Is asbestos roofing and fibreglass roofing similar?

Answer 1

Both fiberglass and asbestos are fibrous materials. In fact, fiberglass was considered a decent substitute for asbestos and commonly used until the health effects became apparent. Like asbestos, fiberglass has heat-resistant qualities that make it good for insulation. Fiberglass doesn’t burn or support combustion. It is inorganic and resistant to most chemicals. Asbestos also has unmatched resistance to heat and combustion. Both are excellent performers in thermal environments.

The similarities of fiberglass and asbestos can also be explored in regards to their dangerous health effects. Both asbestos and fiberglass are carcinogenic. According to the EPA, exposure to asbestos can cause lung cancer and mesothelioma. Fiberglass has also been found to be carcinogenic. In fact, fiberglass is sometimes known as the “man-made asbestos” or the “20th century asbestos” for having carcinogenic effects like asbestos. While fiberglass may not be as carcinogenic as asbestos, according to some research studies, both are linked to cancer, which is a dangerous disease. The major difference can also be explored in regards to the type of carcinogen. Fiberglass isn’t classified as a human carcinogen, according to some studies.

Asbestos is naturally occurring, while fiberglass is man-made. Asbestos has always been present in some soils and rocks. Fiberglass began being commercially synthesized in the 30s. Both may have thin fibers, but one is man-made.

The effects of inhaling or ingesting asbestos can take years to experience. The substance can take years to cause cancer. However, fiberglass irritates instantly when it comes into contact with the eyes and skin. Fiberglass causes inflammation of the skin or irritant contact dermatitis. Inhaling fiberglass also causes breathing difficulties that can be experienced almost instantly.

While both asbestos and fiberglass are considered dangerous, asbestos is more dangerous. Asbestos can rest safely once installed and only becomes airborne when damaged or mishandled. The same is true for fiberglass. However, one is more carcinogenic. While the classification of fiberglass as a human carcinogen is debatable, asbestos is a proven human carcinogen.

Asbestos has a higher heat resistance and tensile strength properties when compared to fiberglass. Fiberglass is more temperature resistant than polyamide and cotton, but it isn’t comparable to asbestos in this regard. However, it offers better tensile strength and continuous operation under high temperatures than asbestos. However, fiberglass can’t match asbestos in regards to cut resistance.

While both are known for heat resistant uses, they have different uses. Fiberglass is non-conductive, making it a perfect choice for electrical insulation. Fiberglass is also popular in making aircraft boats, automobiles, storage tanks, pipes, bathtubs, septic tanks, roofing, and cladding. While asbestos is also a great insulator, fiberglass can’t match some of its applications. For instance, unlike asbestos, fiberglass can’t be used to make friction materials like brake band linings.

Green Eco Solutions

1740 Lynnwood Rd Suite 3, Allentown, PA 18103

1-610-973-2500

HGG7+JH Allentown, Pennsylvania

Answer 2

No