answersLogoWhite
US Coins

What is the value of a 1923 buffalo nickel?


Top Answer
User Avatar
Wiki User
2015-07-17 09:55:32
2015-07-17 09:55:32
Determining the Value of an old CoinTo determine the value of your Buffalo Nickel, you need to determine a couple things first :
  • 1) Which (if any) mintmark does it have? Look on the back, under the words FIVE CENTS, to see if it has a small letter. No letter means the coin was minted in Philadelphia, an "S" means it came from the San Francisco Mint.
  • 2) What condition is the coin in ? If you can read all the lettering, it will grade at least Good. If the tip of the buffalo's horn, his tail where it crosses the high point of his hip, and all the detail in the Indian's hair are clearly visible, it will probably grade Extremely Fine

Once you know the date, mintmark, and grade, you can go to a price guide to look up the value. There is a free online RETAIL price guide at the related link.

With no mint mark on the back, $2-5 in average condition. For a updated value see the related link below. With a small "S" under the words FIVE CENTS, $7 if very worn, $25 if only somewhat worn. For a updated value see the related link below.

(*) FWIW the coin is actually a nickel rather than "nickle"

__________________________________________________________________--

Coins are graded on a scale of 1-70. Generally you will find the lowest grade being a 3, or About Good. These coins are very heavily worn with portions of lettering, date, and legend worn smooth. The date may be barely readable. The highest grade possible is a Perfect Uncirculated (MS-70) These coins are in perfect new condition, showing no trace of wear. The finest quality possible, with no evidence of scratches, handling, or contact with other coins. Bery few regular-issue coins are ever found in this condition. In determining the grade of your coin, you should follow these simple guidelines.

G-4 Good-- Legends and date readable. Buffalo's horn does not show.

VG-8 Very Good- Horn worn nearly flat.

F-12 Fine- Horn and tail smooth but partially visible. Obverse rim intact.

VF-20 Very Fine- Much of horn visible. Indian's cheekbone worn.

EF-40 Extremely Fine- Horn lightly worn. Slight wear on Indian's hair ribbon.

AU-50 About Uncirculated- Traces of light wear on only ht ehigh points of the design. Half of mint luster present.

MS-60 Uncirculated- No trace of wear. May have several blemishes.

MS-63 Choice Uncirculated- No trace of wear. Light blemishes.

Following these guidelines on determining the approximate grade of your coin can further help your understanding of the value of your 1923 Indian Head (Buffalo) nickel.

A 1923 Philadelphia (No mint mark) Buffalo Nickel ranges from $2.00 (G-4) to $60 (MS-63). There was 35.7 million of these nickels minted here in 1923.

A 1923S (San Francisco mint) Buffalo Nickel ranges from $7.50 (G-4) to $475 (MS-63). There was 6.1 million of these nickels minted in San Francisco in 1923.

All values are approximate and there are always certain numismatic anomalies that may change (increase or decrease) the value of your coin.

More:The 1923 Buffalo Nickel was minted in Philadelphia and San Francisco so the value depends on the condition. These are the values according to USA Coin Book:

Philadelphia (no mint mark): In good condition, this coin is worth about $1.90 up to about $55 in MS60 mint condition. In MS63 choice uncirculated grade, this coin is worth about $150.

San Francisco (small "S" mint mark): In good condition, this coin is worth about $7.10 up to about $445 in MS60 mint condition. In MS63 choice uncirculated grade, this coin is worth about $900.

Related Questions

User Avatar

The coin is normally called either a Buffalo nickel or an Indian Head nickel. The entire buffalo is shown, not just its head, LOL! Please see the Related Question for details

User Avatar

value of a 1936 buffalo head nickel

User Avatar

This coin is also called a buffalo nickel. Both names are about equally common. Please see the question "What is the value of a 1923 US nickel?" for details by mint mark and condition. 1923 is not a rare date for Buffalo nickels. Well-worn, it's worth about a dollar. Lightly worn, it's worth about $8 A nice uncirculated one is worth about $100

User Avatar

The coin is called an Indian Head nickel or a buffalo nickel, not "buffalo head" - after all, it shows the entire buffalo! Please see the question "What is the value of a 1936 US nickel?" for more information.

User Avatar

The coin is called an Indian Head nickel or a buffalo nickel, not "buffalo head" - after all, it shows the entire buffalo! Please see the question "What is the value of a 1934 US nickel?" for more information.


Copyright © 2020 Multiply Media, LLC. All Rights Reserved. The material on this site can not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with prior written permission of Multiply.