0
Why was the communist victory in Russia a contradiction to Marxist theory?
Wiki User
∙ 13y ago
Marxism states that for a Communist Revolution to occur, a large extent of the working classes in the population of the country must be behind the whole idea, and instead of having leaders to make the revolution happen, it will be the whole Working Class (Proletariat) rising up together to overthrow the (current) form of government etc. However, the Bolshevik Revolution was a Coup d'etat, in that only 500 or so Bolshevik members, led by Leon Trotsky, made the revolution actually happen.
Wiki User
∙ 8y ago
Wiki User
∙ 13y agoMarx believed that the industrialized nations would be first to choose communism, because millions of workers in dehumanizing and brutal factory conditions would unionize and revolt. Marx did not see that working conditions would generally improve over time and that unions would be successful in winning wage concessions, legal changes, etc.
Russia had little factory labor and industrial development. The country did not fit the Marxist model at all. The people who revolted were farmers, soldiers, sailors, police, doctors, mechanics ... nearly all types of people.
Add your answer:
Earn +20 pts
Where the mensheviks communist?
Yes the Mensheviks were a communist group in communist Russia. They were mostly made up of the middle class or bourgies. They believed in a large group of people changing things slowly. This was very different to the Bolsheviks who had 15 group members who believed in a fast marxist revolution.
What is market-Leninism?
If Soviet Russia was Marxist-Leninism, China is Market-Leninism. In other words, communist; China has a one party system and that party is communists, but the focus is not on isolation. Soviet Russia had no interest to compete in the global market, where China is Market-Leninism, they compete in the global market and remain communist or follow the teachings of V.I. Lenin.
What were non communist in Russia called?
Non-communist Russia was called Russia. When Russia was under communism, it was called the Union of Soviet Socialists Republics or the USSR.
Marxist group seeking to change Russia through revolution?
Bolsheviks
Women under the control of communist russia were considered?
women under the control of communist russia were considered?
What made communist Russia and communist China utopias?
Nothing. They were not communist utopias from a marxist point of view.
What nation experienced a Marxist takeover during the 1918?
Russia experienced a Marxist takeover in 1917 during the Russian Revolution. The Bolsheviks, led by Vladimir Lenin, overthrew the provisional government and established a communist government.
When did Leon Trotsky begin to inform his fellow revolutionaries that a communist regime in Russia could not survive without help?
It was within the Russian Revolution of 1905 that Leon Trotsky began writing his idea that a communist or a Marxist regime in Russia would not last without an ally. Because of the poor industrial strength of Russia and its lack of a real trade union working force, Trotsky was hoping that a Marxist revolution, ideally in Germany . Thus with the help of an advanced industrial power such as Germany, a Russian Marxist regime would receive the help needed to prevent a counter revolution in Russia.
Where the mensheviks communist?
Yes the Mensheviks were a communist group in communist Russia. They were mostly made up of the middle class or bourgies. They believed in a large group of people changing things slowly. This was very different to the Bolsheviks who had 15 group members who believed in a fast marxist revolution.
What was the name of the first marxist party in russia?
The Russian Social Democratic Labor Party (RSDLP) was the first Marxist party in Russia. In 1903, the party split into two factions, the Bolsheviks and the Mensheviks. The Bolsheviks eventually split off completely from the RSDLP and formed their own party. The Bolshevik Party eventually became the Communist Party in 1918.
Who was a revolutionary that contributed to Marxist theories of government?
Lenin. Supported by the germans, he overthrew the government of russia and founded the ussr. he added the idea of a communist party to marxism, forming the ideaoulogy of Marx-Leninism.
What was the first country to try to enact Marx and Engels's communist manifesto?
The first country to attempt to implement Marx and Engels's communist manifesto was the Soviet Union, following the Russian Revolution of 1917. The Bolsheviks, led by Vladimir Lenin, established a communist government based on Marxist principles.
What is market-Leninism?
If Soviet Russia was Marxist-Leninism, China is Market-Leninism. In other words, communist; China has a one party system and that party is communists, but the focus is not on isolation. Soviet Russia had no interest to compete in the global market, where China is Market-Leninism, they compete in the global market and remain communist or follow the teachings of V.I. Lenin.
What Nation experienced a Marxist takeover during 1918?
Russia
In which country did the first marxist revolution take place?
russia
Is russia limited or unlimited government?
Russia is a communist government
What were non communist in Russia called?
Non-communist Russia was called Russia. When Russia was under communism, it was called the Union of Soviet Socialists Republics or the USSR.
