0
Did Alexander Hamilton Want Equal Representation Or Proportional Representation?
Wiki User
∙ 11y ago
Add your answer:
Earn +20 pts
Where did states have representation that was proportional to their population under the Connecticut Compromise?
The compromise provided for a bicameral federal legislature that used a dual system of representation: the upper house would have equal representation from each state, while the lower house would have proportional representation based on a state's population.
How could you change equal representation in the senate?
No amendment could change equal representation in the senate without
Does the senate provide equal representation?
Inequal in representation by population, but perfect in terms of equal representation by State. The big states are equal to the smaller sized states. Bicameral legislatures seem to balance things out quite well.
What did Benjamin Franklin write?
He didn't actually *write* any of it. The development of the rules and governmental structure specified in the constitution was the work of the convention as a whole and then the final wording was turned over to a committee of style. Franklin's most significant contribution was the Great Compromise. There was a significant divide between the more populous states who wanted representation in congress to be based on population and the smaller states who wanted equal representation. The disagreement seemed insoluble and the convention was in danger of breking up over the issue. Franklin proposed that the House of Representatives have proportional representation and the Senate have equal representation. this compromise was excepted and the rest, as they say, is history. Michael Montagnehe didnt...duhh Although he helped come up with the U.S. system of governemnt as outlined in the Constitution, he did not actually write any of the document.
What is the meaning of equal representation?
When all 3 branches of government is equal. Neither branch has more power than the other. ______________________________________ Equal representation : Each region has the same number of elected representatives.
Where did states have representation that was proportional to their population under the Connecticut Compromise?
The compromise provided for a bicameral federal legislature that used a dual system of representation: the upper house would have equal representation from each state, while the lower house would have proportional representation based on a state's population.
What are the good and bad aspects of equal representation?
I assume you are referring to how the states are represented in the federal legislature. The small states wanted equal representation; that is, they wanted all states, regardless of population size, to have the same number of votes in the congress. The large states argued in favor of proportional representation, where votes would be apportioned by the size of the population. The compromise was, of course, to have a bicameral legislature, one with two houses, one having proportional representation, the other having equal representation.
How does bicameralism in Congress reflect the principle of federalism?
By giving each State equal representation in the Senate and representation proportional to its population in the House, bicameralism ensures a division of power.
Congress is made up of the?
House of Representatives (435 representatives) chosen through proportional representation. Senate (100 senators) chosen by equal representation, 2 senators for each state.
Define proportional representation?
Proportional representation is an electoral system in which the number of seats a political party wins in an election is proportional to the number of votes it receives. This system ensures that the share of seats a party holds accurately reflects the support it has among the electorate. It is designed to provide fair representation for a diverse range of viewpoints in government.
What is the difference between equal and proportional representation?
Equal representation means each region or state is represented by the same number of elected representatives. Proportional representation, on the other hand, means that the number of seats won by a party is proportionate to the received number of votes.
The Great Compromise settled which key issue at the Constitutional Convention?
The Great Compromise settled the dispute of state representation in the U.S. Congress. It was decided that representation in the U.S. House of Representatives would be proportional to population, while representation in the U.S. Senate would be equal among all states.
Is senators elected based on equal representation or proportional representation?
The representation of states in the United States Senate is based on equal representation. Every state, regardless of size, elects two senators; in contrast, the number of seats a state has in the House of Representatives is based on that state's population. This difference arose out of the conflict between the Virginia Plan and the New Jersey Plan put forth at the Philadelphia Convention. The Virginia Plan proposed that representation in the legislature be based on either a state's population or its monetary contribution to the federal government, whereas the New Jersey Plan proposed an equal distribution of seats in the legislature to all states. The agreed upon compromise between these two plans, called the Connecticut Compromise, established two houses: the House of Representatives, based on proportional representation, and the Senate, based on equal representation.
Is weight and mass proportional but not equal?
true or false. weight and mass are proportional but not equal
The pressure of an ideal gas is indirectly proportional to?
Other things being equal, it is directly proportional to the temperature. It is also directly proportional to the amount of gas.Other things being equal, it is directly proportional to the temperature. It is also directly proportional to the amount of gas.Other things being equal, it is directly proportional to the temperature. It is also directly proportional to the amount of gas.Other things being equal, it is directly proportional to the temperature. It is also directly proportional to the amount of gas.
When did it take place the great compromised?
The Great Compromise took place during the Constitutional Convention of 1787, where delegates resolved the issue of representation in Congress by creating a bicameral legislature with equal representation in the Senate and proportional representation in the House of Representatives. This compromise helped establish the framework for the United States government.
What developed between the large and small states over how representation should be chosen for the new government?
At the Constitutional Convention, states with huge populations want proportional representation. Small states wanted equal representation. The compromise consisted of the House of Representatives apportioned by population, and the Senate which has two Senators from each state.
