0
How is the district method different than the winner take all method electoral votes?
Wiki User
∙ 6y ago
Since the election of 1824, most states have appointed their electors on a winner-take-all basis, based on the statewide popular vote on Election Day. Maine and Nebraska are the only two current exceptions, as both states use the congressional district method. In a winner-take-all state, all of the state's Electoral votes go to whichever candidate receives a majority of the popular vote, or a plurality of the popular vote (less than 50 percent but more than any other candidate). Maine and Nebraska use the "congressional district method", selecting one elector within each congressional district by popular vote and awarding two electors by a statewide popular vote.
Wiki User
∙ 6y ago
Wiki User
∙ 10y agoThere are three different types of district systems for dividing a state's electoral votes.
The one currently used in Maine and Nebraska parallels the fact that the number of electors each state may appoint equals the number of U.S. Representatives the state is entitled to (or the number of Representatives the state will be entitled to on the next Inauguration Day in the case of elections occurring in years ending with a "2") plus the number of U.S. Senators the state is entitled to. Every state is always entitled to two Senators. For every U.S. congressional district in Maine and Nebraska in which a candidate wins the popular vote, he gets an electoral vote, and since in each state there are two more electoral votes than there are congressional districts, the other two electoral votes go to the winners of the statewide popular vote.
Another system that was used by some states in the past but is not currently in use is to divide the state evenly into electoral districts, the number of which equals the number of electors. For every electoral district in which a candidate wins the popular vote, he/she gets an electoral vote, and like the nationwide popular vote, the statewide popular vote is not used.
A third system that was recently proposed in Virginia is similar to the one currently used by Maine and Nebraska except that instead of the two remaining electoral votes going to the winner of the statewide popular vote, they go to whomever wins the most congressional districts.
Add your answer:
Earn +20 pts
What is a congresional district?
The Congressional District Method (a.k.a., Maine-Nebraska Method) is an alternative way of distributing electoral votes within a state. In a winner-takes-all system, the winner of the statewide popular vote receives all of that state's electoral votes. Under the Congressional District Method, the electoral votes are distributed based on the popular vote winner within each of the state's congressional districts; the statewide popular vote winner receives two additional electoral votes.us-presidential-electorsThe number of electoral votes allocated to each state is equal to the size of the state's Congressional delegation.us-presidential-electorsThe two statewide-winner electoral votes are held to be equivalent to the two votes each state receives in the U.S. Senate. The district-wide-winner electoral votes are equivalent to that district's vote in the House of Representatives.Only maineand nebraskause the Congressional District Method for distributing their electoral votes. Maine has four electoral votes, based on its two Representatives and two Senators. Nebraska has two Senators and three Representatives, giving it five electoral votes.us-presidential-electorsMaine began using the Congressional District Method in the united-states-presidential-election-1972. Nebraska has used the Congressional District Method since the united-states-presidential-election-1992.us-presidential-electorsus-presidential-electorsThe Congressional District Method allows for the chance for states to split their electoral vote between multiple candidates. Before 2008, neither Maine nor Nebraska had ever split their electoral votes.us-presidential-electorsNebraska split its electoral votes for the first time in 2008, giving John McCain its statewide electors and those of two congressional districts, while Barack Obama won the electoral vote of nebraska-s-2nd-congressional-district.us-presidential-electorsIn addition, the Congressional District Method can be more easily implemented than other alternatives to the winner-takes-all method. State legislation is sufficient to use this method. A constitutional amendment's adoption is not needed, unlike some other Electoral College reform options.us-presidential-electorsHowever, the Congressional District Method has its downsides. For instance, candidates might only spend time in certain battleground districts instead of the entire state and cases of gerrymandercould become exacerbated as political parties attempt to draw as many safe districts as they can.us-presidential-electorsRead more: us-presidential-electors
How does the district method differ from the winner-take-all method?
hjlkkhgl
Do any states fail to have a winner take all apportionment of electoral college votes?
Maine and Nebraska allow for the splitting of their electoral votes. I think they both award one elector to the winner in each Congressional district and give the other two votes to the over-all state-wide winner.
What are the two states observe the district system for electoral votes?
Maine and Nebraska award one vote to the winner of each Congressional district and two for the state overall winner. I suppose you might this the district system.
Does primary winner get all electoral votes?
In most states, the winner of the popular vote receives all of the electoral votes. However, two states, Nebraska and Maine, allocate their electoral votes proportionally based on the winner of each congressional district and the state's overall popular vote.
Which two states do not adhere to winner take all in elections?
Nebraska and Maine do not simply award all their votes to the state-wide winner. They award one vote to the winner in each separate congressional district and two votes to the state-wide winner.
What would using either the district plan or the proportional plan to reform the electoral college?
Using either the district plan or the proportional plan to reform the electoral College would NOT ensure that the winner of the popular vote become president.
Name one state where the winner of the election is not awarded all the electoral college votes of that state?
Maine and Nebraska are the only states that do not award all of their electoral votes under multiple-winner plurality. In both states, the state at large has two electoral votes elected unti multiple-winner plurality. Each congressional district in these states also has a single electoral vote allocated using single-winner plurality, making it possible for the state to give electoral votes to multiple candidates.
Does Oregon electoral college split?
Oregon does not split its Electoral College votes. Since the election of 1824, most states have appointed their electors on a winner-take-all basis, based on the statewide popular vote on Election Day. Maine and Nebraska are the only two current exceptions, as both states use the congressional district method. Maine and Nebraska use the "congressional district method", selecting one elector within each congressional district by popular vote and awarding two electors by a statewide popular vote.
All fifty states use a winner-take-all method of granting electoral votes is it true or false?
True.
Is California a winner take all electoral vote state?
Yes, in most states. Maine and Nebraska split their votes by congressional district.
Do all electoral college votes from one state go to one candidate?
The District of Columbia and 48 U.S. states (all except Maine and Nebraska) utilize a winner-takes-all rule for the Electoral College. In a winner-take-all state, all of the state's Electoral votes go to whichever candidate receives a majority of the popular vote, or a plurality of the popular vote (less than 50 percent but more than any other candidate). Maine and Nebraska use the "congressional district method", selecting one elector within each congressional district by popular vote and awarding two electors by a statewide popular vote.
