answersLogoWhite

0

Just Black dissented because of his absolutist belief that Congress shall make "no law" abridging the freedom of speech, and probably because of a similarly absolute view on the constitutional mandate of a "public" trial under the Sixth Amendment.

He did not believe that the Constitution provides the right to a "fair trial" above the provisions in the Bill of Rights.

User Avatar

Wiki User

14y ago

What else can I help you with?

Related Questions

What was the concurring opinion on Sheppard v Maxwell?

maxwell got ten years in prison for not giving sheppard a fair trial


Do you agree more with Justice Fortas and opinion or Justice Black and dissent Give reasons for your answer.?

I lean more toward Justice Fortas's opinion, as it emphasizes the importance of protecting individual rights and freedoms under the Constitution, particularly in the context of due process. Fortas's perspective acknowledges the evolving nature of society and the necessity of adapting legal interpretations to safeguard personal liberties. In contrast, Justice Black's dissent, while advocating for strict adherence to constitutional text, may overlook the practical implications of rigid interpretations in contemporary contexts. Balancing foundational principles with the realities of modern governance is crucial for a just legal system.


What document did justice black criticize as part of his argument in the dissent?

the majority opinion. -apex


What Black claims at the end of the dissent that as a result of the Court's decision the Court will?

What Black claims at the end of the dissent is that as a result of the Court's decision, it will have caused the First Amendment to suffer a "devastating blow" by allowing the government to silence dissenting voices.


How and why did John Locke write the second government?

He did it by getting with Jack Sheppard on the island and beating the black smoke.


Who sings the songs wings?

Maxwell. Its from his album Black Summer's Night.


Is Victoria Justice black?

No she is not.


Who sings the song 'pretty wings'?

Maxwell. Its from his album Black Summer's Night.


Where can I buy Maxwell Black's book Joint Resolution?

Its available on Amazon as an ebook


When will Maxwell's trilogy CD Black Summer Nights be released?

Maxwell releases his album trilogy early 09. Columbia his record company is timing the release carefully.Snillits of new material can be heard on Maxwell's MySpace site.


Is there Justice in the book black boy?

I don't think there is but there is a girl justice


Does Victoria Justice have a black iPhone?

Yes she have black iPhone