Notorious Murderers and Serial Killers

Who was the first known female serial killer in the US?

User Avatar
Wiki User
2014-11-24 16:37:49

Lavinia Fisher was the first female serial killer who killed a

known 19 people in the late 19th century. She was to be hanged on

18 February 1820, and once the noose was attached she jumped off

the gallows committing suicide instead.

Belle Gunness (1896 - 1908) aka 'Lady Bluebeard' was labeled as

a Black Widow (women who kill men in particular.) On a farm outside

of Chicago she killed 49 people, including multiple husbands, ranch

workers, children she adopted and killed them by poison. She set up

a ranch worker to take the fall for it (he died in prison) and she

was never brought to justice.

Ellen Etheridge (1912 - 1913) was 22 years old. She married a

Texas millionaire and inherited 8 of his children and she killed

off three at a time by arsenic poisoning. She served life in


Martha Wise (1924 - 1925) aka 'the Borgia of America' was a 39

year old widow from Ohio. When her family opposed her marrying a

younger man she used arsenic to kill three of her family members,

but the family became suspicious and reported her to police. She

not only admitted to the three murders, but burning down the church

because the minister had been reluctant to marry her and her lover.

She served life in prison.

Killers who are females are rare or unknown only because they

are more cunning and society prefers to see a serial killer as a

male. Some have even been known as 'contract killers' and are for

hire. Some work with a male partner and, although rare, some will

work with a female partner. Some work in groups such as 'Charles

Manson Group'. Women are generally more successful at being serial

killers (a serial killer is considered one with three or more

victims) and are intelligent, resourceful and more careful than the

male serial killers. Many kill for money (marrying, murdering their

husband and remarrying, thus, 'The Black Widow.'

The best known to the American public was Aileen Wuornos, born

Aileen Carol Pittman, executed in 2002 by lethal injection in

Florida. She was convicted of murdering six men who had picked her

up as a hitchhiker.

Dorothea Puente, a seemingly kindly landlady in California, was

accused of murdering nine of her elderly tenants in order to take

their pension checks that continued to come to her house.

Authorities found six bodies buried in her yard, but she was only

convicted of three of the murders. In 1993, she was sentenced to

life in prison at age of 64.

There are many more female serial killers that could be named,

but the above is to show that these are the female serial killers

that were caught and there were more before them and female serial

killers are on the rise now. They are more crafty and less likely

to be caught.

Lavinia Fisher was not a serial killer. The story of her career

is filled with apocryphal legend.''Here are some early cases (from

"Female Serial Killers of 19th Century America")

"font-size:14.3999996185303px;" />

1829 - Martha "Patty" Cannon - Maryland/Delaware state line

1840 - Kinney, Hannah Hanson - Boston & Lowell,


1845 - Mrs. Elizabeth Reed - Lawrenceville, Illinois

"font-size:14.3999996185303px;" />

1851 - Rachel Clark - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

"font-size:14.3999996185303px;" />

1851 - Nancy Farrer - Cincinnati, Ohio

"font-size:14.3999996185303px;" />

1852 - Nancy Hufford - Cumberland, Md., Somerset, Pa.

"font-size:14.3999996185303px;" />

1857 - Polly Frisch (Hoag) - Alabama, Genessee County, New


1857 - Elizabeth Routt - Hazel Green, Tennessee

"font-size:14.3999996185303px;" />

1858 - Lydia Studley - Valley Falls, Rhode Island

1858 - Phebe Westlake (nee Irwin) - Chester, New York

1860 - Mary Jane "Bricktop" Jackson - New Orleans, Louisiana

1860 - Elizabeth P. McCraney - Lancaster, Wisconsin; Medford,

Otsego, N. Y.

1865 - Martha Grinder - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

1869 - "Gardiner, Maine Black Widow Serial Killer" - Gardiner,


1869 - Mrs. Wahle - Jacksonville, Illinois

1869 - Mrs. White - Lafayette Township, Sussex County, New


Copyright © 2020 Multiply Media, LLC. All Rights Reserved. The material on this site can not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with prior written permission of Multiply.