If one rents a retail property and a fire occurs who is liable for damages the tenant or the property owner?

already exists.

Would you like to merge this question into it?

already exists as an alternate of this question.

Would you like to make it the primary and merge this question into it?

exists and is an alternate of .

In Commercial Insurance, Foreclosure, London
Answer 1, Fire Liability It depends on whose fault it was. If the tenant started the fire via a cigarette, stove burner, candle left lit, or any other cause by the tenant, then the tenant is liable for all damages. If the fire is caused by the structural failure (i.e. electrical problem, gas leak) then the landlord is responsible for the damages. However, the landlord is not responsible for belongings that were inside. Renters insurance would take care of that and the insurance carrier would pay out such a claim. If the fire is caused by someone other than the tenant or landlord, then the landlord is responsible as well. However, property insurance will cover a landlord in most cases should the landlord not be found liable for the loss. A fire investigation will reveal what happened in the case of any fire. Answer 2, Additional Input I am forced to respectfully disagree with part of answer 1, which otherwise is very good.
In order to support my position, allow me to provide some of my qualifications. Before retirement, I spent two years as a Firefighter, and 25 years as an Investigator/Expert Witness/Consultant in the Origin and Cause of Fire/Arson/Explosion. I have worked WITH [both for and against] MOST of the major insurance carriers in the country.
Answer 1's statement--"If the fire is caused by the structural failue (i.e. electrical problem, gas leak) then the landlord is responsible for the damages."
This is not always true. Even though his liability insurance carrier MAY CHOOSE to accept liability AND PAY THE TENANT, the landlord is not actually liable UNLESS he was NEGLIGENT, AND DETERMINED SO IN A COURT OF LAW.
If the cause of the fire is something of which he was aware, or if it can be proved in court he should have been aware, then he COULD be found NEGLIGENT. If the cause was something he could not have forseen or prevented, then the chances are that a jury would find in his favor, not negligent, and not liable for tenant's damage.
The second statement with which I have to disagree is--"If the fire is caused by someone other than the tenant or landlord, then the landlord is responsible as well." This is unbelievable.
I will give a couple, of possibly hundreds, of examples of cases in which no jury on Earth would hold the landlord responsible and liable.
First, is an example which is not "conjured up," as I worked many such cases over the years, and it continues to occur.
Consider that a criminal parolee [already a two-time loser in a "three-strike" state] breaks into the business during the night. He "digs" through all the drawers, cabinets, cash register, etc. looking for the money most business keep there overnight. When it is time to leave, he realizes that he has left his fingerprints everywhere, and it would be impossible to "wipe" the entire place down.
A common solution many criminals use is to set the place on fire, thinking and hoping that his fingerprints will be destroyed. I just cannot believe that you, or any jury, would have the gall to hold the landlord responsible and liable.
Another type of case which I have seen more than once is that of a vehicle driver, having lost control, crashing into the building. Then, either the vehicle caught fire, or something inside the building caught fire. There is NO WAY the landlord should be determined to be either responsible or liable.
IF ANYONE DISAGREES WITH MY ANALYSIS, please add your analysis, WITH SUPPORTING examples, to this answer. I WILL continue to monitor this question/answer because I have to know how a landlord can be held responsible and liable for a third party's actions.
Could you answer me This? I am currently leasing a commercial building (currently at 3 years out of 7) The front office has just gone up in flames. The fire department was able to contain fire and the building was deemed safe to work in. it has now been 5 days and the landlord has come by to take pictures and notes of damage but has only said two words since the incident "good luck." now...here is my dilemma...i don't have renters insurance or General Liability. My business has suffered tremendously over the past year. i went from earning 200k a year for the past 10 years to living pay check to pay check. so insurance is no longer something i can afford. fire department has stated that "a unattended heater was the cause of fire on the west side of the office..." it is not a heater they see but a water cooler with hot and cold option.

I've had a electrician come by and take a look at the damages and without saying anything asked him to search for what he would believe is the cause. He also concluded it came from the water cooler but asked for me to purchase another similar cooler to determine if the cooler had a faulty surge protector. I've been unable to find the same model in water cooler and have now run out of ideas on what to do.

what would you suggest for me to do next? should i get another professional opinion? since i don't have insurance, should i offer to pay his liability deductible or pay out of pocket? if i was to seek another professional opinion on cause of fire, from who? is there such a dedicated profession? and if so, under what listing? this is my first incident and i feel so lost. Any help or direction would be greatly appreciated. thank you in advance.
Answer
I'm very sorry for your loss. It appears though (from your description) that you are liable for the damages. It would probably be a waste of time and money getting a third opinion since 2 have already agreed on the cause. I would suggest that you find a reasonable and reputable contractor to begin the repairs. If you can expedite repair of the damages, the landlord may opt not to sue you.
37 people found this useful

Is the homeowner or the tenant responsible for damages caused by a tree falling on a rented property?

\n. \n Liability for Fallen Tree \n. \nHomeowner's insurance would be the first recourse. If insurance does not cover the damages the owner of the property would be responsible.\n. \n. \n One Possible Exception \n. \nThe answer above is fundamentally accurate but the tenant is not autom… (MORE)

To whom do you owe rent if the owner of your property changes?

Answer . \nCheck your rental agreement with the first owner, first. See if it covers this situation and if so, how you would proceed. If it doesn't, then you would pay your rent to the new owner, but you should also request a new rental agreement and make very sure that your security deposit i… (MORE)

How can a tenant obtain insurance that covers damage his carelessness caused to the property he rents?

Answer . It's usually called a "Floater Policy." When renting you should always get a damage deposit from the tenant and if they leave your suite in ruins at least your insurance will pay for it. You have the right to give 24 hours notice to your tenant (by letter) stating that you will be ins… (MORE)

If you own property as tenants in common and will the foreclosure action of one owner show on the credit report of the other owner too?

Just the type of ownership will not affect whether the foreclosure action shows up on each owner's credit report or not. Almost anyone can be listed as an owner of a particular property; the bank will be most concerned with who signed for the loan as being responsible for paying the mortgage. If … (MORE)

Are you liable for a car damaged by a storm while on your property?

No, You would generally not be liable for Storm damage to a car while on your property. It is not customary to hold an individual legally liable for acts of nature that are beyond our control. Storm damage to a vehicle is generally covered under the Auto Owners Insurance Policy Comprehensive coverag… (MORE)

If only one of the four owners of a house lives there is he liable for the entire property tax?

In theory, all owners of the property are responsible for the property tax and it is up to them to agree how to divide the obligation among themselves. The tax authorities will post a tax lien on the property (regardless of who owns it) if the taxes are not paid, and attempt to notify the last kno… (MORE)

Is one flat in a block liable for damage caused to other properties eg. from fire leaks and would home contents insurance need to be at a high enough level to cover it?

Answer . It is possible that you can be held responsible for damages caused to other units if your actions or negligence somehow caused the fire/damage. For instance, maybe you were cooking and something caught on fire or maybe you accidently left your iron on one morning, and this caused a larg… (MORE)

Why does a tenant need property damage insurance?

Answer . Your land lord is not responsible for any damage to or loss of personal belongs. This is why you would want to get renters insurance.. Answer . The owner of the home should have it covered with "Home Owner's Insurance", which doesn't cover a tenant's belongings should there be a fire… (MORE)

Is a property owner liable to others if there is fire on the owned property and the automatic sprinklers activate and cause water damage to the property of others?

\nIt depends on how the lease is written. You may be liable if the damage was done as a result of actions caused by the landlord, and as such the landlord is responsible for the sprinkler system. However, you shold be covered under your insurance or better yet the other tenant should be covered unde… (MORE)

Damage to property cause owners neglect?

Property damage is covered by a property liability insurancepackage. This applies to all incidents in which an automobilecauses damage to another person's property such as a fence orhouse. If you do not have property liability insurance, the driveris responsible for covering the damages out of pocke… (MORE)

If a tree does property damage who is liable?

Mother Nature would be the liable party, Unfortunately, she does not carry insurance. If your property is insured, Then your property Insurance Policy will cover the cost of damage repairs.

Can an owner of property be held liable for a death where one died by drowning in a swimming pool?

Maybe. But be prepared to show how the property owner was negligent. An property owner is responsible to his guests or invitees to have reasonably safe conditions on his property. To win your case, there would have to be an unsafe condition at the pool that the owner should have known about or did k… (MORE)

Is a tenant liable for property damage if the landlord left an item in this case a bed frame on the property which the tenant started to use without permission and then broke?

Any item that was present at the time of rental or lease signing, if damaged, is to be repaired to the best ability of the tenant, or if repair is not possible, then the landlord is entitled to collect damages. Before the lease was signed, there should have been a "walk through" with the landlord or… (MORE)

If the primary owner is involved in an accident can the cosigner be held liable for personal or property damage?

I am not an attorney but to my understanding, yes they can!! The other party just has to prove your at fault. For instance, you co-signed which allowed the primary to get the vehicle which did the damage without you the primary couldn't of gotten the loan and therefore it is your fault. The only way… (MORE)

Renting out a property -what do you have to know about the new tenants?

Well, you as a landlord can learn as much as you want, or as little as you want, because as a landlord you can basically rent to whomever you want. That being said you have the right to limit, to a certain degree, the scope of renters, such as convicted felons or registered sex offenders, especially… (MORE)

Are you covered under your home owner policy for renting your property?

No. You are required to notify your Insurance Company whenever you rent out your property to others. . The policy is required to be endorsed as "Tenant Occupied" and additional premium is most often collected due to the increased risks associated with the rental. . Failure to notify your insurer w… (MORE)

Do a tenant have to pay rent in a foreclosure property?

Tenants do have to pay their landlords even if the property is under foreclosure - until the foreclosing agency or entity takes total control of the property. When this happens they become the landlord, to which the rent is due accordingly. Whichever landlord has controlled the property can still co… (MORE)

What if someone is hurt on your property but you have someone renting it who is liable?

The person who was hurt will undoubtedly be able to find a lawyer willing to argue that you are liable. And that the renter is liable. And that the descendents of the person who originally sold you the house are liable, as are their mechanics, hairdressers, and employers.. The point is this: you sh… (MORE)

How much time do you have when an owner files bankruptcy on the property you rent?

If a landlord files for bankruptcy, the answer depends on whether it is a Chapter 13 or a Chapter 7 (or possibly a Chapter 11, which would be the same as a 13 for this purpose). In a C, 13, the landlord would be entitled to continue to collect rent and be responsible for maintaining the property an… (MORE)

Is the property management company required to tell the property owner if a tenant commits suicide?

Unless it is in the contract or required by law, the property management company is probably not required to tell the property owner if a tenant commits suicide. However, common sense and protection from possible liability would recommend that action. A death would have occurred on that piece of pro… (MORE)

Can a tenant insured rented property?

Usually your renter's policy covers whatever you bring into the property that does not become a permanent part of the property. Your renter's policy cannot cover property that belongs to the landlord.

Can a tenant who is renting from an owner of a condo be allowed to be at the homeowner assoc meetings to express his concerns about the property managers?

All communication to the board from a tenant must be made throughthe owner. It is possible for the owner to grant the tenant a limited 'powerof attorney' to represent the owner at a board meeting. The owneris best advised to craft this document through acommon-interest-community-savvy attorney. Wit… (MORE)

Who is liable for accidents in a rented property the property owner or the tenant?

Depends on why the accident happened and where. If the owner created a risk, then the landlord would be liable. If the tenant created the risk or failed to notify the owner of the risk, then the tenant may be liable, unless the accident happened outside of the area rented to the tenant (e.g., a comm… (MORE)

Who is supposed to bear the sinking fund tenant or owner of the property?

As a best practice, the rent your charge should be enough to allow for 5-10% to be dumped monthly into your sinking fund. If you have a single renter property, then it might be practical to seed the fund yourself with a few hundred dollars at the beginning of the year to keep your rental price compe… (MORE)

Is Section 8 responsible for tenant damage to real property?

HUD and the housing authority are not directly responsible for any damages caused by its client tenants. If the tenant damages property, you have the right to evict him just as you would any other tenant. If you take the tenant to court and win the eviction, the tenant will lose his voucher permanen… (MORE)

Can a property management company tell the tenant that they are the owners in fee of a property if they are not the fee owners?

There is nothing to prevent a property management company from lying about the ownership of the property, as long as that does not contribute to a fraud. It is not uncommon for a fee owner of rental properties to hire a property manager and grant it power to represent the owner and manage the prop… (MORE)

Who is responsible for the damages in case of accidental fire that start in one property but damages the neighbor?

The one that they determined caused the fire will be #1. Theproperty one owner if not involved is as much a victim as propertytwo owner. The liability will fall on the one who is responsablefor letting the fire get away and if none is determined each ownerhas a accidental fire claim to file with thi… (MORE)

Where can one rent property in London?

You can get rental properties in Bayswater, Paddington, Hyde Park, Marylebone, Fitzrovia, Mayfair, Notting Hill, Regents Park and the West End areas of Central London. Through proper estate agent finding properties in London is quite tough. There are many reliable estate agents available. Kay & Co… (MORE)