answersLogoWhite

0

For a given outer diameter, the solid shaft is stronger, but it weighs more.

For a given weight, the hollow shaft is stronger because it has a bigger diameter.
due to less weight & less bending moment..............
the resultant bending moment for a solid pipe is much larger than for a hollow one because of their weight difference

User Avatar

Wiki User

11y ago

What else can I help you with?

Related Questions

What is stronger a round steel pipe or a steel hollow square bar?

By stronger, we need to define the loading conditions of the rod or pipe. The strength of a rod or pipe is typically evaluated with axial, transverse (bending), and torsion loads. With the same diameter and the same material, a solid rod is stronger than a hollow pipe. However, with the same weight and material, the hollow pipe is stronger than a solid rod. Because a hollow pipe is lighter than a solid rod at the same diameter, the hollow pipe would have a larger diameter in order to match weights with the solid rod and a larger diameter rod or pipe is stronger than a smaller diameter one.


Can you make hollow steel pipe stronger by filling it with sand or expandable foam that turn it hard?

yes you certainly can mate


What stronge ss pipe or black pipe?

Carbon Steel pipe is stronger than stainless steel pipe as there is more iron in the carbon steel. However, the application depends on the purpose the pipe is being installed. Stainless is of course capable of being sanitized and therefore can be used for food and pharmaceutical uses. Carbon Steel (black pipe) is stronger and cheaper but not sanitary.


How much does a solid steel pipe 6 inches round by 24 inches long weight?

"Solid Steel" would not be a pipe- it would be a rod. Weight of pipe will vary depending on the thickness of the wall of the pipe.


How can you get the weight for steel pipe?

assuming it's hollow. 10.68*ID*(OD-ID)


How is a seamless pipe made?

it is extruded through a mold. metal pipe is poured semi molten through a mold and forced out the other side. plastic is molten and forced thru a mold as well. there used to be a play-doh machine that would make a play-doh tube. then you could see how it's done.


Why does copper pipe pucker when bent?

Pipe is hollow, it needs to be solid when being bent. This can be with the aid of a solid mandrel, spring or even sand on the inside. With the pipe now a solid and if the bend radius isn't to sharp there should be no puckers when bending.


What is the weight per meter of 40 mm dia ms pipe hallow pipe?

The weight of a hollow MS (mild steel) pipe depends on the thickness of the pipe wall. The weight can be calculated by using the formula: Weight = 0.02466 * Thickness * (Outer Diameter - Thickness) for a round hollow pipe.


What are the advantages of steel tubing?

In some cases, depending on the size and weight of tubular steel pipe vs the same or similar size solid steel bar, the tubular steel might be stronger. The molecular structure of the solid steel have the molecules stacked close together, any shock or stress will compress the molecules closer together with no place to go unless the steel bends or breaks. A steel tube has the hollow area which allows shock or stress to be released, it will be less likely to bend or break. It also depends on what the application is tubular steel will definitely be lighter in weight, can be filled, run wiring or plastic tubing through it. Cost is cheaper.


What is 20 mm mild steel square hollow pipe 14 gauge standard weight?

14 gauge


What is weight of ms hollow section pipe 60x60x3.2mm?

To calculate the weight of a mild steel hollow section pipe with dimensions 60x60x3.2 mm, you can use the formula for the weight of a hollow square section: Weight = (Outer area - Inner area) × Density. The outer dimensions are 60 mm x 60 mm, and the wall thickness is 3.2 mm, giving an inner dimension of 53.6 mm x 53.6 mm. The density of mild steel is approximately 7850 kg/m³. The resulting weight is approximately 3.94 kg per meter of the hollow section pipe.


Does Australia export steel pipe and tubes?

China is a large country to export steel pipe, if you want to buy steel pipe, you can import from China.