answersLogoWhite

0

It is a matter of opinion. Many children do not find such methods damaging in any lasting way, physical or psychological. Other people may find that as adults such ways of teaching have left them in some way traumatized. Keep in mind that the severity of the discipline forms a large part of each opinion.

One school of thought is that all violence - if you choose to define spanking as such - is unnecessary; better to teach with words. Learning occurs best in a relaxed environment, according to many studies, and fear of physical discipline cannot be said to be such.

On the other hand, some also say that humans, as animals, have evolved over time to learn from pain and observing consequences for actions. This is the same principle used in training dogs or cats successfully. It is true that our instincts mean that lessons are often taught through realizing that there are undesirable results of our actions - if we run with scissors and cut ourselves badly, we are unlikely to do it again or to ever forget the incident.

As far as major safety concerns go, keep in mind that children often do things more than once after being told not to do so. In cases where even one tryst with disobedience can mean injury or death, sometimes spanking is considered preferable to insure that they remember the next time that they should not do the dangerous action. It seems harsh to some, but others would argue that it is in the child's best interests.

User Avatar

Wiki User

14y ago

What else can I help you with?

Related Questions

Is corporal punishment considered abuse in the context of child discipline?

Yes, corporal punishment is considered abuse in the context of child discipline as it can cause physical and emotional harm to the child.


Is spanking your child with a belt illegal in Hawaii?

In Hawaii, it is not explicitly illegal to spank a child with a belt as a form of discipline. However, it is important to note that excessive or abusive physical discipline can still be considered child abuse under Hawaii law. Parents should always consider positive and non-violent discipline methods.


What are the titles of some parenting videos about the pros and cons of spanking?

Oh honey, there are plenty of videos out there discussing the pros and cons of spanking. Just search for titles like "Spanking: To Swat or Not?" or "The Great Spanking Debate: Discipline or Damage?" But remember, there's no one-size-fits-all approach to parenting, so take those videos with a grain of salt and use your own judgment.


What are the specific guidelines of spanking a child in South Carolina?

There are no specific laws concerning "spanking". However, any physical act either by use of an instrument or not that leaves bruises, abrasions, and so forth is considered physical abuse and if reported is subject to investigation by child protective services.


Can you leave a bruise when you spank your child in Florida show the law?

In Florida, spanking a child is generally considered a form of discipline, but it must be reasonable and not excessive. If spanking leaves a bruise or causes injury, it may be deemed abusive under Florida law, potentially leading to legal consequences. Florida Statute 39.01 defines abuse as "any willful act or threatened act that results in physical injury" to a child. Therefore, while some physical discipline is permitted, it should never result in harm.


What is wrong with spanking a bad boy?

Spanking a child as a form of discipline has been shown to have negative effects on their development and well-being. Research indicates that it can lead to increased aggression, mental health issues, and a strained parent-child relationship. It is important to use positive and effective discipline strategies, such as positive reinforcement and setting clear expectations, to promote healthy child development.


Is your child abusive?

It depends on the context and the child. In some cases, a slap could be considered spanking, and acceptable physical punishment. In other cases, a slap could fall outside the bounds of punishment and be considered abuse.


That kids are allowed to be hit?

if it is diciplenary by the child's parents yes(like spanking), but if it is parental abuse or abuse from any other person it is considered child abuse


What is the Florida law on spanking children?

Florida restricts all spanking as child abuse. Florida law states that any act that can physically or mentally hurt a child is considered child abuse and you can be charged with a felony for it.


Is slapping your child abusing?

Yes, slapping your child can be considered a form of physical abuse. It can cause emotional harm, lead to the child feeling fearful or insecure, and may erode trust between the child and parent. It's important to use positive discipline strategies that do not involve physical violence.


Is picking someone up considered physical abuse?

No, it is not considered physical abuse unless it is done in a rough manner that can leave bruises.


Is slapping a teenager and swearing at teenager abuse?

It is Verbal and Physical abuse. Verbal Abuse is considered with the swearing while the physical is the slapping.