0
What two competing plans did delegates to the Constitutional Convention debate?
Wiki User
∙ 15y ago
The two plans proposed to determine congressional representation and debated over at the Constitutional Convention were: The "Virginia Plan" or the "Large States Plan" This plan would benefit the larger states (Virginia, New York, the Carolinas, etc.) by making congressional representation proportional to the state's population. This would enable the more populous states to gain more representation, and thus more power in Congress. The "New Jersey Plan" or "Small States Plan" This plan prevented the smaller New England states from being swallowed by the larger states by making all representation equal. The larger states loudly protested that they deserved more representation, but the smaller states steadfastly refused to budge, and threatened to leave the fledgling union if their demands were not conceded to. The debate was eventually settled by The "Connecticut Compromise" or the "Great Compromise" Proposed by delegate Roger Sherman of Connecticut, this plan proposed a bicameral (two house) legislature. In one house (now the House of Representatives), representation would be based on population, while in the other house (now the Senate), each state would have an equal vote.
Wiki User
∙ 15y ago
Wiki User
∙ 13y agoThe competing of small and large state
Nicole Sprinkle
Add your answer:
Earn +20 pts
Were did the delegates of the states meet in Philadelphia for the constitutional debate?
The Constitutional Convention was held at Independence Hall, in Philadelphia.
Which of these is a compromise of two proposals for representation that were presented to the Constitutional Convention?
The Connecticut Compromise -Apex
What was the goal of the constitional convention?
THE Constitutional Convention in 1787 was to replace the Articles of Confederation with a stronger governing document.
What were the secrecy rules during the constitutional convention?
The Secrecy rule said that the convention had to be held in secret and no outside sources could know what was being debated inside the convention. It helped delegates talk freely without the threat of media attention or possibly losing their political careers due to votes or subject matter they addressed.
Why did founding fathers get chosen to write the Constitution without any public input?
The Philadelphia Convention was, in fact held behind closed doors. Minutes of the meetings were secreted at Mt. Vernon, and not all delegates arrived at the convention with the understanding that the convention was being held not to alter the Articles of Confederation, but to replace them with a new Constitution. This secrecy was probably neccessary. To open the convention to public debate would have assured that it would have been mired in constant debate with little hope for a workable agreement. The delegates wisely, I think, chose to hammer out a completed document that could be presented to the states in a complete or near complete form. This both minimized the debate, and provided for those skillful at propaganda ample time to formulate arguements for and against the document. (Federalist Papers) In the end, the public did have a say, in so far as each state had to ratify the document.
What led to numerous debate among the delegates at the Constitutional Convention?
Organization and function to the executive branch
Were did the delegates of the states meet in Philadelphia for the constitutional debate?
The Constitutional Convention was held at Independence Hall, in Philadelphia.
What two competing plan did delegates to the constitution debate?
The competing of small and large state
What did the delegates to the Constitutional Convention do to end the debate about how to elect the President?
They decided to let Congress elect the President.
What were the key rules at the Constitutional Convention?
The 2 most important rules of the Constitutional Convention were that the discussions would be kept secret and that delegates could reopen any issue for later debate. These rules facilitated relatively free and open discussion.
Which of these is a compromise of two proposals for representation that were presented to the Constitutional Convention?
The Connecticut Compromise -Apex
How did the Founding Fathers solve the problems at the convention?
The Founding Fathers used debate and compromise to solve problems at the Constitutional Convention. The convention was held in 1787.
What does constitutional convection mean?
Constitutional convention refers to a gathering of delegates to revise or draft a new constitution. It is a formal assembly where representatives come together to discuss and propose changes to the existing constitutional framework. These conventions provide an opportunity for the public and political leaders to debate and shape the fundamental laws of a nation.
What was the goal of the constitional convention?
THE Constitutional Convention in 1787 was to replace the Articles of Confederation with a stronger governing document.
What major debate began when delegates tried to fix the articles of confederation?
dont no
Where any of the founding fathers at any point in disagreement with what was being decided?
If by founding fathers you mean delegates to the Constitutional Convention then the answer is yes. there was a great deal of vigorous debate over what form the new government should take and everybody had to compromise on something. Ultimately only thirty nine of the delegates actually signed the Constitution. Michael Montagne
What fraction of the slaves in a state were included when determining represantation in congress?
The Three-Fifths Compromise was a compromise reached between delegates from southern states and those from northern states during the 1787 United States Constitutional Convention. The debate was over if, and if so, how, slaves would be counted when determining a state's total population for constitutional purposes.
