What is a 1909 pennie worth?

Answer 1

Penny, not "pennie", and the coin is actually a cent.

There were several varieties of cent struck in 1909 and all have different values.

> 1909 Indian head; retail values from $8 to $15 depending on how worn it is.

> 1909 Indian head with a small "S" under the wreath; $450 to $750

> 1909 Lincoln cent with no letter under the date and no letters on the back at the 6:00 position - $2 to $5

> 1909 Lincoln cent with no letter under the date and the small letters V.D.B on the back at the 6:00 position - $7 to $11

> 1909 Lincoln cent with an "S" under the date and no letters on the back at the 6:00 position - $77 to $235

> 1909 Lincoln cent with an "S" under the date and the small letters V.D.B on the back at the 6:00 position - $720 to $1400