answersLogoWhite

0


Best Answer

Yes, a deductive argument can have false premises. However, the conclusion does not follow logically if the premises are false, making the argument unsound.

User Avatar

AnswerBot

3h ago
This answer is:
User Avatar

Add your answer:

Earn +20 pts
Q: Can a deductively argument have false premises?
Write your answer...
Submit
Still have questions?
magnify glass
imp
Continue Learning about Philosophy

Deductively sound arguments are also deductively valid?

Yes, deductively sound arguments are deductively valid. A deductively valid argument is one where it is impossible for the premises to be true and the conclusion false. If the argument is deductively valid and the premises are also true, then the argument is sound.


A valid argument can have a false conclusion True or False?

True. A valid argument can have a false conclusion if the premises logically lead to that conclusion even though it is not true. Validity in logic refers to the structure of the argument, regardless of the truth or falsity of the premises or conclusion.


Can strong argument have false premises?

Yes, a strong argument can have false premises. Even if the premises are false, if the reasoning that leads from them to the conclusion is sound and persuasive, the argument may still be strong in terms of its structure and validity. However, it's important to strive for accuracy and truthfulness in the premises for a more reliable argument.


Can a sound argument have a false conclusion?

A sound argument cannot have a false conclusion. A sound argument refers to a deductive argument which is valid and has all true premises, therefore its conclusion cannot be false.


A true conclusion cannot be derived validly from false premises?

That's correct. The validity of an argument depends on both the form of the argument and the truth of the premises. If the premises are false, then even if the argument is logically valid, the conclusion cannot be considered true.

Related questions

What is deductively valid argument?

A deductively valid argument is if the premises are true then the conclusion is certainly true, not possibly true. The definition does not say that the conclusion is true.


What is deductive validity?

A deductively valid argument is if the premises are true then the conclusion is certainly true, not possibly true. The definition does not say that the conclusion is true.


A valid argument can have a false conclusion True or False?

True. A valid argument can have a false conclusion if the premises logically lead to that conclusion even though it is not true. Validity in logic refers to the structure of the argument, regardless of the truth or falsity of the premises or conclusion.


Can a sound argument have a false conclusion?

A sound argument cannot have a false conclusion. A sound argument refers to a deductive argument which is valid and has all true premises, therefore its conclusion cannot be false.


What will the The truth table for a valid deductive argument show?

The truth table for a valid deductive argument will show that when the premises are true, the conclusion is also true. It will demonstrate that the argument follows the rules of deductive logic and the conclusion necessarily follows from the premises.


What are the three argument types?

The three argument types are ethos, logos, and pathos. Ethos refers to establishing credibility and trustworthiness, logos involves using logic and reasoning to persuade, and pathos involves appealing to emotions to make a connection with the audience.


Deductively sound arguments are also deductively valid?

Yes, deductively sound arguments are deductively valid. A deductively valid argument is one where it is impossible for the premises to be true and the conclusion false. If the argument is deductively valid and the premises are also true, then the argument is sound.


How Can a strong inductive argument have a false conclusion?

A strong inductive argument can have a false conclusion if the premises are not relevant to the conclusion, even though they may seem to provide strong support. This can happen if there is a flaw in the reasoning or if there is a hidden assumption that is not valid. Strong inductive arguments should have premises that are actually connected to the conclusion in order for the argument to be valid.


Can strong argument have false premises?

Yes, a strong argument can have false premises. Even if the premises are false, if the reasoning that leads from them to the conclusion is sound and persuasive, the argument may still be strong in terms of its structure and validity. However, it's important to strive for accuracy and truthfulness in the premises for a more reliable argument.


What are Truth Validity and Soundness?

Truth refers to a statement that accurately reflects reality, validity refers to a logical relationship between the premises and conclusion in an argument, and soundness refers to an argument that is valid and has true premises.


What is argument validity?

Argument validity refers to the property of a deductive argument when the conclusion logically follows from the premises. In valid arguments, if the premises are true, then the conclusion must also be true. Validity does not guarantee the truth of the conclusion, only that the conclusion is well-supported by the premises.


Can an argument with a true premises and true conclusion be invalid?

Yes, an argument with true premises and a true conclusion can still be invalid if the conclusion does not logically follow from the premises. Invalidity concerns the structure of the argument rather than the truth of the statements involved.