answersLogoWhite

0

Based on what the US Military is purchasing, the Mossberg 590A1. The total military order for Benelli M1014 shotguns is only 20k units, whereas in the past decade alone, the Navy submitted a contract for 2,200 to 7,500 Mossbergs starting in 2004, and the Army ordered 14,818 in 2005. The Winchester and Remington shotguns were phased out of service in 2005, and for the forseeable future, the Department of Defense will only be using the Mossberg for pump shotguns, as it is the only one to pass the DOD 3443 standards. While the pump lacks the rate of fire of a semi-auto, the semi-auto lacks the ability to easily handle the less-lethal ammunition types (rubber slugs, tear gas, the new TASER XREP 12 gauge round), which aren't powerful enough to cycle the gas action. The pump is also safer for door breaching, since it can be left hammer down on a fired shell and left dangling by the sling if the operator decides to transition to another weapon (handgun or carbine) after breaching the door.

Remington fans will claim that the 870 would pass the military's 3443 test easily, but as Remington never submitted a sample for testing (and the 3443 spec has been around since 1975), no one really knows.

References:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Benelli_M4_Super_90

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Combat_shotgun

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mossberg_500

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Remington_870

--scot

User Avatar

Wiki User

17y ago

What else can I help you with?

Related Questions

What is the best tactical shotgun?

The Benelli M4 Semi-Automatic, is the best tactical shotgun ever made in the history of firearms.It is the shotgun of choice for the US Marines, and had been tested in the most extreme conditions and has proven to be a solid performer under any circumstance.The 18.5" barrel is short enough to maneuver around some of the tightest corners and still comply with the law.It has a pistol grip which can help prevent an attacker from pulling the weapon out of your hands.Benelli is an Italian company dedicated to quality, service and performance.Other popular choices include the Mossberg 500 & Remington 870, these cannot even compare to the speed, quality, and performance of the Benelli M4. The M4 has no equal and will become your most trusted bedside companion.Except for the fact that the M4 still has problems cycling reduced loads. You have to brace yourself to make sure that a reduced load cycles properly. In a combat situation that is not always available. The Remington 870, while slower to cycle because it's a pump shotgun will cycle everytime no matter what load you are using. Also not to mention the nearly $1000 difference in price.While the Benelli M4 is amazing, it is not without its drawbacks. Until broken in, the action is too stiff to be used with less than lethal and light loads (I mean reallylight--stuff you really shouldn't be using for defense anyway). After shooting a couple hundred rounds through my Benelli, it will now happily spray 20 year old #7 birdshot without a hiccup.The Benelli is also much more expensive than, say, the venerable Remington 870. As a proud owner of both a Benelli m4 and a 14" Remington 870 I can say that both are superb. Both are ferocious home defense weapons.But since the question is which is thebest. I agree with the above response, the Benelli M4 is the finest tactical shotgun ever devised. If moneyis an object, however, a ghost ring sighted Remington 870 is a fine choice that will serve you well.


What is the basic combat load for the shotgun?

According to the Wikipedia article (though it is doubtful this is true) provided in the Related Links section, the Remington 1100 Tactical Shotgun, used in the military, holds a maximum of 8 12-guage rounds in the magizine.


What are some examples of a combat shotgun?

Combat shotguns have been around for a long time and early examples such as the Winchester range from the early 20th Century were very accurate over a long range. These have developed over the years and latest models such as the Remington range now have digital sights and extremely accurate long range capabilities


What shotgun starts with the letter n?

NeoStead 2000 (NS2000) - a combat shotgun developed by Truvelo Armoury of South Africa.


What are the features of an AAA 12 gun?

The feature of an AA 12 gun is known as Atchisson Asault Shotgun. It is a combat shotgun that can shoot in either selective fire, semi-automatic or fully automatic shotgun.


Which is better DC or Mortal Combat?

Mortal combat everybody can agree on that. Mortal Combat is more popular overall and I like it better, more characters and stuff.


What is better close combat or aura sphere?

ofcores is close combat


What companies manufacture ACR type rifles?

Bushmaster manufacturers the ACR rifle. It is an adaptive combat rifle. Remington manufacturers an ACR for military use. It is part of their Adaptive Combat System.


How do you get a combat shotgun on Fallout 3?

Combat Shotgun on Fallout 3if the time is low one of the tenpenny tower resedents has one slice his neck open :D and take it you probaly want to my more ammo from morea at megaton he only has 10 shells!


What is better range magic or combat on runescape?

obviously combat, because of strength!


What is better for rouge shadow or combat in crystal saga?

Shadow Rouge is better for PVP, Combat Rouge is better for PVE. So depends on what you wanna do more of.


Where could one purchase an AA 12 Shotgun?

An AA 12 Shotgun cannot be purchase legally. The AA 12 Shotgun is an automatic combat weapon. It fires at a relatively slow rate of 300 rounds per minute.