answersLogoWhite

0

The reason Tool doesn't allow iTunes (or any other digital music distributor) to sell their music has little to do with "illegal file sharing" or that they're simply "holding out like Metallica." True, they do put a lot of work into the physical packaging and presentation of their albums, and thus they prefer that consumers get the full artistic experience by purchasing the artwork along with the music. However, that's only half of the reason.

I believe that Tool probably WOULD allow their albums to be sold digitally if iTunes would allow them to sell them ONLY in their entirety... that is, people would NOT be able to download individual tracks. Rumor has it that iTunes has refused to make such accommodations, so the band continues to avoid digital album sales. Not sure if this is really true, but it wouldn't surprise me in the least.

If you know anything about Tool, you recognize their songs are often very lengthy (like 8+ minutes a piece) and frequently blend into one another. They're one of the few bands that truly carries on the tradition of the "concept album," and to enable people to pick and choose individual tracks from any of their albums would be to condone the bastardization of that tradition. Their albums are not simply collections of one-off pop songs. They are much more akin to epic, classical compositions with many different movements that build on, and borrow from one another to form a single cohesive work. They're meant to be experienced as a whole.

This is actually NOT so much the case for Maynard James Keenan's other bands (A Perfect Circle and Puscifer), whose albums ARE available for digital purchase on iTunes etc. I guess maybe because these bands are more song-oriented he felt it wasn't degrading the art to make them available digitally.

Not to mention, Tool have always made a conscious effort to present themselves as something of an enigma. Just listen to any interview they've ever given and it will become obvious that they're not interested in philosophical conversation or revealing much about what truly inspires them. They basically adhere to sarcasm and nonsensical comments. Thus, I wouldn't be surprised if they're boycotting iTunes "just because," so they can inspire people like you to go on the internet and hypothesize about the reasons why.

User Avatar

Wiki User

11y ago

What else can I help you with?