What does 'shouting fire in a crowded theater' mean?

already exists.

Would you like to merge this question into it?

already exists as an alternate of this question.

Would you like to make it the primary and merge this question into it?

exists and is an alternate of .

The phrase refers to a quote from Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes, Jr.'s opinion in the case Schenck v. United States, 249 US 47 (1919), a Supreme Court case that explored the limits of First Amendment protection of free speech.

The exact quote is: "The most stringent protection of free speech would not protect a man in falsely shouting fire in a theatre and causing a panic."

Holmes point was that there is no absolute right of free speech, because there are always circumstances in which unregulated expression can create problematic or dangerous situations. The need for safeguarding the public (or, in the case of Schenck, the government) against certain forms of speech creates exceptions that are not protected by the First Amendment. "Falsely shouting fire in a theatre" is an example illustrating Holmes' point.

Another quote from Schenck that further clarifies the Court's position: "Words which, ordinarily and in many places, would be within the freedom of speech protected by the First Amendment may become subject to prohibition when of such a nature and used in such circumstances a to create a clear and present danger that they will bring about the substantive evils which Congress has a right to prevent. The character of every act depends upon the circumstances in which it is done."

The "clear and present danger" test became the standard against which exercise of certain First Amendment rights were measured. The Court later relaxed these restrictions in a series of cases that culminated in the current restriction, defined in Bradenburg v. Ohio, 395 US 444 (1969). In Bradenburg, the Court held a person could not be punished for using offensive or infammatory language, but only by inciting "imminent lawless action," with "lawlessness" being a likely outcome of the speech.

In the Per Curiam opinion for Bradenburg, the Court wrote: "These later decisions have fashioned the principle that the constitutional guarantees of free speech and free press do not permit a State to forbid or proscribe advocacy of the use of force or of law violation except where such advocacy is directed to inciting or producing imminent lawless action and is likely to incite or produce such action."

Justice William O. Douglas concurred, repeating another quote from Justice Holmes: "The question in every case is whether the words used are used in such circumstances and are of such a nature as to create a clear and present danger that they will bring about the substantive evils that Congress has a right to prevent. It is a question of proximity and degree."
22 people found this useful

Can a person be prosecuted for yelling fire in a crowded building when there is no fire?

Answer Yes, it's called Reckless Endangerment. When you make an action like that intentionally and knowing that there is no such danger, it encourages an action in the crowd that you would have probable reason to suspect panic. People get injured in panics. To put people in danger knowingly and w (MORE)

How not to get shouted at?

I suppose that from the moment you act and talk with respect, promote truth & harmony instead of injustice, it's all entirely to the others. Although you should make an effort to understand the reasons behind their behaviours (education, past and present experiences), always remember that you cannot (MORE)

Fires fatal gunshot in fords theater?

On Good Friday April 14, 1965 while watching a play at Ford'sTheater Abraham Lincoln was assassinated by a gunshot wound to thehead. The person who fired the fatal shot was John Wilkes Booth.

Which words did the crowds shout as Jesus entered Jerusalem?

John 12: . 12 On the next day much people that were come to the feast, when they heard that Jesus was coming to Jerusalem, 13 Took branches of palm trees, and went forth to meet him, and cried, Hosanna: Blessed is the King of Israel that cometh in the name of the Lord..

What does it mean dreaming of a crowd of people?

The crowd of people in your dream represents the many differentfacets of yourself. The different individuals in the crowd are alldifferent parts of your own complicated life: you as student; youas daughter or son; you a friend; you as a person of faith; you asa musician, artist or scholar, etc. If t (MORE)

What does Give a shout mean?

To communicate with someone informally, by phoning them or visiting them. So instead of saying "If you need me, call me" you could say "If you need me, give me a shout."

What is theater and what does it mean to you?

Theater is a way to express yourself by acting. By using your role and charteristics of that character, you can express yourself by using what you know or have experienced about it. You show in your perspective of the role how you would have done it. You express it in your own way.

What does Two's Company Three's a Crowd mean?

The saying "two's company, three's a crowd" refers to the phenomenon which can happen when a third person joins a group but doesn't really mesh with one of the other two. For example, if A and B are best friends, then B's boyfriend C turns up, A will feel awkward. "A" will feel like a "third wheel". (MORE)

What does it mean when someone says your shout?

It means it's your turn to buy a round of drinks. Australian slang. "It's my shout" = It's my turn to buy a round of drinks. Presumably because one will shout to get the bartender's attention. If someone says "Your shout, mate" head immediately to the bar and buy a round or a pitcher of beer.

What does crowding out mean?

\nIncreased government spending results in higher interest rates which puts downward pressure on investment spending.

How was the globe theater set on fire?

In 1613, shakespeare performed a play in the globe about Henry vIII. Sparks which flew from the cannon they were using ignited with the thatched roof- this started the fire. Fortunately, the globe was rebuilt with a tile roof and reopened a year later in 1614.

What year was the globe theater fire?

The Globe Theater was originally built in 1599. It was destroyed by fire on June 29, 1613. It was rebuilt in the same spot by June of 1614. It was then closed down in 1642 by the Puritans.

What is the mean the loose cannon in the crowd?

A "loose cannon" is someone who gets upset or angry easily, and who acts without thinking. So in a crowd of people the loose cannon would be the one who gets upset and starts something--maybe just yelling, or maybe violence.

Meaning of don't shout and wave it about?

are you thinking bout the hokie pokie or sumtin? . cuz if u are its put your _________in and shake it all about.. . if your not.. . then they probably want you to be quiet and just start dancing:* . i dont know

Was the fire at the globe theater by accident?

Yes, the burning of the Globe Theatre is was an accident. TheGlobe Theatre was burnt down as the result of a misfiring of acannon, that was likely used in the production of Henry VIII.

If you shout does it mean that you are right?

No. It may mean that you have a weak argument or point to make so you need to boost it by shouting. It could also mean you are in the company of rude people who are not listening. Shouting brings everyone down to a lower level. It is better to arrange an environment where you can speak softly and be (MORE)

Why can you not shout fire In a theater?

You can if there is a fire, but if you shout fire when there isn't one, raising a false alarm, people will dial 911, everything will turn into chaos and people could be injured. You could be sued for any damage or injuries, if not charged with several crimes.

What defense if any does one have for yelling fire in a crowded theater?

Well, there are a few ways, but I've narrowed it down to two, very usable, ideas. - You can act as though you legitimately thought there was a fire. - You can play it off as though it was a bet. Both will more thank likely work, but it's still not a good idea. People will become genuinely fright (MORE)

When was it unlawful to yell fire in a theater?

It was made illegal in the Supreme Court case Schenk v. United States in 1919. The court case was more tailored to talk and advocating Communism, using the "fire in a crowded theatre" idea as an analogous figurative statement, but that's when the phrase was coined and made unlawful.

What did the crowd shout when Jesus entered Jerusalem?

A: Mark 11:9: " And they that went before, and they that followed, cried, saying, Hosanna; Blessed be he that cometh in the name of the Lord. " These are the words of the Jewish Succoth, which Mark seems to have transferred from autumn to the Passover season for the procession story. John Shelby S (MORE)

When is hunger games Catching Fire in theaters?

Catching Fire hits theathers in Novemember 21,2013 Jennifer, josh, and Liam will reprise their roles in the films. Reprise as in come back. Oh and Mockingjay will be split into two movies. part one in Novemember 21, 2014 and part two on Novemeber 20,2015 it's a long wait but it's worth the wait righ (MORE)

When will Catching Fire be in theaters?

Catching Fire will be coming to theaters on November 21st in the following countries: . Argentina . Hong Kong . Italy Catching Fire will be premiering on November 22nd, 2013 in the following countries: . Australia . Denmark . Ireland . Sweden . United Kingdom . United States It w (MORE)

Why can't you shout fire in a theatre?

I'm going to pretend this is a serious question, because I'm really not sure. You can't shout "FIRE" in a theatre or any crowded area. This will cause unnecessary panic and a mob to be created. People could get seriously injured in such a scenario. Additionally, they'll miss out on their movie :( (MORE)

When is Catching Fire coming to theaters?

If I'm not mistaken, it comes out on November the 22 or the 20th 2013. All I know is that it is gonna be a while till it will be coming to theaters. :(. Hope this helped! :)

What does the word crowd mean?

The word 'crowd' has about 5 definitions. The definitions arebelow: 1. a large number of persons gathered closely together; a crowdof angry people. 2. any large number of persons. 3. any group or set of persons with something in common; Therestaurant attracts a theater crowd. 4. au (MORE)

What is crowded mean?

it means there is a lot of people in an area like maybe on black Friday the stores where crowded

What does mean to dream your sister shouting?

Shouting in a dream is pretty straight forward to interpret. Thisis an expression of a need to communicate anger or urgency. Thefact that it is your sister in the dream does not necesarily meanyou sister is angry with you. In fact it may indicate just theopposite, as it is believed that all charactu (MORE)

What does someone shouting at you in a dream mean?

It could mean that you are stressed or nervous. On a symbolic level, the person shouting at you represents you, yourself. This is your own (unconscious) mind trying to tell you something. You may be making a serious mistake, such as falling into a deadly addiction or becoming involved in a toxic (MORE)

What was the cause of the Chicago Iroquois theater fire?

They said the cause of the fire was from a gas ceiling lamp thatwas not yet constructed but still use for the stage performance-thelight somehow ignited the stage curtain. Eddie Foy (a famouscomedian) ordered the curtain to be pulled down, the curtainsnagged and somehow caused the whole building to (MORE)

What is shouting?

shouting is a verb. It is the present participle form of shout. Shout means to talk very loudly