Labor and Employment Law
Compensation and Benefits
Business Ethics

What is the differences in a Discretionary bonus versus non Discretionary bonus?

Top Answer
User Avatar
Wiki User
Answered 2008-01-07 21:52:54

As is generally the case in the law, it depends. The question is important because the answer dictates whether payment of a bonus is required. A discretionary bonus is based on no objective criteria and not routine, thus payment is not required. A non-discretionary bonus is paid routinely and/or based on objective criteria which may give rise to an implied contract requiring payment. A number of issues arise with respect to non-discretionary bonuses. As for the criteria used, shortages or losses usually considered a cost of doing business cannot be deducted when calculating a bonus. In one case an employer paid a bonus based on net sales. The net sales were determined by deducting cash and merchandise shortages from gross sales. This was determined to be an illegal deduction as the shortages deducted were considered costs of doing business and not the result of the employee's dishonest or willful act or other than the employee's simple negligence. An employer which does not condition earning on the employee's being employed at the time of payment runs the risk an employee who voluntarily quits may be entitled to the entire or a pro-rata share of the bonus. Furthermore, if an employee is terminated without valid cause before fulfilling the terms necessary to earn a bonus, the employee may be able to recover at least a pro-rata share of the bonus paid. In establishing a non-discretionary bonus plan, it is advisable to develop it in writing specifying all conditions necessary to earn the bonus. Accordingly, employers should consult with legal counsel to insure the terms of the bonus plan do not contain any illegal conditions or criteria.

User Avatar

Your Answer


Still Have Questions?

Related Questions

Discretionary bonus tax?

The discretionary bonus tax refers to the tax that is excludable from a given employee's regular rate of pay. The non-discretionary bonus on the other hand refers to that which must be included in the regular rate.

Differences between discretionary and non discretionary fiscal policy?

Discretionary fiscal policies are those that are enacted in response to a need, for example, a tax cut. Non-discretionary fiscal policies are those that happen regardless of conditions or need, for example, the welfare system.

What is the difference between discretionary and non discretionary spending?

Non-discretonary spending is spending that has to be spent. Discretionary spending is spending that may or may not be spent and there is a choice about what to spend the money on.

What is the opposite of vital?


What does non discretionary mean?

Required, obligatory, compulsory.

Discretionary project vs non-discretionary project?

Projects where management has a choice in implementing them are called discretionary projects. Projects where no choice exists are called nondiscretionary projects.

Distinguish between discretionary and non-discretionary fiscal policy?

Non-discretionary policies are ones that automatically happen. A progressive income tax and the welfare system both act to increase aggregate demand in recessions and to decrease aggregate demand in overheated expansions. Discretionary policies are those that the government chooses to do in response to conditions -- e.g. enact a tax rate cut.

What some are differences between a mixture of iron plus oxygen versus compound composed of iron and oxygen?

The mixture can be separated by non-chemical methods.

What is the differences of a filtered cigarette versus a non-filtered?

A filtered cig has a filter that you pull the smoke through. A non-filtered doesn't have the filter to pull the smoke through. With a non-filtered you can get bits of tobacco in your mouth while smoking.

What is non Discretionary cost?

A non-discretionary cost is one that is not completely controllable by you. Typically you may be able to exert a little influence on such costs by understanding and manipulating consumption patterns but you are not able to unilaterally completely eliminate the cost from your cost-base.

What is a non withdrawalble bonus in a online casino?

A non-withdrawable bonus from an online casino or sportsbook is a bonus you have inherited that can be placed in your slot machines, poker table, a bet etc where you receive the winnings and don't lose any of your own money if you lose the bet (just your bonus). You only receive the amount you won from your winning bet and not the bonus.

How do you get to the bonus level in Super Mario 64 DS?

There is no bonus levels. Only hidden levels & non-hidden levels.

Why is copper used in plumbing versus PVC?

Because it is NON Toxic

What are non-discretionary funds?

Amounts of money which basically have "already been spent" i.e. already encumbered by contracts or promises to pay.

What has the author Mazen I Hassounah written?

Mazen I. Hassounah has written: 'Urban spatial home-based-discretionary and non-home-based travel patterns'

What is the difference of a magnum engine versus a non magnum engine?

more horsepower on the magnum

What are the differences in municipal police versus county police?

A municipal police department is responsible for law enforcement services within the city limits. County police departments perform the same services for the non-incorporated areas within the county boundaries.

What are the differences between sinusoidal oscillators and non sinusoidal oscillators?

sinusoidal vs non sinusoidal

Explain executable versus non-executable files in DOS?

difference between executable file and non-executable file in dos

What are the five ideal elements of a good criminal law?

1. Non-Discretionary 2. Provides enough discouragement to prevent its being broken 3. Fair and objective 4. Non-draconian 5. Easy to enforce

What are the differences between ferrous metals and non-ferrous metals?


What are the differences between rotating and non rotating black holes?

non rotating dont rotate but rotating do

What is the difference between ohmic and non ohmic elements?

what are the differences between ohmic and non ohmic elements

Difference between woven and non woven fabrics?

what are the differences between woven and non woven fabrics

What is the best and strongest Platebody you can were in Runescape?

Rune hands down for Non-members. For members, its either barrows or 3rd age melee set. This costs alot, but has amazing bonuses. It has +409 slash bonus + 395 stab bonus and +381 crush bonus.