What was the problem with the periodisation of Indian history that James mill offers?

Answer 1

James Mill's periodization of Indian history was problematic because it oversimplified and misrepresented the complexities of India's diverse cultures and historical developments. He divided Indian history into three distinct periods—Hindu, Muslim, and British—without adequately acknowledging the rich interactions and continuities between these eras. This linear and Eurocentric perspective marginalized indigenous narratives and contributions, leading to a skewed understanding of India's past. Additionally, it reinforced colonial attitudes by portraying Indian society as stagnant and in need of Western intervention for progress.