answersLogoWhite

0

Catholic (and typically Christian) answer: The mass recapitulates the last supper, which took the form of a Passover Seder as it was celebrated in the days when the Temple still stood in Jerusalem.

Jewish answer: The Catholic answer is probably wrong. If you look at the text of the traditional Catholic Mass, it strongly resembles the text of the Amidah, a prayer said three times daily in the Jewish liturgy. It has no resemblance to any of the liturgy of the Seder, a ritual that we know has been fairly stable for most of the past 2000 years. The actual ritual of communion, with blessings over bread and wine that are then consumed, strongly resembles the Kiddush ritual conducted at the start of every Sabbath and festival meal (incuding the Passover Seder), where blessings are said before consuming wine and bread. We suspect that the form of the Amidah and Kiddush ritual was already in place in Jesus time and we suspect that the Jewish followers of Jesus retained this ritual structure and gradually added new explanations linking it to the last supper until the actual origins of these rituals was forgotten.

User Avatar

Anonymous

5y ago

What else can I help you with?

Related Questions

Did Jesus have the Last Supper on Passover?

Yes he did. The Last Supper was a Passover Seder.


Is it true that at the last supper Jesus instituted the passover?

Passover existed before the Last Supper, so Jesus did not institute it at the Last Supper. He was celebrating the Passover and instituted the Eucharist at the Last Supper.


How many years between the first passover and the last supper?

Jews still celebrate Passover to this day.


Was Jesus celebration of the Last Supper really his celebration of the Jewish Passover?

Yes. His Last Supper was at the time of year at which Passover is celebrated.


What is the ceremony called reenacting the last supper?

passover


Does pass over and last supper have same meaning?

The Last Supper of Jesus was a Jewish Passover meal, or Seder.


What is the difference between Passover and last supper?

In the synoptic gospels, the Last Supper was on the day of the Jewish Passover feast, so we can say that Jesus and the disciples were partaking of the Passover feast.In John's Gospel, the crucifixion was on the day of preparation for the Passover, so John does not describe a Last Supper, saying just that on evening before, when their supper was ended, Jesus washed the feet of the apostles.


Which Gospels include the Last Supper?

The Last Supper was the Passover feast and appears in the Synoptic gospels, Matthew, Mark and Luke, because Passover occurred on the Thursday before the crucifixion. In John's Gospel, the Passover was on the Friday of the crucifixion, so there is no Last Supper recorded, instead Jesus washed the feet of the disciples.


In what ways is the Passover like the lords supper?

It isn't. Some people think that the last supper was a Passover seder, however, the timing was wrong for that to have happened.


What Jewish religious ceremony was celebrated on the last supper?

Passover


Why did Jesus celebrate the passover during the last supper?

yes


Why were the celebrating the last supper?

Jesus and his disciples were celebrating the festival of the passover.