What were the advantages and disadvantages of secrecy at the Philadelphia?

Answer 1

The secrecy at the Philadelphia Convention in 1787 allowed delegates to freely discuss and debate contentious issues without public scrutiny, fostering open dialogue that led to compromises essential for the formation of the U.S. Constitution. This confidentiality enabled a more honest exchange of ideas, ultimately facilitating the creation of a stronger federal government. However, the lack of transparency also raised concerns about accountability and public trust, as decisions were made without citizen input. Additionally, it led to criticisms from those who felt excluded from the process, potentially undermining the legitimacy of the resulting document.