On your first trip, get the bolt cutters (upper left star) and the fur from the right-hand star, the chicken farm.
On your second trip to Puerto Rico, the farmer is out to catch the chupacabra. Use the Jeep to herd 3 spotted goats into the clearing at the center star, then get out and join the farmer.
On your second trip to Puerto RicoThe box (crate) is what the farmer uses to try to catch the chupacabra. Once you corral three spotted goats at the center star (using the jeep), get out and wait with the farmer to catch the chupacabra in the box.
On your first trip to Puerto Rico, you can get some bolt cutters and some fur from a fence. But the DNA test shows it is not from the chupacabra. On your second trip, the farmer is trying to catch the chupacabra. Help him by using the jeep to corral 3 spotted goats into the clearing at the center star. Then you can get out and join him.
Go back to Puerto Rico, where the herder is planning to catch the chupacabra with a crate and some chains. Drive to Snaggletooth Rock (center star) and herd the three spotted goats into the grassy area with the jeep. They will lure the chupacabra. Get out and join the herder as you wait for the creature.
There do not appear to be any sheep anywhere on Cryptids Island. There are many goats at the Puerto Rico location, and part of the plan to catch the chupacabra involves using them as bait. After first testing the fur from the barbed wire fence, return to Puerto Rico to use the jeep to corral the three spotted goats at Snaggletooth Rock.
On your second visit to Puerto Rico, use the jeep to corral three of the spotted goats at Snaggletooth Rock (located at the center star). Once all three spotted goats are in the grass circle, leave the jeep and meet the goat herder, who has set up the large crate and lock so you can catch the chupacabra. Or at least try to.
On your first trip to Puerto Rico, drive the jeep to the house of the herder's brother (right side star). He says some fur on the fence is from the chupacabra. Take it back to run a DNA test, but it turns out to be from a wild dog.
On your second trip to Puerto Rico, the farmer will be trying to trap the chupacabra at Snaggletooth Rock (center star on the map). Drive there and use the jeep to corral 3 spotted goats into the area near the rock. Get out and meet the farmer, and soon you will capture the chupacabra (sort of).
On your first trip to Puerto Rico, all you can do is get the bolt cutters (upper left star) and the fur from the fence (right side star). When you return from testing the fur, you find the herder is out to catch the chupacabra. His brother fills you in, so you go to the Snaggletooth Rock (center star) and herd 3 of the spotted goats into the area as bait. Then you get out and wait with the herder for the chupacabra to come.
In Puerto Rico, the goat herder's brother has a chicken farm, at the right hand star on the jeep map. There is some fur on the barbed wire fence. Collect it and analyze the DNA at the Mews lab. (Unfortunately it is from a coyote. Return to Puerto Rico and talk to the herder and his brother. You can help catch the chupacabra at Snaggletooth Rock - center star on the map.)
The chupacabra can only be lured (using three goats) on your second visit to Puerto Rico. On the first, you have to get the fur from the barbed wire at the herder's brother's ranch (star at the right on the jeep map) and take it back for analysis. When you return, the herder is planning to trap the chupacabra. His brother suggests that you use the jeep to chase three spotted goats into the clearing at Snaggletooth Rock (center star). The chupacabra will come after them if you succeed. When all three are in the grass circle, get out of the jeep and join the herder.
The chupacabra can only be lured (using three goats) on your second visit to Puerto Rico. On the first, you have to get the fur from the barbed wire at the herder's brother's chicken farm (star at the right on the jeep map) and take it back for analysis. When you return, the herder is planning to trap the chupacabra. His brother suggests that you use the jeep to chase three spotted goats into the clearing at Snaggletooth Rock (center star). The chupacabra will come after them if you succeed. When all three are in the grass circle, get out of the jeep and join the herder.
The goat herder who loans you his jeep is out to catch the chupacabra when you visit Puerto Rico the second time (the first time you took back the fur sample). His brother, the chicken farmer, suggests that you herd three spotted goats into the rocks at Snaggletooth Rock (center star) to serve as bait. Once you do, meet the herder there who has set up the trap.