answersLogoWhite

0


Best Answer

Since the question doesn't specify, we'll discuss the exile of the Ten Tribes of Israel, the destruction of the First Temple, and the destruction of the Second Temple. In each case, we'll give 1) a spiritual reason, and 2) a political ("current events-type") reason.
The loss of the Ten Tribes (some 2650 years ago):

1) The spiritual reason was that for over two centuries the Ten Tribes had cut themselves off from the more-righteous tribe of Judah and the Temple, and had been more lax about the prohibition against idolatry. The prophets, such as Hosea, had warned them but were not sufficiently heeded.

2) The temporal reason was that Assyria conquered them and exiled them.


The First Destruction (some 2500 years ago):
1) The general spiritual reason was that God found the people of Judah to be below the spiritual level that was a requisite for having His presence among them. The prophets had warned them (Jeremiah 7:25) but were not sufficiently heeded (2 Chronicles 36:16). Once God's presence no longer felt welcome in the Holy Temple, its destruction was just a matter of time (see Talmud, Rosh Hashanah 31a, and midrash Eichah Rabbah 1:43).
A more specific spiritual reason was the egregious sins of Menasheh, king of Judah, as stated in 2 Kings 21:11-13 and 24:3.


2) The political reason (the specific temporal circumstance) was the fact that King Yehoiakim, after having been obedient to Nevuchadnezzar (king of Babylonia), became insubordinate (2 Kings 24:1); and Nevuchadnezzar responded by conquering the land of Judah, destroying the First Temple and exiling the populace.


Some positive results: the false prophets, at long last, were silenced forever. They had predicted that no Destruction would take place.
Also, the lure of idolatry finally weakened, since the Destruction and Exile happened exactly as predicted by the true Prophets, who were the same ones who had spoken ceaselessly against dabbling in idolatry.


The Second Destruction (in 68 CE):
1) The spiritual reason was that the Jewish people were plagued by an internal enemy, the Sadducees, who had been dragging the spiritual level of the people downwards for many decades. These were men of power who (along the lines of the earlier Hellenizers) were less interested in Torah than in pleasure, politics, and obsequiousness to the Herodian kings and the Romans. Even the once-pious Hasmoneans had eventually become infiltrated by the Sadducees. They had fomented unnecessary wars, sown discord among the Jewish people (see Talmud, Yoma 9b), and had even killed a number of the leading Torah-sages (Talmud, Kidushin 66a). The Second Destruction, as painful and tragic as it was, at least accomplished the disappearance of the impious cliques (as alluded in the parable in the Talmud, Gittin 56b, in which the "barrel of honey" represents Jerusalem and the Temple, and the "serpent" hints to the Sadducees, among others). Once Jerusalem and the Temple were razed, the men of power melted away and the internal life of the Jewish communities returned to the aegis of the Torah-sages. Other non-traditional groups including the Samaritans and the Essenes also now permanently dissociated themselves from the Jewish people.


2) The political trigger to the Second Destruction was the anti-Roman revolt fomented by the Zealots, who acted against the advice of the Rabbis and left the Romans no choice but to crush the people (Talmud, Gittin 56).

User Avatar

Wiki User

9y ago
This answer is:
User Avatar

Add your answer:

Earn +20 pts
Q: Why did jews lose their holy land?
Write your answer...
Submit
Still have questions?
magnify glass
imp
Related questions

What is the Holy Land of the Jews?

Israel.


Why is the holy land the Jews?

Israel is the Jewish homeland. It is where the Jews originated from.


How did Jews holy land spread?

the Holy Land did not spread. If anything, it has shrunk since ancient times.


Who drove the Jews away from the holy land?

The Romans


What is the scattering of Jews outside of the Holy Land?

Diaspora


Why is Reb Saunders against the idea of Palestine becoming the homeland of the Jews?

Reb Saunders believes, like a number of Orthodox Jews, that the Galut (the Exile from the Holy Land) was a divine act of punishment because Jews had violated the commandments that God had given them. When God believed that the Jewish people had repented and were ready for the Messiah, this Messiah would come and bring the Jews back to the Holy Land. Until that time, Jews will remain in exile. They see a Return to the Holy Land as being an act of blasphemy because Jews should wait for God to bring them into the Holy Land and not to physically move there of their own free will.


Why did Jesus lead the Jews to freedom?

Jesus did not lead the Jews to freedom. The Romans went on to destroy the Holy Temple and expel the Jews from the land.


What term describes the Jews who dod not live in the holy land?

Diaspora. It refers to the emigration of the Jews into areas outside Palestine.


Who led the attack of the holy land?

God directed the Jews, who were led by Moses and Joshua.


What three religions share the same holy land in Jerusalem?

Christians, Jews, and Muslims


What was the major reasons for the crusades?

The Christians wanted to release the holy land (Jerusalem) from the Jews.


When did judaism lose its holy land?

Never. The Divine promise of the Holy Land to them has never changed, and some Jews have always lived there. The majority of the Jews were exiled from the land at the time of the dispersing of the Ten Tribes (traditional date: 2566 years ago), and again at the First Destruction (traditional date: 2433 years ago). After the Second Destruction (1943 years ago), the Jewish majority in the land dwindled slowly, until the point (some 1600 or 1700 years ago) that they became a dwindling minority. Jews have been returning to the land, in small numbers at first, beginning 750 years ago.