answersLogoWhite

0


Best Answer

Trick question. That depends on the state statute and whether it is repugnant to the US Constitution or federal law in an area where the federal government asserts supremacy. If the statute falls under the penumbra of states' rights, then the statute is controlling and the US Supreme Court will (should) uphold it.

If the statute is unconstitutional under the US Constitution and involves a part of the Constitution incorporated (applied) to the states, then the US Supreme Court decision is controlling. If the statute would be unconstitutional under the US Constitution, but involves a part of the constitution not incorporated to the states (for example, the Seventh Amendment), the Supreme Court will decide whether to apply the Constitution, which would then be binding on all states, or whether to allow the state statute to stand, in which case the state statute would be controlling.

User Avatar

Wiki User

13y ago
This answer is:
User Avatar

Add your answer:

Earn +20 pts
Q: Which is controlling the state statute or US Supreme Court?
Write your answer...
Submit
Still have questions?
magnify glass
imp
Related questions

The highest court at state level is the supreme court?

state supreme court


How is the supreme court structured and what are the responsibilities?

Each state has its own court system. These courts are created by state statute or constitution to enforce state civil and criminal laws. Most of the states have trial courts, intermediate courts of appeal, and a supreme court.


Which has the greater authority U.S Supreme Court or the state Supreme Court?

U.S Supreme Court


What court is usually composed of from 3 to 9 judges and is the highest court in the state?

This would be the state supreme court for a particular US state.supreme court


Is the highest court at the state level is it the state supreme court?

Yes STATE SUPREME COURT is the highest court at the State level.It is the is the ultimate judicial tribunal for a particular case.Different STATES have there own supreme courts.The supreme court of USA is the highest court.It can over rules the decisions made by State supreme courts.


What is the highest court in the US?

The US Supreme Court is the highest court in the US. Each state has its own Supreme Court, but the US Supreme Court is the end of the line.


What state supreme court is most often cited by other state supreme courts as authority?

According to the California Supreme Court Historical Society, the California Supreme Court has been the "most cited and followed" state supreme court since 1940.


Can the state Supreme Court over rule the federal Supreme Court?

No


Which court would most likely hear a case over interpretation of a state constitutio?

state Supreme Court


Is the Supreme Court of Florida a federal court or state court?

The Supreme Court of Florida is the highest appellate court in the Florida state judicial system.


How can the supreme court overpower the legislative branch?

Yes and no. The US Supreme Court doesn't have veto power, and can't overturn a legislative act unless it is properly challenged in the federal court system and petitioned to the Supreme Court under its appellate jurisdiction. The Court can't actively seek out legislation to overrule.


What is the highest court in your state?

The Georgia Supreme Court is the highest court in my state.