0
In parliamentary language, the term 'closure' is used to signify when the government wants to force the debate on a particular bill to end by a certain date and time. It is usually enforced when the opposition parties strongly object to one or more measures in the bill, and raise their objections at every available opportunity. It is not used simply to end a filibuster. Filibusters are rare in the parliamentary system. They tend to run out of steam quickly and on their own. 'Closure' is usually met with a hue and cry by the opposition parties, who accuse the government of muzzling parliament, stifling debate, and generally acting in an undemocratic manner. The term 'guillotine' is invariably used by the opposition, in reference to the government. There is a well developed vituperative vocabulary readily available to hurl at the government upon the slightest indication of closure. Journalists, of course, have a field day. Closure often gives new life to the issue at hand, brings the topic to the public's attention, and makes the government look bad. Therefore, it is seldom used. It also tends to heighten any hostilities between the government and opposition, and as such results in a spillover effect, where the opposition parties debate other bills more strenuously. When closure is invoked, it generally results in a 'lose-lose' situation for the government. Governments tend to prefer extending the time for debate, by scheduling morning and evening sittings of parliament, rather than invoking closure. The most memorable abuse of closure occurred in the Canadian House of Commons in 1956 over the debate on the proposed Trans-Canada Pipeline, and is thought to have been the primary reason the government was defeated at the polls the following year.
Wiki User
∙ 15y ago
Wiki User
∙ 9y ago"Cloture" refers to the process of bringing a debate to a quick end in parliamentary procedure. It is also called closure, or a guillotine. The process originated in the French National Assembly, and was introduced into the Parliament of the UK to overcome obstruction of the Irish Nationalist party. The U.S. and others adopted the process thereafter.
Wiki User
∙ 10y agoThat word is apparently "Cloture" - a word seemingly only in American legal usage.
Wiki User
∙ 12y agoanil
Wiki User
∙ 11y agocloture
Add your answer:
Earn +20 pts
What may end debate on a bill on the floor of the house?
motion to end debate
What is a procedure that may be used to limit or end floor debate in a legislative body?
Cloture
Limit on the debate of a bill in the senate?
If the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court is part of the majority, he or she gets to write the _______.
How do you end debate on a bill in the Senate before everyone is ready to do so?
AnswerThe President of the Senate decides when debate ends.AnswerUnder most circumstances, debate is forced to end by cloture, meaning the Senate votes whether to end the debate. Cloture requires 60 votes (three-fifths of the Senate) to be successful, and is followed by an up or down vote on the issue being debated.If the other party is engaged in a filibuster (rather than simple debate), a two-thirds majority vote is required to end the filibuster.The President of the Senate (who is also the Vice-President of the United States) or, in his (or her) absence, the president pro tempore, may conclude the debate ifthose wishing to end discussion exercise the nuclear option-- and special circumstances apply. Under Senate Rule 22, if a Senator calls for a "point of order" that can be upheld on constitutional grounds, the presiding officer of the Senate decides whether the Constitution supports the Senator's reasoning calling for a vote. Otherwise, the presiding officer can uphold a point of order on procedural grounds, but the Senate can vote to override his (or her) decision.So, technically, the President of the Senate can only "end" the vote on constitutional grounds, but one of the Senators has to initiate the process and justify its use.[But don't worry; the latter scenario is uncommon.]
How many votes does it take to invoke cloture in the senate?
60% of those voting are needed to stop debate on ordinary legislation. (2/3 are needed to end debate on senate rules and only 51% are needed to close debate on presidential appointments, other than for supreme court justices.)
What describes a cloture rule?
The cloture rule is a way to end a filibuster in Congress. A minimum of 16 senators must sign the petition and three-fifths of the Senate must vote to pass it.
How many seats are needed for a filibuster proof Senate?
In the United States Senate, there needs to be 60 Senators who vote to end all discussion or debate about a given bill or issue and have it move to a floor vote. The United States House of Representatives do not allow filibusters, since each member has a time limit on how much they can speak (or stall) about a piece of legislation. Filibusters can occur in the Senate for as long as there is are no group of 60 Senators who vote to stop them.
The procedure used to cut off debate and end a filibuster is known as?
cloture
What stops a fillibuster?
In the United States Senate, the rule used to stop a filibuster is called "cloture." With the approval of three-fifths of the sitting Senators, this rule sets a limit on how long the Senate can continue to debate a bill or other proposal before voting on it.
Is the filibuster a legitimate provision?
The filibuster is based on the rules of the United States Senate, but it is not mentioned in the Constitution, which says only that the Senate gets to make its own rules and procedures. whatever is part of the rules would be considered to be legitimate by most people, although not necessarily sacrosanct. Traditionally, there was no limitation on debate in the Senate, but restrictions were gradually added, allowing first 2/3 and now 60% of the Senate to vote to end debate and vote on the measure at hand. In 2013, the Senate changed the rules to end filibusters on the nominations of federal judges (except Supreme Court justices) and executive-branch positions.
How can a filibuste be stopped?
by a motion for cloture that requires 60 senators to vote to cut off debate.
What is the difference between a filibuster and closure in the senate?
A filibuster is a delay tactic to prevent a motion (e.g., a motion on a legislative bill) from being voted on by the member of the assembly in which the motion is being considered. Fillibusters extend debate on the motion to obstruct its passage. Cloture is an action that ends debate so that the assembled body may vote on the motion. Therefore, cloture can end a filibuster so that the motion may be put to the floor for a vote. In the U.S. Senate, for example, cloture can be achieved with a 3/5 vote (i.e., 60 of 100 Senators).
