would have given the three disciples this divine experience yet instruct them not to tell of it, when to do so would have helped spread the message of Jesus - just as the gospel account of the Transfiguration now helps spread the message of Jesus. Perhaps the reason the gospel story says that Jesus told the disciples to say nothing, is that the Transfiguration was unknown outside the gospels. Either the Transfiguration never happened as described in the gospels, or Jesus must have told the disciples not to tell anyone what they had seen.
Add your answer:
Earn +20 pts
Which two Old Testament characters appeared at the Transfiguration?
A:Jesus took Peter, James and John up into a high mountain, where his appearance changed, and they saw him talking to two strangers. Somehow, the disciples knew without question that the strangers talking to Jesus were Moses and Elijah. Why the disciples even thought the men were Moses and Elijah is not stated.
Which apostle reported that he was an eyewitness to the transfiguration of Jesus and that he heard the voice of God?
A:Jesus took Peter, James and John up into a high mountain, where his appearance changed. They saw him talking to two strangers, who the disciples knew without question were Moses and Elijah, and heard the voice of God. The Second Epistle of Peter indirectly reports this event (1:16-21), but scholars say that 2 Peter was certainly written during the second century, long after the death of Peter. As evidence of this, the epistle contains almost the entire text of the epistle known as Jude, which clearly identifies itself as a work of the second century. Regardless of the dating, it is not credible that Peter would have copied so much from another epistle. We are left to understand that the anonymous author of 2 Peter wrote from what he knew about the transfiguration from the gospels. Peter himself never reported that he had seen the Transfiguration.
Why did Jesus tell the three Apostles to keep quiet about what they had seen at the Transfiguration and what is the significance of this silence in Mark's Gospel?
Jesus instructed the Apostles to keep silent about the Transfiguration because the event revealed his divine nature and true identity as the Son of God, which was not meant to be fully disclosed until after his death and resurrection. The significance of this silence in Mark's Gospel highlights the theme of secrecy and the gradual unveiling of Jesus' identity throughout the narrative. It also emphasizes the disciples' lack of understanding and the need for them to witness the whole story before fully comprehending Jesus' mission.
What is the meaning of the Transfiguration?
The Transfiguration is an event in the Bible where Jesus' appearance changed and became radiant while speaking with Moses and Elijah. It is seen as a manifestation of Jesus' divine nature and a preview of his glory as the Son of God. The event emphasizes Jesus' role as the fulfillment of both the Law (represented by Moses) and the prophets (represented by Elijah).
Jesus told Nathanael that he had seen him before Where did Jesus see him?
Jesus saw Nathanael while he was under the fig tree before they physically met. This demonstrated Jesus's divine knowledge and ability to see beyond what is visible to others.
What are the name of mountains where Jesus taught?
Jesus took a few disciples to a mountain call Mount of Transfiguration. Where the two prophets of old prophet Elijah and prophet Moses were seen by the disciples.
What does Jesus say to the disciples as they descend the mountain and why is this significant during the transfiguration?
Mark 9:9 says that, as they came down from the mountain, Jesus charged the disciples that they tell no one what they had seen. The significance of his command is that, by keeping this command, no one could have told Mark or any other Gospel author of the transfiguration. Yet Mark claims to describe the transfiguration experience in detail.
What miracle did Jesus do in mount of transfiguration?
On the Mount of Transfiguration, Jesus was "transfigured," meaning that he was seen by the Apostles Peter, James and John in his glorified form, bright as the sun in blazingly white clothes. In this form, he spoke with Moses and Elijah, who also appeared there with Jesus. See Luke 9:28-36.
The number of times Jesus appeard to his disciples?
It is not told how many time he was seen by his disciples. Only events that relate to his teachings are recorded in scripture.
What events mark Jesus glorification?
On the Mount of the Transfiguration, where Jesus went with Peter, James, and John, Jesus was seen by them in his glorified state. He "glowed" like the sun. He was also seen speaking to Moses and Elijah, who both had been dead several hundred years.
What did the disciples do to show they cared for Jesus?
Jesus' disciples were His companions for three years, accompanying Him throughout His ministry. After they had witnessed the Resurrection, the disciples bore witness to what they had seen and knew - that Jesus was indeed risen from the dead and God's son. They preached this message until the end of their lives, endured persecution in His name, and wrote a record of what they had seen and heard. These writings became part of the New Testament.
When did Jesus command his disciples to be silent?
Jesus told his disciples on a couple of occasions to tell no man of what they had seen - as in - Then charged he his disciples that they should tell no man that he was Jesus the Christ. (Matthew 16.20) And - And as they came down from the mountain, Jesus charged them, saying, Tell the vision to no man, until the Son of man be risen again from the dead. (Matthew 17.9)
Who was seen by jesus under the fig tree?
Jesus saw his future disciple Barthalemow under a fig tree. His friend Philip (one of Jesus's 12 disciples) brought Bartholomew to Jesus.
What was the relationship between Jesus and Peter?
Jesus and Peter had a close relationship, with Peter being one of Jesus' original twelve disciples. Peter was often seen as a leader among the disciples and was known for his loyalty to Jesus, although he also famously denied knowing Jesus three times before the crucifixion. Jesus affirmed Peter as the rock on which he would build his church, showing the significance of their relationship in Christian tradition.
Sins of the disciples?
The disciples to sinned like all of us. Judas Iscariot betrayed Christ. Peter denied Jesus thrice. and Thomas doubted that it was the risen christ who the other s had seen.
Who was not with the other disciples when the risen Jesus appeared to his disciples?
[John 20:24] Thomas called Didymus aka Doubting Thomas because when the disciples told him they had seen Jesus, Thomas would not believe them unless he had tangible proof which he got 8 days later when Jesus reappeared.
How did Jesus react to the question who are you?
Jesus was asked if He was the Christ the Son of God by the High Priest at His trial. Jesus answered in the affirmative, adding that He would be seen coming in the clouds of Heaven. When John the Baptist sent his disciples to ask if Jesus was the Promised One, He referred to the prophecies from Isaiah and the miracles they had seen as demonstration of who He was.
