0
Which US President had the most unsuccessful nominations for appointing Supreme Court Chief Justices?
Wiki User
∙ 14y ago
Ulysses S. Grant was the only President to have two Chief Justice nominations opposed by the Senate. Both candidates' names were withdrawn prior to a vote due to indications the men would be formally rejected:
George Henry Williams (1873)
The Senate Judiciary Committee declined to recommend Attorney General Williams to the full Senate. He was later forced to resign as Attorney General when caught accepting a $30,000 bribe from Pratt & Boyd in exchange for dropping charges of fraudulent customs entries against the company.
Caleb Cushing (1874)
Cushing's nomination was withdrawn when he was strongly criticized for his earlier anti-war stance and inconsistent behavior when serving in the US Senate. On one or more occasions, Cushing publicly supported causes he later voted against.
Others Rejected as Chief Justice
John Rutledge, (1795) Rutledge was a recess appointment by President Washington, but the Senate believed he was mentally incompetent and declined to confirm his nomination. Rutledge attempted suicide when he learned of the rejection.
Roger B. Taney, (1835) Andrew Jackson's nomination of Roger B. Taney for Chief Justice was tabled indefinitely, but he was ultimately confirmed when the political composition of the Senate changed a few months later.
Abe Fortas, (1968) President Johnson nominated Abe Fortas to replace Chief Justice Earl Warren, who was planning to retire, but conservative members of the Senate saw him as an extension of Warren, whom they disliked due to his progressive leadership. Fortas also raised eyebrows by accepting a total of $15,000 from corporations in exchange for public speaking engagements at universities. The Senate filibustered Fortas' nomination, and his supporters weren't able to muster enough votes for cloture. Fortas was forced to resign in 1969 after accepting a $20,000 retainer for legal advice from a friend and Wall Street financier.
For more information, see Related Questions, below.
Wiki User
∙ 14y ago
Add your answer:
Earn +20 pts
Who are US supreme court judges nominated by?
The president is responsible for appointing justices, who then must be approved by the Senate.
Who appoints the supreme court justices?
The president appoints the supreme court justices
How are justices on the Supreme Court chosen?
The president gets to choose the justices himself
Which US Presidents did not appoint a justice to the Supreme Court?
Four US Presidents did not appoint any Supreme Court justices:William H. HarrisonZachary TaylorAndrew JohnsonJimmy CarterJimmy Carter is the only President of the four who served a full term.
What is the role of president in supreme court?
The President has sole authority to select and nominate US Supreme Court justices, but this power is checked by the Senate, which must approve the nominee by a simple majority vote (51%) before the President can make an official appointment.
Who are US supreme court judges nominated by?
The president is responsible for appointing justices, who then must be approved by the Senate.
The President is allowed the appoint US Supreme Court justices but who has to give their consent for the nominations to be approved?
The Senate
How many justices are there since your country started appointing justices?
like 2 or three
How does the president check the power of the supreme court?
The President checks the power of the Supreme Court by appointing Supreme Court justices and the Chief Justice (subject to Senate confirmation).
How does the supreme court checks the powers of the president?
The President checks the power of the Supreme Court by appointing Supreme Court justices and the Chief Justice (subject to Senate confirmation).
How can the president check and balance the power of the two other branches of government?
The President can veto bills passed by Congress, thus checking the Legislative Branch. The President checks the judicial branch by appointing Supreme Court justices.
Who has the power to make treaties nominate justices to the Supreme Court and other government positions like cabinet officials ministers and ambassadors?
The President has these powers. These powers are granted to to him and him alone by the Constitution.
What best describes presidential nominations of justices to the Supreme Court?
Politicized process.
What president left a strong legacy by appointing 4 justices to the supreme court?
There were multiple presidents that appointed 4 justices to the Supreme Court. There are also numerous others who appointed more than 4. The presidents who appointed exactly 4 justices include: Grant Benjamin Harrison Harding Truman Nixon
Can Supreme Court Justices only be appointed by the President of the US?
Yes, but not quite. If a vacancy occurs in the Supreme Court, the president nominates a replacement. However, the US Senate must confirm the president's nominee and this confirmation is not automatic - a large number of nominations have been rejected through the years.
Can the supreme court justices only be appointed by the president of the US?
Yes, but not quite. If a vacancy occurs in the Supreme Court, the president nominates a replacement. However, the US Senate must confirm the president's nominee and this confirmation is not automatic - a large number of nominations have been rejected through the years.
Which president appointed ten justices?
George Washington nominated ten justices- no too surprising since there were no justices when he became president.
