0
Would a ruling by the federal appeals court for my circuit be binding precedent if I file a federal law claim in a state court?
Wiki User
∙ 14y ago
If the Federal Court precedent is applicable to your situation it can be cited - HOWEVER - although they may consider it, it does NOT mean that it would be binding on them.
Wiki User
∙ 14y ago
Add your answer:
Earn +20 pts
On which states are appeals court ruling binding?
On State Courts of Appeal - their rulings are binding on the entire states court system. On the findings of a Federal Appeals Court - they are binding upon the federal district courts within THAT appeals courts circuit.
What is a decision made by a higher court such as a US Court of Appeals Circuit Court or the US Supreme Court that is binding on all federal courts?
A decision made by a higher court sets a binding precedent for the inferior court(s).
Is court precedent mandatory or persuasive?
That depends on which court you're referring to. In the federal court system, the US Supreme Court sets binding (or mandatory) precedent for all lower courts; the US Court of Appeals Circuit Courts set binding precedent for all US District Courts within their jurisdiction, but only persuasive precedent elsewhere; the US District Courts do not set binding precedent at all, they only set persuasive precedent.
What is the difference between a binding precedent and a persuasive precedent?
A binding precedent is precedent that a court MUST follow (it is law). All prior judicial decisions in a specific court's jurisdiction heard at that court's level or higher are considered to be binding precedent. In contrast, persuasive precedent is precedent that a court need not follow (it is NOT law, but, as the name suggests, may be persuasive because it suggests a line of reasoning). All prior judicial decisions OUTSIDE of that court's jurisdiction or from a LOWER court are considered to be persuasive only.
How does the court of appeals for the federal circuit differ from other federal courts appeals?
The United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit is the only federal court with jurisdiction that is defined by subject matter as opposed to geographic area. There are eleven other number circuits covering the geographic area of the United States, and one Federal Circuit for Washington, D.C.The United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit hears appeals from specialized trial courts, such as the United States Court of Federal Claims, and complaints arising under the patent laws. Unlike other federal courts of appeals, it hears appeals from all district courts. Uniquely, the Federal Circuit has binding precedent for the entire U.S. within the jurisdiction of its subject matter. This is unlike other Federal Courts of Appeals which have binding precedent over a geographic region, and can result in differing interpretations of federal law (commonly known as "Circuit Splits"). This typically means that in regards to its subject matter, the Federal Circuit is typically the last word, as most of its cases will not be heard by the US Supreme Court.AnswerThe jurisdiction is different.There are thirteen United States Courts of Appeals Circuit Courts comprising the intermediate appellate step between the District Courts and the Supreme Court.The United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit is the only court with nationwide jurisdiction over courts with special subject matter jurisdiction, such as appeals from:US Court of Federal ClaimsUS Court of International TradeUS Court of Veterans' ClaimsUS Trademark Trial and Appeal Boardpatent casesUS contractor disputesappeals from several departmental boards and commissionsappeals under certain Acts of Congress.The other twelve US Court of Appeals Circuit Courts have territorial jurisdiction over US District Courts located within Circuit's regional parameters. US District Courts have original (trial) jurisdiction over cases of general jurisdiction (the majority of federal civil and criminal cases) that occur within the boundaries of their district.
How does the Court of Appeals for the federal circuit differ from other federal Court of Appeals?
The United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit is the only federal court with jurisdiction that is defined by subject matter as opposed to geographic area. There are eleven other number circuits covering the geographic area of the United States, and one Federal Circuit for Washington, D.C.The United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit hears appeals from specialized trial courts, such as the United States Court of Federal Claims, and complaints arising under the patent laws. Unlike other federal courts of appeals, it hears appeals from all district courts. Uniquely, the Federal Circuit has binding precedent for the entire U.S. within the jurisdiction of its subject matter. This is unlike other Federal Courts of Appeals which have binding precedent over a geographic region, and can result in differing interpretations of federal law (commonly known as "Circuit Splits"). This typically means that in regards to its subject matter, the Federal Circuit is typically the last word, as most of its cases will not be heard by the US Supreme Court.AnswerThe jurisdiction is different.There are thirteen United States Courts of Appeals Circuit Courts comprising the intermediate appellate step between the District Courts and the Supreme Court.The United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit is the only court with nationwide jurisdiction over courts with special subject matter jurisdiction, such as appeals from:US Court of Federal ClaimsUS Court of International TradeUS Court of Veterans' ClaimsUS Trademark Trial and Appeal Boardpatent casesUS contractor disputesappeals from several departmental boards and commissionsappeals under certain Acts of Congress.The other twelve US Court of Appeals Circuit Courts have territorial jurisdiction over US District Courts located within Circuit's regional parameters. US District Courts have original (trial) jurisdiction over cases of general jurisdiction (the majority of federal civil and criminal cases) that occur within the boundaries of their district.
How does the court of appeals for the federal circuit differ from other federal courts of appeals?
The United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit is the only federal court with jurisdiction that is defined by subject matter as opposed to geographic area. There are eleven other number circuits covering the geographic area of the United States, and one Federal Circuit for Washington, D.C.The United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit hears appeals from specialized trial courts, such as the United States Court of Federal Claims, and complaints arising under the patent laws. Unlike other federal courts of appeals, it hears appeals from all district courts. Uniquely, the Federal Circuit has binding precedent for the entire U.S. within the jurisdiction of its subject matter. This is unlike other Federal Courts of Appeals which have binding precedent over a geographic region, and can result in differing interpretations of federal law (commonly known as "Circuit Splits"). This typically means that in regards to its subject matter, the Federal Circuit is typically the last word, as most of its cases will not be heard by the US Supreme Court.AnswerThe jurisdiction is different.There are thirteen United States Courts of Appeals Circuit Courts comprising the intermediate appellate step between the District Courts and the Supreme Court.The United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit is the only court with nationwide jurisdiction over courts with special subject matter jurisdiction, such as appeals from:US Court of Federal ClaimsUS Court of International TradeUS Court of Veterans' ClaimsUS Trademark Trial and Appeal Boardpatent casesUS contractor disputesappeals from several departmental boards and commissionsappeals under certain Acts of Congress.The other twelve US Court of Appeals Circuit Courts have territorial jurisdiction over US District Courts located within Circuit's regional parameters. US District Courts have original (trial) jurisdiction over cases of general jurisdiction (the majority of federal civil and criminal cases) that occur within the boundaries of their district.
How does the Court of Appeals for the federal circuit differ from the other federal Court of Appeals?
The United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit is the only federal court with jurisdiction that is defined by subject matter as opposed to geographic area. There are eleven other number circuits covering the geographic area of the United States, and one Federal Circuit for Washington, D.C.The United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit hears appeals from specialized trial courts, such as the United States Court of Federal Claims, and complaints arising under the patent laws. Unlike other federal courts of appeals, it hears appeals from all district courts. Uniquely, the Federal Circuit has binding precedent for the entire U.S. within the jurisdiction of its subject matter. This is unlike other Federal Courts of Appeals which have binding precedent over a geographic region, and can result in differing interpretations of federal law (commonly known as "Circuit Splits"). This typically means that in regards to its subject matter, the Federal Circuit is typically the last word, as most of its cases will not be heard by the US Supreme Court.AnswerThe jurisdiction is different.There are thirteen United States Courts of Appeals Circuit Courts comprising the intermediate appellate step between the District Courts and the Supreme Court.The United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit is the only court with nationwide jurisdiction over courts with special subject matter jurisdiction, such as appeals from:US Court of Federal ClaimsUS Court of International TradeUS Court of Veterans' ClaimsUS Trademark Trial and Appeal Boardpatent casesUS contractor disputesappeals from several departmental boards and commissionsappeals under certain Acts of Congress.The other twelve US Court of Appeals Circuit Courts have territorial jurisdiction over US District Courts located within Circuit's regional parameters. US District Courts have original (trial) jurisdiction over cases of general jurisdiction (the majority of federal civil and criminal cases) that occur within the boundaries of their district.
How does the Court of Appeals of the federal circuit differ from other federal courts of appeals?
The United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit is the only federal court with jurisdiction that is defined by subject matter as opposed to geographic area. There are eleven other number circuits covering the geographic area of the United States, and one Federal Circuit for Washington, D.C.The United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit hears appeals from specialized trial courts, such as the United States Court of Federal Claims, and complaints arising under the patent laws. Unlike other federal courts of appeals, it hears appeals from all district courts. Uniquely, the Federal Circuit has binding precedent for the entire U.S. within the jurisdiction of its subject matter. This is unlike other Federal Courts of Appeals which have binding precedent over a geographic region, and can result in differing interpretations of federal law (commonly known as "Circuit Splits"). This typically means that in regards to its subject matter, the Federal Circuit is typically the last word, as most of its cases will not be heard by the US Supreme Court.AnswerThe jurisdiction is different.There are thirteen United States Courts of Appeals Circuit Courts comprising the intermediate appellate step between the District Courts and the Supreme Court.The United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit is the only court with nationwide jurisdiction over courts with special subject matter jurisdiction, such as appeals from:US Court of Federal ClaimsUS Court of International TradeUS Court of Veterans' ClaimsUS Trademark Trial and Appeal Boardpatent casesUS contractor disputesappeals from several departmental boards and commissionsappeals under certain Acts of Congress.The other twelve US Court of Appeals Circuit Courts have territorial jurisdiction over US District Courts located within Circuit's regional parameters. US District Courts have original (trial) jurisdiction over cases of general jurisdiction (the majority of federal civil and criminal cases) that occur within the boundaries of their district.
How does the Court of Appeals for circuit differ from other federal courts of appeals?
The United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit is the only federal court with jurisdiction that is defined by subject matter as opposed to geographic area. There are eleven other number circuits covering the geographic area of the United States, and one Federal Circuit for Washington, D.C.The United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit hears appeals from specialized trial courts, such as the United States Court of Federal Claims, and complaints arising under the patent laws. Unlike other federal courts of appeals, it hears appeals from all district courts. Uniquely, the Federal Circuit has binding precedent for the entire U.S. within the jurisdiction of its subject matter. This is unlike other Federal Courts of Appeals which have binding precedent over a geographic region, and can result in differing interpretations of federal law (commonly known as "Circuit Splits"). This typically means that in regards to its subject matter, the Federal Circuit is typically the last word, as most of its cases will not be heard by the US Supreme Court.AnswerThe jurisdiction is different.There are thirteen United States Courts of Appeals Circuit Courts comprising the intermediate appellate step between the District Courts and the Supreme Court.The United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit is the only court with nationwide jurisdiction over courts with special subject matter jurisdiction, such as appeals from:US Court of Federal ClaimsUS Court of International TradeUS Court of Veterans' ClaimsUS Trademark Trial and Appeal Boardpatent casesUS contractor disputesappeals from several departmental boards and commissionsappeals under certain Acts of Congress.The other twelve US Court of Appeals Circuit Courts have territorial jurisdiction over US District Courts located within Circuit's regional parameters. US District Courts have original (trial) jurisdiction over cases of general jurisdiction (the majority of federal civil and criminal cases) that occur within the boundaries of their district.
How does the court of appeal for federal circuit differ from other federal courts of appeals?
The United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit is the only federal court with jurisdiction that is defined by subject matter as opposed to geographic area. There are eleven other number circuits covering the geographic area of the United States, and one Federal Circuit for Washington, D.C.The United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit hears appeals from specialized trial courts, such as the United States Court of Federal Claims, and complaints arising under the patent laws. Unlike other federal courts of appeals, it hears appeals from all district courts. Uniquely, the Federal Circuit has binding precedent for the entire U.S. within the jurisdiction of its subject matter. This is unlike other Federal Courts of Appeals which have binding precedent over a geographic region, and can result in differing interpretations of federal law (commonly known as "Circuit Splits"). This typically means that in regards to its subject matter, the Federal Circuit is typically the last word, as most of its cases will not be heard by the US Supreme Court.AnswerThe jurisdiction is different.There are thirteen United States Courts of Appeals Circuit Courts comprising the intermediate appellate step between the District Courts and the Supreme Court.The United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit is the only court with nationwide jurisdiction over courts with special subject matter jurisdiction, such as appeals from:US Court of Federal ClaimsUS Court of International TradeUS Court of Veterans' ClaimsUS Trademark Trial and Appeal Boardpatent casesUS contractor disputesappeals from several departmental boards and commissionsappeals under certain Acts of Congress.The other twelve US Court of Appeals Circuit Courts have territorial jurisdiction over US District Courts located within Circuit's regional parameters. US District Courts have original (trial) jurisdiction over cases of general jurisdiction (the majority of federal civil and criminal cases) that occur within the boundaries of their district.
Where is The Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit is located?
The court of appeals for the federal circuit is located in Washington, D.C.
