History of the United States
US Constitution
US Government
US Supreme Court

Why did Jefferson oppose Marshall as Chief Justice of the United States?

Top Answer
User Avatar
Wiki User
Answered 2009-11-01 23:35:00

The context of the Court is important: The whole bit was preceded by a legendary struggle between republican Jeffersonian democrats and the Hamilitonian Federalists.

The Federalists were an elitist party (later the "Whigs" and finally the current "Republicans")... consider the following:

The Federalists wanted a strong central government and had little interest in states' rights. The new party advocated a loose interpretation of the United States Constitution based on the "Necessary-and-proper clause" also known as the Elastic Clause that Hamilton used against Jefferson in arguments over the issue of a national bank. It believed that rule by a well-educated elite would serve all interests, and appealed to merchants, bankers, lawyers, editors, landowners, and industrialists; one of John Jay's favorite maxims was, "The people who own the country ought to govern it". Its most powerful leader was Hamilton and his hero was George Washington. The Party built a network of newspapers and had substantial support from religious leaders, especially in New England. Unlike the opposition Democratic-Republicans, it paid little attention to grass roots organizing.

With the elections of 1800, the Federalists were routed from power. With a lame duck Congress, the Federalists made one last attempt at a power-grab. They sought to appoint Federalist judges wherever they could.

The Marshall Court: John Marshall was the longest serving Chief Justice of the Supreme Court in American History, (1801-1836).

He was a Federalist appointed by Federalist President John Adams as part of his effort to pack the Supreme Court with federalist judges before turning over the Presidency to Thomas Jefferson, a staunch republican and anti-Federalist (the infamous "Midnight Judges").

While Marshall presided over a multitude of small cases, there are several cases in which he laid the groundwork for the strong-central government envisioned by the then diposed Federalists.

1. Marbury v. Madison (1803) gave the Court the power of judicial review.

2. U.S. v. Peters (1809) established the Court's right to coerce a state legislature

3. Martin v. Hunter's Lessee (1816) confirmed the Court's right to overrule a state court

4. Cohens v. Virginia (1821). States were no longer sovereign in all respects since they had ratified the Constitution. State courts must submit to federal jurisdiction.

5. McCullough v. Maryland (1819) upheld the right of Congress to charter a national bank, thus putting into national law the doctrine of implied powers.

6. Gibbons v. Ogden (1824) gave the national government undisputed control over interstate commerce by ruling invalid a steamboat monopoly chartered by New York state. This freed internal transportation from state restraint.

7. Fletcher v. Peck (1810) established the principle that state laws were invalid when in conflict with the Constitution

In his written opinions, Marshall typically relied on the power of logic and his own forceful eloquence, rather than citing law. This approach was noted by Associate Justice Joseph Story: "When I examine a question, I go from headland to headland, from case to case. Marshall has a compass, puts out to sea, and goes directly to the result."

Two of these cases stand above the rest: Marbury v. Madison and McCullough v. Maryland.

Marbury vs. Madison in 1803 established the Supreme Court as the final arbiter of the constitutionality of federal law. A later ruling expanded it to include state law as well. The Constitution itself is silent on the question of who determines what is or is not constitutional. And it does not provide for any means to override a Supreme Court decision other than by Constitutional amendment.

Some proponents have stated that "the legal basis and concept of judicial review predate the case, and that Marbury merely formalized it. For example, Saikrishna Prakash and John Yoo point out, with respect to the ratification of the Constitution, that "no scholar to date has identified even one participant in the ratification fight who argued that the Constitution did not authorize judicial review of Federal statutes. This silence in the face of the numerous comments on the other side is revealing." However, lack of recorded debate does not intent/law make. It is important to note that nothing in the text of the Constitution explicitly authorized the power of judicial review, despite persistent fears voiced by Anti-federalists over the power of the new Federal court system. Indeed, there is nothing in the ratification debates that cite the supremacy of the US Constitution over state law.

A second ruling of the Marshall court in 1819, (McCulloch vs. Maryland) introduced the concept of a "living constitution" and reversed the doctrine of "enumerated powers". Under enumerated powers the federal government could only exercise powers specifically given it by the Constitution. All others were reserved to the states and to the people under the Tenth Amendment. The Marshall court reversed this giving the government all power not specifically prohibited by the Constitution.

These decisions were controversial because the alternate position advanced that the states had not surrendered sovereignty upon ratification of the US Constitution. Indeed, several states included secession clauses in their ratification acts. The idea was that the Constitution set to limit the federal government. That, the Bill of Rights, was meant to specifically restrict the federal government's interactions with the various States and their citizens. Not, that the Constitution was ratified with the intent that it be supreme over state law.

Consider the import of the other cases that he presided over, they constitute a Federalist (elitist) wishlist.


User Avatar

Your Answer

Still Have Questions?

Related Questions

Who was the chief justice in 1819?

The Chief Justice of the United States in 1819 was John Marshall.

Who was Chief Justice of the United States during Thomas Jefferson's Presidency?

President John Adams nominated his Secretary of State, John Marshall, to be Chief Justice of the United States in 1801, following Adams' defeat to rival Thomas Jefferson. Marshall was a Federalist like Adams and a distant cousin of Thomas Jefferson, with whom he had a strained relationship.Chief Justice Marshall served on the Court from 1801 until his death in 1835. He had the longest tenure of any Chief Justice, and is considered the most influential leader in Supreme Court history.

What important position is John Marshall remembered for?

He was the Chief Justice of the United States

What was Thurgood marshall accomplishments in life?

Thurgood Marshall became an Associate Justice of the United States Supreme Court. He was the first African-American justice.

What did thurgood marshall?

Thurgood Marshall was a an Associate Justice of the United States Supreme Court. He was the 96th justice and it's first African American justice. He served from 1967 - 1991.

When was John Marshall appointed as Chief Justice of the United States?

Chief Justice John Marshall succeeded Oliver Ellsworth in office on January 31, 1801.

Did John Marshall serve as both Chief Justice of the United States and President of the United States?

NO-- John Marshall was never President but he was Chief Justice.William Howard Taft is the only person who every served in both capacities. (false A+)

Who did president Adams appoint as Chief Justice of the Supreme Court?

He nominated John Marshall to be Chief Justice of the United States.

What was thurgood marshall's job?

Thurgood Marshall was a justice on the Supreme Court of the United States. He was the first African- American ever to be appointed as a justice.

Thurgood marshall's parents?

Thurgood Marshall was the Associate Justice of the United States Supreme Court. William Marshall was Thurgood Marshall's father and Norma Africa Marshall was his mother.

Who was Chief Justice of the United States from 1801-1835?

Chief Justice John Marshall lead the Court from 1801 until his death in 1835.

What the Sedition act?

John Marshall, as chief justice of the United States, helped to strengthen the judicial branch of government by

Who was marshall university named after?

Marshall university is named after John Marshall, who was the fourth chief justice in the United States of America. The university now has over 14,000 students and 700 staff.

When was John Marshall appointed to the US Supreme Court?

Federalist President John Adams nominated his Secretary of State, John Marshall, to the office of Chief Justice of the United States (Supreme Court) in February 1801, after losing the 1800 Presidential election to Thomas Jefferson. Marshall succeeded Oliver Ellsworth, who was in poor health and agreed to step down to prevent Jefferson from nominating his successor.

What is the title of head justice?

In the United States, the title of the head of justice is Chief Justice of the United States. The Chief Justice is the head of the United States federal court system.

In what branch of government did Thurgood Marshall serve as?

As an associate justice on the United States Supreme Court, he served in the judicial branch.

What European country did Jefferson believe was a threat to the United states?

Thomas Jefferson believed that France was a threat to the United States. Thomas Jefferson was the 3rd president of the United States.

When was United States Department of Justice created?

United States Department of Justice was created in 1870.

What is the budget of United States Department of Justice?

The budget of United States Department of Justice is 27,700,000,000 dollars.

Who became Chief Justice of the United States in 1835?

Roger B. Taney became the fifth Chief Justice in 1835, succeeding Chief Justice John Marshall, who died in office after a tenure of 34 years.

Who was a Chief Justice of the United States with the name 'John M'?

John Marshall, the fourth Chief Justice of the United States, who served from 1801-1835, and was instrumental in establishing the Supreme Court as a branch of government equal in power and importance to the Legislative and Executive branches.

Who is thurgood mashall?

Thurgood Marshall was the first African American Justice of the Supreme Court of the United States. He served from 1967 until 1991.

What body does the Chief Justice of the United States head as the top presiding Judge?

The Chief Justice of the United States heads The United States Supreme Court as the top presiding Judge. The Chief Justice's title is The Chief Justice of the United States.

When was Justice Party - United States - created?

Justice Party - United States - was created in 2011.

When was United States Bureau of Justice Statistics created?

United States Bureau of Justice Statistics was created in 1979.

Still have questions?