Is Protestantism in congruence with the early church an attempt to be catholic Why or why not and is this in fact a net gain or loss for Christianity?

Answer 1

Protestantism, emerging in the 16th century, sought to reform perceived excesses and doctrinal errors of the Catholic Church, emphasizing sola scriptura (scripture alone) and justification by faith. While some Protestant groups aim to align with early church practices, their rejection of certain Catholic traditions indicates a divergence rather than an attempt to be fully Catholic. Whether this represents a net gain or loss for Christianity is subjective; proponents argue it leads to a purer faith, while critics contend it fractures unity and tradition. Ultimately, the impact varies based on individual perspectives on ecclesiology and tradition.