0
Both are equal. If someone broke either type of law, they are punished depending on the severity. Statute law, since it is written law, it is easier to define.
This may be true in Commonwealth Jurisdictions (the U.K. and countries that were formerly colonies of England), but this is not correct in the United States, however. The common law refers to the body of decisions made by judges concerning the meaning of laws. The common law has no criminal provisions and causes no convictions.
A statute law defines whether an action is criminal. In a civil case, statute law and common law determine under what circumstances whether the defendant can be held liable for the tort alleged to be committed.
Statute law can override common law except with respect to decisions of the Supreme Court. The courts might decide a particular conduct is violating a particular law and is therefore criminal, and the legislature can rewrite the statute to specifically exempt that conduct from being a crime. The common law, at that point declares the conduct is a crime except the statute has now overruled what common law said.
The courts might decide a particular conduct is not violating a particular law and is not criminal, and if the legislature can find a way to define it as such that is not unconstitutional, then the prior common law saying the act wasn't a crime is now overridden.
Now, if the Supreme Court decides something, the legislature can override it if they decide to change the statute to grant more protections to the accused, then it can override a Supreme Court decision. But if the Supreme Court decides Congress doesn't have the power to do something, it can't give itself that power short of a constitutional amendment.
For example, in the famous case of Roe v. Wade, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled abortion restrictions during the first three months are unconstitutional. But after that, they can be imposed, and even more so in the last three months.
So Congress couldn't impose conditions on abortions less than 3 months after conception. It could completely legalize them during the other 6 months, or it can impose restrictions after the first three. This is also applicable to state legislatures.
Wiki User
∙ 12y ago
Add your answer:
Earn +20 pts
Why is statute law superior to common law?
Statute law is considered superior to common law because it is passed by a legislative body and reflects the will of the people through their elected representatives. Statute law is also more stable and predictable as it is documented in written form, making it easier to interpret and apply consistently by legal professionals and the judiciary.
When the common law does not provide an answer the courts must refer to a statute law for guidance?
No. The question is stated in reverse. When the statute has not addressed an issue, then the courts must look to common law.
Can common law override statute law?
Yes and no. In general, in the U.S., a statute overrides pre-existing common law, to the extent of the statute's language. For example, a common law rule may apply to "all contracts". If the legislature later enacts a statute that is stated to apply to "all contracts for the sale of goods," then the statute overrides common law, but only with respect to contracts for the sale of goods.However, a later court case may arise where there is some question to whether the statute applies as written; there is an issue that is not explicitly covered by the statute (for example, the statute may not have defined "goods"). The court may then interpret the statute's unexpressed terms, and in that sense "override" the statute (at least in part) by its interpretation. And that interpretation will be followed in lower court cases.But the right of courts to throw out, or void, statutes because they are unconstitutional is well enshrined in U.S. common law.
When there is inconsistency between a statutory provision and a common law principle which law prevails?
Statute.
What is A codified law?
A codified law is a law enacted by the legislature and described in statute, instead of only in the common law of judicial decision.
Why is statute law superior to common law?
Statute law is considered superior to common law because it is passed by a legislative body and reflects the will of the people through their elected representatives. Statute law is also more stable and predictable as it is documented in written form, making it easier to interpret and apply consistently by legal professionals and the judiciary.
What the common law duty placed on a promoter give one example of what this duty requires?
There is no such thing as "enforceable" common-law. Common law evolved long ago into statute law and it is the provisions of statute law with which courts must contend with today. Statute law (especially in the English-speaking countries of the world) is based on common law but no such 'common law' survives today which is not codified and set forth in statute law. Common law is NOT legally enforceable.
Is employment law a statute law or a common law?
Statue Law
What are three principles of common law?
common law is based on precedent rather on statute law
What are the two kinds of laws you have in australia?
Statute law and common law are the two types of laws in Australia. Statute law refers to the legislation passed in parliament. Upon approval by parliament, statute law becomes common law. Common law emanates from the judiciary, and they are laws passed by juries and judges.
Which is the dominant law statute laws or common law?
Statue
When the common law does not provide an answer the courts must refer to a statute law for guidance?
No. The question is stated in reverse. When the statute has not addressed an issue, then the courts must look to common law.
Does a state statute have priority over a common law of that state?
Statute law comes from legislation. Legislation is enacted by our parliaments and politicians supposedly voicing the needs and social standards of the community as a whole. Common law is made from the verdicts made by judges interpreting statute law. Also it says so in the Constitution!
What effect statute law may have on common law?
What effect statute law may have on common law principles existed prior to the statute?
What is a statute?
A positive law created by state legislature or congress
Are wills statute or common law?
Probate law is now codified (by statutory law) in most jurisdictions but it is derived from common law.
What are the main features of common law and statute law?
The main feature of common law is that this type of law represents the judicial decisions within the court system. The main feature of statute law is that it represents the wishes and beliefs of the legislature.
