0
How do personal relationships among Supreme Court justices affect decision making?
Wiki User
∙ 14y ago
When the justices are in conference discussing a case, they try to build consensus for their point-of-view through persuasive argument because they want their perspective to sway the majority. A friend may be psychologically more willing to accept and support a particular argument than an antagonist, but it seems most votes consistently fall along party lines (with the exception of Justice Kennedy, who is the swing vote), so ideology appears more important in judicial decision-making than friendship, although friendship may be a factor influencing support among justices with similar values and ideas.
Bear in mind that these men and women are on the bench because of their vast knowledge of the Constitution and law, as well as their demonstrated ability to reason and make decisions independently. None of them is likely to vote against their personal beliefs for the sake of friendship.
One example of friendship on the Supreme Court not interfering with judicial integrity is that of Justice Ginsburg and Justice Scalia, who are ideologically polar opposites and rarely vote the same way on a case. Outside the courtroom, however, the two are close friends who often spend free time and vacation together. Justice Ginsburg is reported to have framed pictures of the two of them together on the desk in her chambers.
Wiki User
∙ 14y ago
Add your answer:
Earn +20 pts
What influences supreme court decisions?
The justices of the US Supreme Court vote on each case that is brought before them. The decision of the court is whatever a majority of the justices agree on. Each justice has an equal say in the decision.
What is the decision of most of the justices on the Supreme Court called?
The agreed ruling of more than half of the Supreme Court justices is called a majority decision.
The strategic model of Supreme Court decision making emphasizes?
how the justices account for the views of other justices when deciding how to act
What is a written statement by most of the justices in support of a Supreme Court decision?
The agreed ruling of more than half of the Supreme Court justices is called a majority decision; the written document is called a majority opinion or the "opinion of the Court."
What is the minimum vote required in the supreme court for a decision pass?
In the US Supreme Court, a decision requires a simple majority of the justices hearing the case. If all nine justices are present, the minimum for for a majority is 5 votes of 9.
For the majority ruling on the Supreme Court there needs to be at least justices who agree?
For a majority ruling on the Supreme Court, a minimum of five out of the nine justices must agree. This is because a majority decision requires more than half of the justices to support a particular outcome or opinion. It is necessary to have a majority in order to establish a binding decision for the Court.
There are justices on the supreme courthow mean justices on the supreme court are there?
there are about how mean justices on the Supreme Court.
The Supreme Court must have a to render a decision in a case.?
The Supreme Court must have a simple majority to render a decision in a case.
What type of vote is required for a majority decision in the US Supreme Court?
For a case to be heard before the U. S. Supreme Court there must be a quorum. This requires at least six Justices to be present. There is a total of nine Justices on the Supreme Court but illness or recusals could cause less than 9 on a case. For a decision to be rendered it requires a majority of the Justices hearing the case. If all Justices are present the majority would require 5 or more to met this requirement.
If a case is being heard by the US Supreme Court what is the closest decision that can be made if all justices are there?
The Supreme Court requires a simple majority vote for a decision. If all nine justices are present, the closest possible vote would be 5-4.
What branch appointed Supreme Court Justices?
Supreme Justices are nominated by the Senate.Then, the President appoints the justices. Therefore,the executive branch appoints supreme court justices
What is a written explanation of a US Supreme Court decision called if five or more justices agree?
Five or more justices who agree on a decision form a majority. The written decision is sometimes called the "majority opinion," but is officially known as the "opinion of the Court" to signify its importance.
