0
Why was Union General George B McClellan correct concerning his next move after the Battle of Antietam?
Wiki User
∙ 7y ago
US President Lincoln and General in Chief Henry Wager Halleck were critical of General McClellan for not moving immediately against the Army of Northern Virginia after the Battle of Antietam. It can be debated that McClellan had difficulties in resupplying his army, which was huge and reequipping it was a time costly task. This was the reason he believed that an immediate advance against Lee's army was not the correct move.
His view is confirmed as General Robert E. Lee saw the strategic situation in the same way. McClellan realized that Lee's two-sided base was a threat to his army in Virginia. Lee's home base had support.
Richmond and the vital Virginia Central railroad. Good roads and a rail link to the Shenandoah Valley was Lee's base to the West. It was also rich in food supplies.
From Lee's Valley base he would threaten the flank and rear of any Union army moving south to Richmond.
And attacking Lee's army directly in Virginia, without resupplying would not be a good move by McClellan.
President Lincoln did not see the value of McClellan's hesitation. But if Lincoln knew Lee agreed with McClellan, his attitude might have been different.
Wiki User
∙ 7y ago
Add your answer:
Earn +20 pts
What statement about the battle of Antietam is correct in apex?
It led Lincoln to declare the end of slavery in the South.
What battles did George B McClellan participate in?
George McClellan fought following battles during the Civil War : Philippi; Rich Mountain; Cheat Mountain; The Peninsular Campaign, whose most important battles were: The Seven Pines and the Seven Days; Antietam.
After World War I the general feeling of most americans was?
All Answers Are Correct
What is the correct title of the general staff positions that report to the incident commander?
because
What were the correct predictions of General Robert E Lee concerning General in Chief US Grant in March of 1864?
Shortly after US Grant was appointed to be the new general in chief of the Union armies, he made it clear that he would attach himself personally to the Army of the Potomac. This was a slight to General George Meade, as Meade had saved the Union from a disastrous defeat at the Battle of Gettysburg. Lee was certain and correct in that Grant would make Virginia and the capture of Richmond a priority. Lee also correctly predicted that while Grant would orchestrate the Union forces heading south towards Richmond, Grant would create a secondary offensive from the south side of the James River. This dual offensive posed a serious threat to the outnumbered forces of General Lee. Lee also made several other correct predictions, however, all of them revolved around the dual offensive assault.
How did Union General Ambrose Burnside keep General McClellan from committing political suicide?
When General George B. McClellan was reappointed to head the Army of the Potomac, the Secretary of War, Edwin Stanton had opposed this move by Lincoln and made it clear to Lincoln that McClellan was not to be 100% trusted. Stanton was correct and McClellan wanted to settle some personal scores with the Secretary. McClellan took Ambrose Burnside into his confidence and informed Burnside that he would force President Lincoln to fire Stanton, if he, McClellan, was to take up his new command. The ever loyal Ambrose, counseled against this and reminded the general to avoid politics at this time. McClellan agreed to his friends advice, but created a headquarters staff in Washington DC small and loyal only to himself. Anyone who was not a stout ally of McClellan was no longer part of the inner military circle that McClellan created. This is perhaps the reason that after McClellan was relieved of command after Antietam, Burnside turned Lincoln down two times to be McClellan's replacement. Only after the third request of Lincoln, did Burnside accept command. No one realized at the time, that Burnside would be the short lived third leader of the Army of the Potomac. Nor would he be the last one either.
What was the main issue that forced US President Lincoln to relieve General George B McClellan of his duties?
General George B. McClellan had his own ideas on how to prosecute the US Civil War. He resisted the Lincoln administration's ideas concerning the the seizure of Southern civilian property and force the South's civilians to bear responsibility for their part in the war. Disagreeing with President Lincoln was one thing, however, not obeying direct orders from Lincoln was another matter. McClellan's idea was to wage war against the Confederate government and their armies. He believed the war could be won without doing this, and he believed that the Union victory, by using his methods would lead to a better peace when the South was forced to rejoin the Union.In this situation, whether McClellan was correct or not, his duty was to obey President Lincoln. He refused and finally was relieved of all duties.
What statement about the battle of Antietam is correct in apex?
It led Lincoln to declare the end of slavery in the South.
What is the correct statements concerning the spinal cord?
One of them should be correct, normally.
Which concerning equal rights amendment is correct?
The amendment was not ratified.
What was one important step Union General George B McClellan needed to accomplish in order to have control over US military policies?
Union General George B. McClellan wanted to conduct the US Civil War in his own fashion which he believed was the correct course to take to win the war. He faced many obstacles in order to accomplish such a difficult task. He was not trying to take over the government but to redirect what he believed was an obstacle to do this. His first sights were set on the easiest targets, namely ones that were in the military where he had the most influence. Blocking McClellan was General Winfield Scott. From August to the end of October, 1861, McClellan began a systematic campaign to undermine Scott. Due to Scott's age, the easiest way for McClellan to reduce Scott was to drive him into retirement. This was ashame in that Scott was responsible for having McClellan in Washington DC in the first place. Because he and Scott had constant contact over military affairs, McClellan began to spread rumors about Scott's physical ability to retain his position, and, spread rumors about his failing mental capacities. He helped undermine Scott by ignoring him and bypassing him in the military chain of command. And he weakened Scott by being rude and standoffish. Scott did finally resign and McClellan replaced him as general in chief, a powerful position if used properly. Although Lincoln never expressed concern that his general in chief was disloyal, he cautioned McClellan that his new primary duties might impair McClellan's ability to take on two significant jobs. One was the rebuilding of the Army of the Potomac, the other was carrying on the strategic command of all the Union armies. McClellan convinced Lincoln that he could handle both jobs. In his own mind he had already taken a strong dislike of his Commander in Chief.
Which of these is a correct matchBattle of Shiloh—TennesseeBattle of Antietam—PennsylvaniaBattle of Fredericksburg—MississippiBattle of Fort Henry—Virginia?
Battle of Shiloh—Tennessee
What is the statements concerning the equal rights amendment is correct?
the amendment was not ratified
Which statement concerning wood decay is correct?
Wood is biologically degradable.
Is dis-concerning a word?
No, "dis-concerning" is not a word. The correct term is "disconcerting," which means causing someone to feel unsettled or anxious.
What about the battle of Antietam is correct?
it led Lincoln to declare the end of slavery in the South
What caused US President Lincoln to be disappointed with General George B McClellan?
General McClellan was an excellent military strategist, but not a very aggressive commander of troops in the field(in battle). Early in the war, after McClellan had been endlessly drilling the Army but not deploying it for battle, Lincoln sarcastically commented "If General McClellan is not going to use the Army, I'd like to borrow it for a while." McClellan was too much of the siege mentality. During the 1862 Peninsular Campaign parts of the Union Army got within about 7 miles of Richmond(their objective)and basically stopped their advance. Lincoln needed a General who was aggressive in battle and that is why he respected Gen. Grant. NO, Lincoln's problem with McClellan was not military but political. Like most people, McClellan objected to the Radical Republicans' use of the war to push their political agenda and to rape the South. The Radical Republicans in Congress, few of whom had ever done military service, were suspicious of professional military men, particularly those of the upper classes such as McClellan and Fitzhugh Porter. They held hearings on the conduct of the war, and sought to harass and imprison any officer they suspected of "disloyalty" (i.e., not following the radical Abolitionist party line). The radicals in Congress wanted to fire McClellan long before Lincoln actually did. And Lincoln did not replace McClellan with Grant. He replaced McClellan with Pope and Burnside, who were disasters (but "politically correct"), then Hooker (ditto), and finally Meade, who was a conservative Democrat...but by now Lincoln was running out of Generals. Then Grant came in as Meade's boss. Grant was safe politically because his friend and sponsor was the powerful Illinois Congressman Elihu Washburne, whom Lincoln listened to and obeyed.
