0
There was speculation from the time the fourth gospel was written as to just who this beloved disciple was. As with all the New Testament gospels, this gospel was originally anonymous. Later in the fourth century, after authors had been attributed to the other gospels, the Church Fathers noticed that the apostle John was not mentioned in the last gospel. They decided that the answer must be that this disciple was John. They then decided that the same disciple must have been the author of the gospel, being too modest to use his own name for this most important and beloved disciple. Thus, on the basis of speculation alone, the disciple at the foot of the cross was John, but only in the gospel now known as John's Gospel.
Wiki User
∙ 12y ago
Add your answer:
Earn +20 pts
If the apostle John was the only apostle to witness the crucifixion then why did he not write it in his own Gospel?
It is likely that John did not feel the need to repeat the detailed account of the crucifixion in his Gospel since it was already well-documented in the other Gospels. Instead, John focused on other aspects of Jesus' life and teachings to provide a unique perspective to his readers.
Who stood with John at the foot of the cross?
it wasnt a disciple, it was SalomeThe Gospel According to John Says:The only disciple that we know was present at the Crucifixion was the beloved disciple, traditionally thought to be John. He was standing with Mary, the mother of Jesus, her sister, and Mary Magdalene. When Jesus saw Mary, His mother, standing with John, he said, "Woman, behold thy son!" Then he said to John, "Behold thy mother!" From that time John took Mary into his home (John 19:26-27).
What apostale stayed with Mary at the crucifixion?
The apostle John was the only apostle who stayed with Mary, the mother of Jesus, at the foot of the cross during the crucifixion.
Did John fall with Mary to the right of the cross facing Jesus on Calvary?
There is nothing in scripture that says anything about this. The only reference to John with Mary the mother of Jesus at the cross was Jesus' plea to John. Jesus, dying on the cross, turned to John (the 'disciple whom Jesus loved' i.e. his best friend) to ask him to look after Mary as he would his own mother. It would have been the duty of Jesus, being the oldest son of Mary, to provide for her in this way in Jewish law. Similarly he asked Mary to accept John as her new 'son' who would look after her. We are told that from that moment John took Mary into his own home.
Who was the only disciple of Jesus to die of natural causes?
The disciple traditionally believed to have died of natural causes is John. He is said to have lived to an old age and died peacefully, contrasting with the deaths of other disciples who were martyred.
What disciple was with Mary when Jesus was on the cross?
It's generally thought that the Apostle John was at the crucifixion, along with several women including Jesus' mother Mary.AnswerScripture tells us that John was the only disciple to be present at the crucifixion. Jesus spoke to him from the cross to ask him to look after his mother Mary after his death.
How do we know John was an eyewitness to the arrest and crucifixion of Jesus?
A:The gospels tell us that the apostle John was at the arrest of Jesus, but there is actually no way to know whether he was an eyewitness to the crucifixion of Jesus. Certainly, if we knew that the 'disciple whom Jesus loved', found only in John's Gospel, had actually been the apostle John, we could then say that this gospel tells us that John was at the foot of the cross and therefore an eyewitness to the crucifixion. However, the association of the beloved disciple with John was only made late in the second century, and only on a speculative basis. Moreover, there is another problem, no matter who the beloved disciple was. The synoptic gospels make it quite clear that Mary, mother of Jesus, and those of his acquaintance watched from afar off, but John's Gospel says that Mary and the beloved disciple were at the foot of the cross and that Jesus charged the disciple with looking after Mary like his own mother. Both accounts could not be true, and it seems likely that John's account was an elaboration of the earlier accounts.
If the apostle John was the only apostle to witness the crucifixion then why did he not write it in his own Gospel?
It is likely that John did not feel the need to repeat the detailed account of the crucifixion in his Gospel since it was already well-documented in the other Gospels. Instead, John focused on other aspects of Jesus' life and teachings to provide a unique perspective to his readers.
John the apostle- all about his life?
Apostle John was the son of Zebedee and Salome. He was a fisherman by trade, as were his father and brother James,who was also called to be a disciple of Jesus. John is known as 'the disciple that Jesus loved' or the 'other disciple' which are the ways he refers to himself in the Gospel of John. John, along with Peter and James, were especially close to Jesus. John was present at the crucifixion and was entrusted with the care of Mary, Christ's mother. John also saw into the tomb of the risen Christ. After he witnessed the ascension of Christ into Heaven, John preached the Gospel message, and wrote the Gospel and Epistles bearing his name and also the book of Revelation. He is the only disciple believed to not have died a martyr's death.
Who was the youngest disciple of Jesus and the only one to die of old age?
John.
What John was at the crucifixion of Jesus?
Historically, it would have been possible for John the Baptist to be at the crucifixion, since Josephus tells us that John was not imprisoned and executed until 35 or 36 CE, long after the accepted time of Jesus crucifixion. However, the Bible makes no mention of John the Baptist being present, and even tells us that John was executed quite early in the mission of Jesus. So, from a historical perspective it would have been possible, but unlikely, for John the Baptist to be at the crucifixion. From a gospel perspective, John could not have been there because he himself was already dead.
Who was the only apostle at Jesus' cross?
John was the only apostle at the cross when he died.
Who was the next disciple of Jesus after Judas?
The only disciple not to desert Jesus was 'the disciple Jesus loved' - John, who was present with jesus' mother Mary, Mary Magdalene and other women at the place where Jesus ws executed. The only disciple not to desert Jesus was 'the disciple Jesus loved' - John, who was present with jesus' mother Mary, Mary Magdalene and other women at the place where Jesus ws executed.
Does the Bible have any other references to John the Apostle as the beloved of Christ other than in John's Gospel?
The "disciple whom Jesus loved" is only mentioned in John's Gospel, and there is no real proof that this disciple was really John. The Church Fathers late in the second century examined the text and declared that the "disciple whom Jesus loved" was John.
Who stood with John at the foot of the cross?
it wasnt a disciple, it was SalomeThe Gospel According to John Says:The only disciple that we know was present at the Crucifixion was the beloved disciple, traditionally thought to be John. He was standing with Mary, the mother of Jesus, her sister, and Mary Magdalene. When Jesus saw Mary, His mother, standing with John, he said, "Woman, behold thy son!" Then he said to John, "Behold thy mother!" From that time John took Mary into his home (John 19:26-27).
What apostale stayed with Mary at the crucifixion?
The apostle John was the only apostle who stayed with Mary, the mother of Jesus, at the foot of the cross during the crucifixion.
Did John fall with Mary to the right of the cross facing Jesus on Calvary?
There is nothing in scripture that says anything about this. The only reference to John with Mary the mother of Jesus at the cross was Jesus' plea to John. Jesus, dying on the cross, turned to John (the 'disciple whom Jesus loved' i.e. his best friend) to ask him to look after Mary as he would his own mother. It would have been the duty of Jesus, being the oldest son of Mary, to provide for her in this way in Jewish law. Similarly he asked Mary to accept John as her new 'son' who would look after her. We are told that from that moment John took Mary into his own home.
