0
The Athenian political, social and legal system was not based on ethics - it was based of pragmatism and desired result. The word we have borrowed from them today 'justice' to them meant 'settlement' - they were interested in a stable society free of internal dissent and vendettas, so they wanted disputes settled.
So the word ethical was not part of their legal system. Athens wanted a settlement, and Socrates was sowing discord and dissent amongst the youth of his day - pushing oligarchy rather than democracy, and dissent from the way matters of state and society were progressed - he was regarded as a threat to national stability and internal security.
As a consequence he was charged with corrupting the youth and with impiety. The first one tells the problem, the second tells the solution (impiety carried the death sentence).
The court was not into ethics, but rather into solutions. It comprised 500 male citizens, and like all their courts, in a small population, these numbers were effectively the equivalent of a modern opinion poll - the court was an opinion poll of the citizens as a whole. A majority wanted him dead to protect their lifestyle, and that is how they voted. Ethics didn't cross their mind.
It is not valid to judge the Athenians by today's standards (and today's standards are questionable in their inconsistency and contradictions anyway). They had a community to run in a stable fashion, and the jurors made a judgement on what they wanted their society to be like and how to achieve it.
Incidentally, the jury was the court - there were no judges and lawyers to muddy the waters - just 500 citizens chosen by lot (randomly) representing the people and giving the verdict and sentence by secret ballot. They judged Socrates a threat to the stability and harmony of their country and wanted that removed.
Wiki User
∙ 10y ago
Add your answer:
Earn +20 pts
Why does Socrates take the hemlock and drink it?
Socrates drank hemlock as his method of execution because he was sentenced to death by the Athenian courts for corrupting young minds and impiety. He chose to accept the verdict and punishment as a demonstration of his commitment to his philosophical principles and beliefs.
What happened As a result of the Yalta and Potsdam conferences?
The Allies agreed that international courts would prosecute Nazis for war crimes.
Did the socrates drink poisen ivy?
Socrates was executed by drinking hemlock, it is generally believed. I do not know if poison ivy can kill people. What I do know, though, is that European people tend to be almost immune to the effect that poison ivy has on American people (like a rash). I am a European and have tried it.
What were the revolutionary courts set up during the reign of terror used to prosecute?
tribunal
Does the US Supreme Court prosecute?
Courts are not responsible for prosecuting. Courts interpret the laws. Courts may render judgement after all the facts are introduced and both sides rest their case.
Who was an Athenian leader who established rule by assembly and people's courts with juries?
Pericles.
What did the fugitive slave act require courts to do?
Prosecute citizens failing to report anyone who looked like a runaway slave.
What was the 3 types of Athenian democracy?
The council of 500, the assembly, and the courts. They did not have the senate! Source was Wikipedia :)
What roles do lawyers and solicitors perform?
Lawyer represent individuals or entities in civil and criminal matter including litigation. A solicitor can defend and prosecute litigation in the UK courts.
Who said Know thyself?
The phrase "Know thyself" (in Greek: γνῶθι σεαυτόν) was inscribed in the Temple of Apollo at Delphi in ancient Greece. It was considered an important philosophical principle and has been attributed to several philosophers, including Socrates and Plato.
What type of court did Solon establish in ancient Rome?
tribunal
What happens if a 11 year old steals something?
This is typically a matter for the juvenile courts, if the juvenile is being prosecuted. Would have to be something that the state wishes to pursue. If something relatively small, it is doubful there will be a prosecution. The discretion lies with the District Attorney to prosecute or not. This is typically a matter for the juvenile courts, if the juvenile is being prosecuted. Would have to be something that the state wishes to pursue. If something relatively small, it is doubful there will be a prosecution. The discretion lies with the District Attorney to prosecute or not.
