answersLogoWhite

0

The Bible is in no way historically accurate.

Lester L Grabbe (Ancient Israel: What Do We Know and How Do We Know It?) makes the following comments on biblical accuracy, based on the consensus of modern historians and archaeologists:

  • On the whole, the biblical text is problematic for Iron I (and the earlier periods). Its picture of a massive exodus and rapid unitary conquest do not match either written records or archaeology.
  • There is nothing in Egyptian texts that could be related to the story in the Book of Exodus. He says that despite the efforts of some fundamentalist arguments, there is no way to salvage the biblical text as a description of a historical event.
  • Not much can be found in the Book of Judges that can be supported.
  • The bulk of the DtrH's text [Joshua, Judges, 1 Samuel, 2 Samuel, 1 Kings and 2 Kings] is not of great value for historical events, though it can be of use for sociological study and of course for literary, theological and other non-historical disciplines of the Hebrew Bible.
  • In some cases, material has clearly been inserted for theological reasons.
  • There is a gradual increase in reliability the later the DtrH narrative progresses. In the last years of the kings of Judah, when there are times that we know what was happening year by year, the biblical text can be remarkable accurate.
  • Prophetic stories do not generally make good historical sources.
  • Stories in the Book of Daniel about Nebuchadnezzar seem at least in part based on legends rising out of the reign of Nabonidus. This was first recognised by W. von Soden but confirmed in a startling way by the discovery of 4Q Prayer of Nabonidus. This last is a Dead Sea scroll, the text of which is intermediate between Babylonian texts and Daniel, thus showing one of the fictional sources used by the author of Daniel.


Grabbe provides a catalog of biblical errors, one of which is a reference in 1 Kings 21 to a Ben-Haddad who was active in the time of Ahab, yet we know that the king of Damascus at this time was Hadadezer. An explanation that has become widely accepted in scholarship is that 1 Kings 20-22 contains material from the later Jehu dynasty (e.g. 2 Kings 13) which has been mistakenly been assigned to the reign of Ahab.

Robert P. Carroll (The World of Ancient Israel: Sociological, Anthropological and Political Perspectives, Prophecy and society) says that with regard to the biblical text we can never be sure how much of the story of the prophets is propaganda and the manipulation of information and how much was untainted by editorial control.

Andrew D. H. Mayes (The World of Ancient Israel: Sociological, Anthropological and Political Perspectives, Sociology and the Old Testament) says that it is becoming clear that the presentation of Yahweh as the only God of Israel in the pre-monarchic period is a late construction which runs up against great historical difficulties.

Ranke-Heinemann (Putting Away Childish Things) says that the whole of Acts of the Apostles, the New Testament 'book of history', is a work of propaganda aimed at Gentile Christians and Gentiles who have not yet become Christians. Hans Joachim Schoeps writes that Acts has been "believed much too readily."
User Avatar

Wiki User

∙ 10y ago
User Avatar

What else can I help you with?

Related Questions

Did Sir William M Ramsay attempt to disprove the Bible when he was a young archaeologist?

The short answer is ... Yes and no. He questioned the historical accuracy of the bible. In his quest to point out inconsistencies of Bible through archaeology, he discovered archaeological evidence to support the Bible as historically accurate.


What discoveries in Mesopotamia prove that the Bible is an accurate historical book?

No discoveries in Mesopotamia prove that the Bible is an accurate historical book, otherwise modern scholars would have to regard it as such. Most modern scholars accept accounts in the Bible as historically true only so far as they are confirmed by extra-biblical sources. They see the Bible as true in parts, but not in total.


Could the Bible be better described as the book of wives tales?

No. There is much wisdom and sense in the bible, as with most religious texts. Though not historically accurate and often self contradictory there is still much to be said for all such works.


What are the release dates for The Historically Accurate Story of Thanksgiving - 2011?

The Historically Accurate Story of Thanksgiving - 2011 was released on: USA: 23 November 2011


Was Cheyenne Autumn historically accurate?

yes


Is “The Passion of the Christ” historically accurate?

Bob


What are the release dates for If Disney Cartoons Were Historically Accurate - 2013?

If Disney Cartoons Were Historically Accurate - 2013 was released on: USA: 20 May 2013 (internet)


Is the movie Brigham Young historically accurate?

yes


Is the New American Bible copyright in 1970 an accurate Bible?

Yes. Most modern translations are accurate.


Why is the Bible a big load of crap?

The Bible is considered sacred text by many people around the world and holds religious significance. It is important to approach discussions about beliefs and religious texts with respect and open-mindedness. It is okay to have differing opinions, but it is important to express them in a respectful manner.


Is The Bible scientifically accurate?

no


What is the distinction you have to make when reading the Bible?

To truly understand the Bible you need to make a distinction between what is historically true and what is purely inspirational.