Top Answer
User Avatar
Wiki User
2010-10-25 12:12:10
2010-10-25 12:12:10

Both were very oriented towards getting glory. Achilles' only reason for going to Troy is to enhance his own glory. Beowulf is not quite as direct about this, but the value of glory and fame in his society suggests that glory was very important for him as well. Beowulf is perhaps a little bit more selfless, in that he is also helping out a small kingdom. Achilles does not care much about the Greeks, as he wishes for them to do poorly just to beg him to come back. This wish of his results in the deaths of many Greeks, including his best friend Patroclus.

Both heroes have a final enemy, though Beowulf has two, and even three if you consider the dragon at the end. In Beowulf, the story centers around his upcoming battle with Grendel and then gives us the bonus of his battle with Grendel's mother. The dragon at the end almost seems like an afterthought, and gives Beowulf the glory of dying nobly.

Achilles's final enemy is Hector, whom he beats about as easily as Beowulf beats Grendel. The ease of their victories shows the authors of these works trying to demonstrate how vastly superior these men were. These days, we like difficult struggles to prove our heroes' worth. Back then, a hero had little trouble dispatching his enemies.

Having said this, Beowulf DOES struggle to kill Grendel's mother, but even here, his victory is assured.

Both men were not kings when they did the deeds they are most famous for. Achilles is a prince, since his father Peleus is still alive. I am sorry, but I do not know Beowulf's actual status when he fights Grendel, but he does not become a king until later in the story.

Beowulf does not have the companion that Achilles has (Patroclus). Nor does he have any of Achilles' anger. This is a very big difference between the two. As I said before, both men are fueled by pride and glory, but Achilles later becomes fueled by vengeance over the slaying of his friend Patroclus. This leads Achilles to fight his biggest enemy, Hector. Beowulf does not have the anger motivation.

Last thought, Achilles dies in a fairly poor way. He is shot in the heel by Paris. I believe he is killed this way because no mortal being can kill him in hand to hand combat. The poets needed to kill him though, to make his story more tragic. No hero wants to die this way. Beowulf, on the other hand, dies fighting a dragon, which is probably one of the coolest ways to die in his culture. Beowulf's death is definitely better than Achilles. You could argue that his character is too, as he is motivated by glory and the eagerness to help, and not glory and rage.


Related Questions

How does Humbaba compare/contrast with the monster figures in the Beowulf epic

When you can not contrast or compare.

Compare and contrast it with what?

Both were very hard to originally translate

you could, but it would be foolish: they are quite different. Beowulf is all mystical, while cantubry tales is actually rather down to earth.

Well, there has to be some purpose :] In a compare and contrast essay you compare and contrast the different aspects of a topic!

compare is when you compare two things that are the same and contrast is when you compare two things that are different.

Compare and contrast NPV with IRR

Compare and contrast HTTP and XML?

Compare and contrast McGregor and Maslow

Compare and contrast character of Jane

compare and contrast intracellular and extracellular

compare and contrast the lakes,wetland and rivers?

compare and contrast Pakistan and India religion

compare and contrast between triangles and a trapezoid

compare and contrast of paradise book 1 and book9

How can you compare and contrast psychodynamic and humanistic

compare & contrast the similarities & differences of a relation & function

The answer depends on what you wish to compare and contrast it with.

Compare: Explain how two or more things are the same. Contrast : Explain how two or more things are different.

Its a paragraph where you usually compare and contrast two things sometimes more. For example you can compare and contrast a dog from a cat Compare= Whats the same Contrast= Whats not the same Dogs and Cats are mamals. You walk a dog but not a cat.

compare and contrast mean the equalities and differences between what you are comparing and contrasting.

Copyright ยฉ 2020 Multiply Media, LLC. All Rights Reserved. The material on this site can not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with prior written permission of Multiply.