answersLogoWhite

0


Best Answer

That's a very subjective question.

Different orthodox Jews follow different traditions, and even among themselves there are some who might think others are taking it "too far".


Some only eat kosher, and will go hungry before eating anything else. Others might have a kosher home, but might sporadically eat at a restaurant. Some might pray twice a day, while others just every shabat. There is no set of rules or traditions that every orthodox Jew everywhere follows, all the time, everywhere.


Each people might have a different perception of what "too far" is, depending on every person's own tradition and set of religious ideas. I'm from a reform tradition, but I might differ with you and think that something you consider is "extreme" is still normal for me.

User Avatar

Wiki User

14y ago
This answer is:
User Avatar

Add your answer:

Earn +20 pts
Q: Do Orthodox Jews take Sabbath rules too far?
Write your answer...
Submit
Still have questions?
magnify glass
imp
Continue Learning about Music & Radio

What is shabbat in Jewish religion?

The Jewish sabbath begins at sundown on Friday and ends at sundown on Saturday. It is practiced because it is one of the commandments given by God to the Jews in the Torah. The Torah is the first five books of the Bible (Genesis, Exodus, Leviticus, Numbers, Dueteronomy) which traditional Jews believe were given directly from God to Moses. The Sabbath (shabbat in Hebrew) is mentioned in numerous places in the Torah -- in Genesis, Exodus, and Dueteronmy the Jews are commanded to "remember the sabbath day and keep it holy ... six days shall you labor and do all of your work but the seventh day is a sabbath to the Lord your God, you shall not do any work ..." The Sabbath is a reminder of the creation story in the Bible -- God worked for six days to create the world and rested on the seventh. To remember this, Jews also rest completely on the seventh day. Traditional Judaism contains a legal system called halacha. This legal system defined the word "work" (melacha in Hebrew) in a very broad way. 39 different types of labor are forbidden on the sabbath -- everything from pruning to lighting a fire to writing to cooking. Orthodox Jews maintain these rules quite strictly. As new technology is introduced, there are many discussions about whether it violates one of the 39 categories of labor and whether the technology can be used on shabbat. Orthodox Jews do not drive, use electricity or phones, go to work, write, touch or use money from sundown Friday to sundown Saturday. It is a day of complete rest -- people go to synagogue, pray, eat meals that were prepared before the sabbath, meet with friends, study religious topics, sing, sleep, take walks and similar activities. In modern times, liberal Jews understand the idea of shabbat as a time for rest and reflection but they do not necessarily follow all of the rules above. This is one of the main dividing lines between Orthodox Judaism and more liberal forms of Judaism. Keeping shabbat strictly (being shomer shabbat) is one of the signs of being an Orthodox Jew.


When did the Sabbath take place?

In Judaism, the Sabbath is on Saturday (Friday sundown until Saturday after twilight).


Can a Jew Disembark from a ship on the sabbath?

There is no prohibition against marrying during Shabbat. However, there is a prohibition against playing musical instruments during Shabbat. Due to the prohibition against musical instruments, Jewish weddings are not held during Shabbat.


What is the significance of the Sabbath day for us today?

Basically, it has the same significance as it did when first given to Adam and Eve. It is a day of rest and remembrance for mankind of God and His Creation. After the fall of both the Northern and Southern Kingdoms of Israel/Judah, primarily due to their disregard for the Sabbath Law (see Jeremiah 17:21-22; Ezekiel 20:12, etals), the Jews were determined not to commit this same error again. They began to make 39 new definitions of what not to do on this day - with its minutia, it became over 200 restrictions and totally burdensome for anyone. Jesus came to clearly show how both the physical and spiritual intent of the Sabbath Law was to be followed. He did not come to destroy the Law but to fill it to its full intent (Matthew 5:17-18). All disciples of Christ follow the Sabbath. The Bible speaks of a Millennial Rule of Christ in the Book of Revelation. In a larger sense, this 1,000 year period is a Sabbath rest in itself. God's laws will be written upon our hearts which will no longer be of 'stone.' Christ and His firstfruits will be there to insure we Focus on the Father and live by every word of God.


How do you play Bowling?

That would take a lot of verbage to do. Click on the 'Rules of Bowling' link below to see the rules of the game along with links that will take you to more information about the game.

Related questions

What is shabbat in Jewish religion?

The Jewish sabbath begins at sundown on Friday and ends at sundown on Saturday. It is practiced because it is one of the commandments given by God to the Jews in the Torah. The Torah is the first five books of the Bible (Genesis, Exodus, Leviticus, Numbers, Dueteronomy) which traditional Jews believe were given directly from God to Moses. The Sabbath (shabbat in Hebrew) is mentioned in numerous places in the Torah -- in Genesis, Exodus, and Dueteronmy the Jews are commanded to "remember the sabbath day and keep it holy ... six days shall you labor and do all of your work but the seventh day is a sabbath to the Lord your God, you shall not do any work ..." The Sabbath is a reminder of the creation story in the Bible -- God worked for six days to create the world and rested on the seventh. To remember this, Jews also rest completely on the seventh day. Traditional Judaism contains a legal system called halacha. This legal system defined the word "work" (melacha in Hebrew) in a very broad way. 39 different types of labor are forbidden on the sabbath -- everything from pruning to lighting a fire to writing to cooking. Orthodox Jews maintain these rules quite strictly. As new technology is introduced, there are many discussions about whether it violates one of the 39 categories of labor and whether the technology can be used on shabbat. Orthodox Jews do not drive, use electricity or phones, go to work, write, touch or use money from sundown Friday to sundown Saturday. It is a day of complete rest -- people go to synagogue, pray, eat meals that were prepared before the sabbath, meet with friends, study religious topics, sing, sleep, take walks and similar activities. In modern times, liberal Jews understand the idea of shabbat as a time for rest and reflection but they do not necessarily follow all of the rules above. This is one of the main dividing lines between Orthodox Judaism and more liberal forms of Judaism. Keeping shabbat strictly (being shomer shabbat) is one of the signs of being an Orthodox Jew.


Did Jesus die on a weekly sabbath day?

Jesus died clearly on what is called Good Friday, as the Jews would not do any form of work , or take the life of people on the cross on a sabbath.


What do the orthodox Jews believe about pain management?

It is perfectly permissible to take medications or have medical procedures in order to lessen one's pain.


What do the Jews do after their meal on sabbath day?

One or more of the following: learn Torah, read, talk, take a leisurely stroll, visit family and friends, rest...


When was Take This Sabbath Day created?

Take This Sabbath Day was created on 2000-02-09.


What if someone dies on the Sabbath?

Death announcements don't take place until AFTER the Sabbath.


When did the Sabbath take place?

In Judaism, the Sabbath is on Saturday (Friday sundown until Saturday after twilight).


Which Jews celebrate the biblical holiday of Shavuot?

Shavuot is recognized as a festival by all branches of Judaism, Orthodox, Reform, Conserviative. However, of the three pilgrimage festivals, it is the most frequently ignored. (Despite the good food, since cheesecake is a traditioinal food for Shavuot.) I have been to Orthodox synagogues where hardly anyone showed up for Shavuot, and I have been to Reform synagogues that were crowded on Shavuot. Even so it is probable that more Orthodox Jews take Shavuot seriously.


Do Jews Christians and Muslims work on the Sabbath?

Muslims ViewRegarding Muslims, They, per Islam religion teachings, do not believe in the saying that God took rest in Sabbath after creating the universe. Muslims, per Quran and prophet Muhammad teachings, believe that Allah (God in English and same God in Christianity and Judaism) is free from the human normal feelings as tired, relaxed, exhausted, needing rest, .... God when requires something to be just "be" then "it is". Accordingly, Muslims work on Sabbath as any other normal week day. Saturday for Muslims is a normal weekday that they may work in or having it as a holiday depending on the working rules not on specific religious rules.Jewish viewTorah-observant Jews refrain from the forbidden forms of creative labor on the Sabbath, as the Torah says (Exodus ch.20, ch.31, ch.35, and Leviticus ch.23). Christian viewMost Christian denominations do not take the Sabbath as stringently as Jews do, but refrain from work in the sense that Sunday is a day to be spent away from a person's job. However, as orthopraxis is not a major consideration in Christianity, the act of observing the Sabbath is not nearly as important as proper belief in Christ and receiving the Eucharist during the Mass.


Can Jews play sport on Saturday?

The answer really depends on how Jewish the person is. Saturday is the Sabbath for the Jews, while Sunday is the Sabbath for Christians. Most Orthodox Jews do not play sports on Saturday, (because they feel it is wrong to do so), while most Conservative and Reform Jews think it's okay to play sports on Saturday, just as most Christians feel it's okay to play sports on Sunday.


What do Jewish funerals NOT allow?

A number of things: 1. Wakes 2. Flowers 3. Music 4. Open caskets 5. Bright colored clothes 6. Caskets with adornment and metal 7. Parties Orthodox Jews tear garments, while Modern Jews wear a ribbon that gets cut. Also, Orthodox Jews cover their mirrors and take off their shoes and have friends provide cooking, cleaning, laundry, and shopping for them. When visiting Jews in mourning, no doorbells are rung and there's no yelling at the door - the door is unlocked and people walk in quietly to visit.


What would a practicing Jew do in a week?

It a typical week, a practicing Jew would do the same things as a non-Jew: go to work, have dinner with the family, do housework, watch TV, etc.Orthodox (and some non-Orthodox) practicing Jews will also pray each morning, usually before going to work, and then again in the evening before dinner.Answer:Note that many Orthodox Jews do not own a TV. In addition to the above answer, a practicing Jew says blessings before and after eating and on many other occasions. Only kosher foods are eaten. Some Torah-study will usually take place several times a week or every day. The Sabbath is kept, with its prayers and festive meals, and abstaining from work.