answersLogoWhite

0

Is it right to try children in an adult court?

Updated: 8/18/2019
User Avatar

Wiki User

13y ago

Best Answer

No, it is not right. Conduct alone, that is, the alleged criminal act, should not by itself determine whether to invoke the heavy hand of the adult criminal justice system. Because people neither expect children to be criminals nor expect crimes to be committed by them, the unforeseen intersection between childhood and criminality creates a dilemma that most of us find difficult to resolve. The only way out of this dilemma is either to redefine the offence as something less serious than a crime or to redefine the offender as someone who is not really a child. Treating most of them as delinquent acts to be adjudicated within a separate juvenile justice system that is theoretically designed to recognize the special needs and immature status of young people and emphasize rehabilitation over punishment is a key feature absent in the Adult Court. To try a young offender in an adult court is both unfair and against the established system.

User Avatar

Wiki User

13y ago
This answer is:
User Avatar

Add your answer:

Earn +20 pts
Q: Is it right to try children in an adult court?
Write your answer...
Submit
Still have questions?
magnify glass
imp
Related questions

Crim control advocates are likely to favor A an increased role for juvenile court B jump programs C increased funding for juvenile court D enhancing prosecuters ability to try juveniles in adult court?

enhancing the prosecutors's ability to try juveniles in adult court


Your husband and you have been married for three years If he dies and your trust states all goes to you do his children have right to argue trust or take you to court?

If the children are not minors, it is doubtful they can successfully argue against the trust. But they can certainly try to take you to court.


In court of Texas is 17 adult?

it depends on how serious the crime commited is. i believe they can try a child at 16 as an adult if the crime is serious enough


Does a 17 year old have to live with her father if her mother dies?

Yes,but you could try to have another adult try to get custody in court


What if your guardian ad litem is wrong or lies?

You need to bring evidence to the attention of the court that shows the GAL is acting in bad faith and not doing their job. You should try to speak with an advocate at the court. If you are a child you should ask a trusted adult for help.You need to bring evidence to the attention of the court that shows the GAL is acting in bad faith and not doing their job. You should try to speak with an advocate at the court. If you are a child you should ask a trusted adult for help.You need to bring evidence to the attention of the court that shows the GAL is acting in bad faith and not doing their job. You should try to speak with an advocate at the court. If you are a child you should ask a trusted adult for help.You need to bring evidence to the attention of the court that shows the GAL is acting in bad faith and not doing their job. You should try to speak with an advocate at the court. If you are a child you should ask a trusted adult for help.


How can a parent stop a 18 year old from leaving court could they try and charge them with being incompetent?

The 18 year old is an adult and can leave, but if it is a court session the court will charge them and may arrest them.


Can i get the father of my unborn child to relinquish his parental right?

You can try, but has to be court approved.


Can a 17yearold be charged as an adult on aggravated robbery charges?

YES! depending on the circumstances the court can decide to try a 17 yaer old as an adult in an assault case


If someone wasn't married and had children does the dad have the right to see his children if he isn't on the birth cirtificates or has never gone to court for custody?

Technically, yes. However, if the mother won't allow visitations the father must establish his paternity through the court and request custody and a visitation schedule. A child support order can be issued at the same time.


Can a parent let the children decide not to follow a court ordered custody agreement?

No, it's the custodial parent's responsibility to see to that the court order is followed. If the visitation order is not followed the custodial parent will be in contempt of a court order and could eventually lose custody. It would be better to discuss the reasons why the children are uncomfortable about visiting and the try to address their complaints. The parents should try to get along and not alienate the children in any way.


Are there any laws to protect my children against their grandmother's lies to try to get custody?

You should get you a lawyer an deverytime your grandmother try to get your childern, you record it. Then you take it to court.


Can a spouse in a divorce prevent relatives of other spouse from seeing minor children?

You could, as a parent it's your right to decide who the child can see.However, as blood relatives, it's also the grandparents right to see the child.You can try to do so, however you should bare in mind that the grandparents then have the right to take you to court for access.