0
Why did the federalists argue against inclusion of a bill of rights in the constitutions?
Wiki User
∙ 7y ago
The Federalist didn't want to add the Bill of Rights because they didn't feel it was needed. They didn't feel it was needed because the powers of the Federal Government was specifically listed in the Constitution, and the Federal Government would have no right to intrude on anything not specifically listed. By listing rights in the First Amendment for example, it appears to be granting rights to the people, even though the anti-federalist put it their to simply specify what the Federal Government had no control over. But by doing so, it appeared to be rights that were given to us by the constitution, when those basic rights we're deemed god given or natural rights that transcend government, as listed at the Virginia Convention.
Wiki User
∙ 13y ago
Add your answer:
Earn +20 pts
What group opposed the constitution because it took power from the states?
They Anti-Federalists. Because of this they successfully pushed for the inclusion of a Bill of Rights after the adoption of the Constitution.
How was the constitution ratifed?
After a long and heated battle between the Federalists and Anti-Federalists over the Constitution versus the Articles of Confederation and the inclusion of the Bill of Rights, a Constitution was written and ratified by all 13 colonies.
What was the Anti-Federalists' greatest concern about ratifying the U.S. Constitution?
Generally speaking, anti-Federalists feared that a too powerful central government might conflict with the states ( former colonies ) own constitutions which guaranteed so many freedoms that were held sacred by state politicians, leaders and ordinary citizens. To overcome the fears of the anti-Federalists, James Madison was assigned the task to create a bill of rights that made sure that a too powerful central government would take away their rights. Madison came up with twelve amendments, however the Framers decided to use only ten of them.
What was the significant of federalists papers?
the anti-federalists were against the constitution and for them to agree with the federalist the federalists needed to add a bill of rights so the anti-federalists could agree with the philadelphia constitution
Who were the anti- federalists and what did they believe?
The Anti-Federalists like a weak government and wanted more power with the states. They were against ratification. They also were in favor of adding a Bill of Rights.
Did most state constitutions did not have a bill of rights at the time of the constitutional convention?
Many of the state constitutions contained a Bill of Rights at the time of the Convention. That was one of the reasons that a Bill of Rights was not included in the original version of theU.S. Constitution. Anti-Federalists feared that without a Bill of Rights inserted in the Constitution, the new federal government might be able to interfere or deny some of the rights of the citizens.
What is a good example of the influence of enlightenment ideas on constitutions?
Natural rights - Most state constitutions had a bill of rights.
What are federalists and anti-federalists?
The federalists were supporters of the Constitution while the anti-federalists oppose the Constitution because of its lack of a Bill of Rights. Key federalists include Alexander Hamilton, John Jay and initially James Madison (changes to a republican (former anti-federalists) later on) Key anti-federalists include, Patrick Henry and Thomas Jefferson.
Which is a good example of the influence of enlightenment ideas on constitutions?
Natural rights - Most state constitutions had a bill of rights.
What is the difference of anti-federalists and federalists and papers?
federalists wanted the constitution to remainn in its origanal state without the bill of rights. anti federalists wanted the bill of rights
What were the issues upon which the Federalists and Anti Federalists disagreed?
The main issue that the federalists and anti-federalists disagreed upon was the Bill of Rights. The federalists believed that the people should just have the constitution, however the anti-federalists believed in making a bill of rights so the people could see what there rights were.
Is a good example of the influence of enlightenment ideas on state constitutions?
Natural rights - Most state constitutions had a bill of rights.
