War of 1812
Known at the time as ‘Madison's war’ after the US president who prosecuted it so badly. This war was a failed attempt by the young USA to seize Canada while Britain was engaged fighting Napoleon in Europe. It might better have been called ‘the Republicans' war’, for it was this party, and in particular the ‘war hawks’ who dominated the House of Representatives thanks to the leadership of Henry Clay of Kentucky, that most wanted it. It was remarkable in that the alleged reason for the war, the British Orders in Council designed to counter Napoleon's Continental System, had been repealed before the USA declared war, and the principal victory won by American arms, by Andrew Jackson at New Orleans in January 1815, was won after peace terms had been agreed. Many attribute this to slow communications, but what the episodes underline is that the US government was determined on war in 1812 and desperate for peace in 1815. It is, finally, a classic illustration of the principle of political economy that wars are fought to increase the domestic power of those who wage it, because the Republicans, while achieving none of their stated war objectives, decisively won the political battle with their opponents the Federalists.
The flashpoint was the stopping of US shipping by the Royal Navy, allegedly to recover deserters but actually impressment by captains desperate for seamen, as they always were—there were five sailors admitted to be American on board HMS Victory at Trafalgar, as there were French, Spanish, Dutch, Danish, and Italian, and we may be sure that few of them were there voluntarily. Thus it was fitting that the war was decided at sea by an imperfect blockade that nonetheless strangled US commerce, bankrupting among others ex-president Thomas Jefferson, who was in many ways the grandfather of the war. He it was who reversed the prudent policy of accommodation with the ocean-dominating British that permitted US exports to treble 1794-1801, who rejected a British offer of what would now be called ‘most favoured nation’ status in 1806 and imposed his own ‘continental system’ that had no significant impact on Britain but reduced US exports from $108 million in 1807 to $22 million in 1808.
On paper it was no contest. The USA had a population of about 7.5 million and a regular army of 12, 000 against 500, 000 and less than 7, 000 in Canada. Her navy, now with seven ‘super frigates’ that outgunned their British equivalents, had acquitted itself well in an undeclared naval war with the French in 1794-1801, the national debt was minuscule thanks to the Federalists, and her flanks were covered. Indeed the one territorial gain to come from the war was West Florida, acquired by sending in agents to proclaim independence from Spain and then request US protection, a technique that also nearly worked in Texas in 1813. This was part of Secretary of State Monroe's forward policy in the matter of western expansion, later to be called ‘manifest destiny’. The USA had ample supplies of powder and two efficient arsenals at Harpers Ferry and Springfield. What it did not have was functional systems of recruitment or supply, the former based on short-term volunteers because of the collapse of the militia and the latter based on notably corrupt contracts with sutlers who added insult to injury by providing short-weight and condemned food to troops already restive because their inadequate pay was invariably months in arrears. Additionally, since 1808 they had been fighting a guerrilla war with Indian tribes loosely confederated by the great Shawnee chief Tecumseh. Although the westerners blamed them for this uprising, in fact one of the greatest lost opportunities of the war was that the British once again failed to exploit the usefulness of Indian allies as systematically as they easily could have.
This does not mean that the role of the Indians was minor; to the contrary, both in the battles along the Canadian border and in tying down US troops all along the western frontier their contribution ensured that the land war started very badly for the USA. A three-pronged invasion of Canada ended with the surrender of armies at Detroit, Frenchtown, and Queenston, while the capitulation of Fort Dearborn was followed by a massacre of the defenders by the Potawatomi, who had some scores to settle. By contrast, the war at sea went spectacularly well, with USS Constitution sinking HMS Guerrière and HMS Java, and the USS United States capturing HMS Macedonian. The US navy also took 50 merchant ships, while privateers took a further 450. As both Theodore Roosevelt and Mahan were later to point out in their outstanding studies of the war, the python-like effect of British sea power was slow to make itself felt, but even so 150 of the fast commerce raiders were taken, writing on the wall for those who could read it.
The year 1813 saw a more sober US strategy of winning control of the Great Lakes, the key to their defeats of the previous year. A US force took York (modern Toronto) and Newark, looted them, and burned the government buildings, something they were to regret. In September under Cdre Perry they won by far the most significant naval engagement of the war against a British flotilla of equal strength on Lake Erie, enabling them to reverse the land results of the previous year. Two British invasions of Ohio failed and at the battle of the Thames east of Detroit, the Americans caught up with the retreating Anglo-Indian army and trounced it, killing (and skinning) Tecumseh, who had earlier suggested that the British commander should wear petticoats. Elsewhere skirmishing characterized by incompetence when not treasonable corruption left the British controlling much of the frontier.
In the south, with little assistance from the British save for the use of Pensacola as a base of operations for escaped slaves and Indians, later to be called Seminoles, some of the Creek people fought their own war 1813-14 until Andrew Jackson instilled some order in the militia rabble under his command by executing one of them, and destroyed the Creeks at Horseshoe Bend in March 1814. Among those under his command were Crockett and Sam Houston, later heroes of Texas independence.
But 1813 had witnessed the turning point at sea, with the British sailing in convoys and sending several new squadrons, one of which ravaged the Chesapeake Bay area. The blockade began to bite and unleashed violent inflation in the USA, while the commander of the USS Chesapeake chose to accept a challenge to single combat by HMS Shannon, which unknown to him had been up-gunned, and was defeated and killed in a 15-minute engagement. The USS Essex was also tracked down and captured in the Pacifics after a very successful year of commerce-raiding, but it was the privateers who kept the stars and stripes on the high seas, boldly sailing around the British Isles and capturing merchant ships by the hundred and even defeating the occasional small warship.
With the abdication of Napoleon in April 1814, the British were able to release more ships and regular troops for the war in America, their numbers rising to about 40, 000. But the US army was able to match these numbers and, under the pressure of war, had shed incompetent commanders and promoted able ones such as Winfield Scott who, although he was nearly killed at Lundy's Lane in July, had drilled his men so well that they fought the British regulars to a standstill. Things went less well elsewhere, with a punitive amphibious operation in the Chesapeake returning the favour for Newark and York by burning Washington and then bombarding Baltimore. More significant was the capture of eastern Maine and the unilateral surrender of a number of New England islands and ports, which were delighted to be able to resume trade in exchange for swearing an oath of allegiance to the crown or otherwise betraying their country. US public finance had collapsed and the Royal Navy, paying in cash, was better able to supply itself from American farmers and merchants than were the US forces offering promissory notes.
The peace negotiations at Ghent that ran from August until Christmas Eve 1814 were a game of bluff and counter-bluff. Wellington, asked to command the forces in America, put his finger on the loss of control of the Great Lakes as the Achilles' heel of the British position, so naturally the British mounted their last big offensive in the south under the command of his brother-in-law Pakenham, who launched a frontal attack across a river and into field fortifications manned by men who could shoot, and was killed along with 1, 500 of his men (a further 500 surrendered) at the battle of New Orleans on 8 January 1815. On 21 February the last men to die in the war were the ringleaders of a mutiny by Tennessee militia in September the previous year, shot by the implacable Jackson, although by that time Congress had hastily ratified the Treaty of Ghent, which restored the status quo ante bellum.
Bibliography
- Hickey, Donald R., The War of 1812: A Short History (Urbana, Ill., 1995)
— Hugh Bicheno
