answersLogoWhite

0


Want this question answered?

Be notified when an answer is posted

Add your answer:

Earn +20 pts
Q: Can Taylor and Fayol's approach to management be reconciled?
Write your answer...
Submit
Still have questions?
magnify glass
imp
Continue Learning about Management

Compare management theory by fw Taylor and Henry fayol?

Henry Fayol treated management as its own discipline and used a systemic approach to analyze the process. Frederick Winslow Taylor applied scientific methods to management to reduce the wasting of resources.


What are the contributions of Fredrick Taylor to the management theory?

Frederick Taylor was the father of scientific management theory. His contributions include the application of engineering and scientific knowledge in management.


Who developed Scientific Management?

Frederick Taylor


Why Henri Fayol is called father of modern management theory?

Fayol has been described as the father of modern operational management theory (George, p. 146). Although his ideas have become a universal part of the modern management concepts, some writers continue to associate him with Frederick Winslow Taylor. Taylor's scientific management deals with the efficient organisation of production in the context of a competitive enterprise that has to control its production costs. That was only one of the many areas that Fayol addressed. Perhaps the connection with Taylor is more one of time, than of perspective. According to Claude George (1968), a primary difference between Fayol and Taylor was that Taylor viewed management processes from the bottom up, while Fayol viewed it from the top down. George's comment may have originated from Fayol himself. In the classic General and Industrial Management Fayol wrote that "Taylor's approach differs from the one we have outlined in that he examines the firm from the "bottom up." He starts with the most elemental units of activity-the workers' actions-then studies the effects of their actions on productivity, devises new methods for making them more efficient, and applies what he learns at lower levels to the hierarchy...(Fayol, 1987, p. 43)." He suggests that Taylor has staff analysts and advisors working with individuals at lower levels of the organization to identify the ways to improve efficiency. According to Fayol, the approach results in a "negation of the principle of unity of command" (p. 44). Fayol criticized Taylor's functional management in this way. "… the most marked outward characteristics of functional management lies in the fact that each workman, instead of coming in direct contact with the management at one point only, … receives his daily orders and help from eight different bosses…" (Fayol, 1949, p. 68.) Those eight, Taylor said, were (1) route clerks, (2) instruction card men, (3) cost and time clerks, (4) gang bosses, (5) speed bosses, (6) inspectors, (7) repair bosses, and the (8) shop disciplinarian (p. 68). - [1] - This, Fayol said, was an unworkable situation, and that Taylor must have somehow reconciled the dichotomy in some way not described in Taylor's works


Who created scientific management?

Frederick Winslow Taylor is the author and not the creator of the scientific management. Scientific management was one of the earliest attempts to apply science to the engineering of processes and to management.

Related questions

Who is credited with pioneering the principles of the scientific approach to management?

Frederick Winslow Taylor


Compare management theory by fw Taylor and Henry fayol?

Henry Fayol treated management as its own discipline and used a systemic approach to analyze the process. Frederick Winslow Taylor applied scientific methods to management to reduce the wasting of resources.


How did Frederick Taylor contribute to modern management?

what is the contributions of Frederick Taylor in the field of management


What is the difference between Taylor and fayol?

The difference between Taylor and Fayol are the management strategies applied. Taylor makes use of scientific management while Fayol makes use of administrative management.


What does the a in the taylor made a wedge stand for?

approach


What did Weber add to the principles of Fayol?

Classical school of public administration includes scientific management and bureaucratic theory. Fayol (and Taylor) is representative of scientific management and top down approach. Weber is presenting bureaucratic theory - with his ideal types.


Discuss the various main elements of taylor's scientific management?

Elements of F W Taylor's Scientific Management?


What are the contributions of Fredrick Taylor to the management theory?

Frederick Taylor was the father of scientific management theory. His contributions include the application of engineering and scientific knowledge in management.


Who developed Scientific Management?

Frederick Taylor


What did critics of Winslow Taylor's scientific management have to say?

Taylor and his followers were criticized on the grounds that scientific management tended to exploit workers more than it benefited them.


What has the author W B Taylor written?

W. B. Taylor has written: 'The management of assets'


Why Henri Fayol is called father of modern management theory?

Fayol has been described as the father of modern operational management theory (George, p. 146). Although his ideas have become a universal part of the modern management concepts, some writers continue to associate him with Frederick Winslow Taylor. Taylor's scientific management deals with the efficient organisation of production in the context of a competitive enterprise that has to control its production costs. That was only one of the many areas that Fayol addressed. Perhaps the connection with Taylor is more one of time, than of perspective. According to Claude George (1968), a primary difference between Fayol and Taylor was that Taylor viewed management processes from the bottom up, while Fayol viewed it from the top down. George's comment may have originated from Fayol himself. In the classic General and Industrial Management Fayol wrote that "Taylor's approach differs from the one we have outlined in that he examines the firm from the "bottom up." He starts with the most elemental units of activity-the workers' actions-then studies the effects of their actions on productivity, devises new methods for making them more efficient, and applies what he learns at lower levels to the hierarchy...(Fayol, 1987, p. 43)." He suggests that Taylor has staff analysts and advisors working with individuals at lower levels of the organization to identify the ways to improve efficiency. According to Fayol, the approach results in a "negation of the principle of unity of command" (p. 44). Fayol criticized Taylor's functional management in this way. "… the most marked outward characteristics of functional management lies in the fact that each workman, instead of coming in direct contact with the management at one point only, … receives his daily orders and help from eight different bosses…" (Fayol, 1949, p. 68.) Those eight, Taylor said, were (1) route clerks, (2) instruction card men, (3) cost and time clerks, (4) gang bosses, (5) speed bosses, (6) inspectors, (7) repair bosses, and the (8) shop disciplinarian (p. 68). - [1] - This, Fayol said, was an unworkable situation, and that Taylor must have somehow reconciled the dichotomy in some way not described in Taylor's works