What should have never happened to the Mormons?

Answer 1

From a Mormon perspective, I wouldn't say that there is anything that 'should never have happened'. Mormons believe that God is in control of all things and that He would never allow something to happen that shouldn't happen.

There have been many mistakes made and ideals not met throughout church history, but time has shown that God planned for these and that they have served as a positive influence in the lives of those involved and even people much later on. Some examples of this are:

Martin Harris losing 116 pages of the Book of Mormon manuscript - later translation of the Book of Mormon revealed that the most important parts of this section were repeated later on (see 1 Nephi 9; 1 Nephi 19:3; Words of Mormon 1:5-7) and this event served to solidify the dedication of Joseph Smith and others in their strict obedience to God.

Apostasy of early coverts in Kirtland - although devastating at the time, this event proved who were true believers and who were 'fair weather friends'. It separated the wheat from the tares and provided strength in later trials.

Zions Camp - This group of men walked from Ohio to Missouri in order to rescue their fellow saints, but once they arrived turned around and walked back without ever accomplishing what they came for. This was a difficult journey and many became seriously ill along the way. Although many saw this as a mistake and despised Joseph Smith for it, it also proved who were his most loyal followers - who later were ordained as the first Apostles in this dispensation.

Failure to establish Zion in Missouri - Although the Lord promised that Missouri would be given to the saints for the establishment of Zion, the Mormons were severely persecuted and kicked out before this promise was fulfilled, supposedly due to their unfaithfulness. This showed what kind of faithfulness and obedience would be required in Zion, and provides a future ideal for modern Mormons to strive toward.

Murder of Joseph Smith - while this was a tragic moment for all his followers, it helps to solidify the faith of Mormons everywhere that Joseph was killed rather than denying his claims. It also was a comfort to know that his trials were complete and he would now be at peace. Finally, it allowed for the succession of a new leader and the experience of learning that the death of a prophet does not mean the death of his religion.

Trek west, including the handcart tragedies - doubtless the trek west and the difficult living once they arrived in Utah was the most difficult moment in the lives of most involved. It became even more tragic in the case of the Martin and Willie handcart companies, many of whom starved and froze to death along the way. While it was difficult, it strengthened the faith and determination of all those involved. Many accounts say that these pioneers were grateful for the experience. The accounts of these pioneers serve to strengthen and support modern Mormons.

Controversies, such as polygamy and priesthood qualifications - While the reasons for these difficulties may not yet be evident, they allow followers to exercise faith that God is in control. They also continue to serve as a way to prove who is a true follower and who struggles in their faith.

In conclusion, God allows for mistakes and tragedies to happen so that He can manifest His power, prove us, and strengthen our faith. There are not things that 'should never happen', because all things are made right through God.