0
What else can I help you with?
What did the Virginia Plan called for?
It called for the states to have proportional representation.
How does the Virginia Plan promote proportional representation and which states would be likely to support this plan?
The Virginia Plan promotes proportional representation by proposing that legislative representation be based on each state's population or financial contributions, ensuring that larger states have more influence in the legislative process. This plan would likely be supported by populous states such as Virginia, Pennsylvania, and New York, as they would benefit from greater representation compared to less populous states. The plan aimed to create a stronger national government, appealing to those who favored a more centralized authority.
Was proportion representation in the New Jersey plan?
Yes, the New Jersey Plan proposed a system of equal representation for each state in Congress, regardless of population size. This plan aimed to ensure that smaller states had an equal voice in the legislative process, contrasting with the Virginia Plan, which advocated for proportional representation based on population. Ultimately, the New Jersey Plan contributed to the discussion that led to the Great Compromise, establishing a bicameral legislature with both proportional and equal representation.
Why did Virginia want there to proportional representation in Congress?
Virginia wanted proportional representation in Congress to ensure that its population and economic strength were adequately reflected in the legislative process. As a larger state with a significant population, Virginia sought to influence federal decision-making in alignment with its interests. This desire was a key factor during the Constitutional Convention, leading to the proposal of the Virginia Plan, which aimed to create a bicameral legislature with representation based on population. Ultimately, this push for proportional representation was rooted in a belief in fairness and the need for larger states to have a stronger voice in Congress.
What did the plan call for?
It called for the states to have proportional representation.
What were some of the complaints of small states regarding the Virginia Plan?
The Virginia Plan was based on population, while the New Jersey plan gave all states equal legislative representation. The small states could have been effectively stymied by control of the more populous states under the Virginia plan. The compromise was to form a bicameral Congress with one chamber using a form of each of the plans: the House of Representatives with proportional representation and the Senate with equal representation.
What is the plan for a state representation by population?
virginia plan
Small states in the uinon objected to a a) Virginia plan b) New Jersey plan c) Connecticut plan?
Small states in the union objected to the Virginia Plan. The Virginia Plan proposed a legislative structure based on population, which would give larger states more representation and power. In response, small states favored the New Jersey Plan, which called for equal representation regardless of size, ensuring that their interests would not be overshadowed by larger states. This disagreement ultimately led to the Great Compromise, resulting in a bicameral legislature with both proportional and equal representation.
What is different between the Virginia and New Jersey plan?
The New Jersey Plan was a proposal to have representation in Congress be equal for every state. In the Virginia Plan, representation was determined by population.
Who developed the Virginia Plan with James Madison?
James Madison is credited with developing the Virginia Plan, along with assistance from Edmund Randolph and others. The Virginia Plan, presented at the Constitutional Convention in 1787, proposed a strong central government with a bicameral legislature and proportional representation based on population.
What plan proposed proportional representation in both the House of Representatives and the Senate?
The plan that proposed proportional representation in both the House of Representatives and the Senate is known as the "Virginia Plan." Introduced at the Constitutional Convention of 1787, it advocated for a bicameral legislature with representation based on state population or financial contributions to the national government. This proposal aimed to address concerns about fair representation, particularly for larger states, and was a key point of contention that ultimately influenced the Great Compromise, which established the current structure of Congress.
Which of these is a plan that offered the Constitutional Convention a proposal for representation?
The New Jersey Plan
