What argument do you think is most logical between Thomas Paine or John Dickson?

Answer 1

Both Thomas Paine and John Dickinson presented compelling arguments during the American Revolution, but Paine's case in "Common Sense" is often seen as more persuasive due to its emotional appeal and clarity. Paine argued for immediate independence from Britain, emphasizing the absurdity of monarchy and advocating for a democratic government, which resonated with many colonists. In contrast, Dickinson's approach in his "Letters from a Farmer in Pennsylvania" focused on reconciliation and reform rather than outright separation, which may have seemed less urgent in the face of escalating tensions. Ultimately, Paine's call for revolution galvanized public sentiment and mobilized support for independence.