answersLogoWhite

0


Best Answer

Because Edward can read Carlisle's mind and knows his decision is to say yes... He feels betrayed by Carlisle because Carlisle was the one person who was kind of his ally in not turning Bella into a Vampire because they are the two who believe that your soul is lost when you become immortal.

- Calculus Ho

User Avatar

Wiki User

14y ago
This answer is:
User Avatar

Add your answer:

Earn +20 pts
Q: At the end of twilight new moon when the cullens are voting wether or not to change Bella Edward says to carlisle why are you doing this to me you know what this means what does Edward mean by this?
Write your answer...
Submit
Still have questions?
magnify glass
imp
Continue Learning about Movies & Television

How old was Edward when he became vampire?

Edward Cullen was changed into a vampire by Carlisle Cullen when Edward was 17. he and his mother had spanish influensa and were both dying. Carlisle was with Edwards mother, just before she died she told Carlisle to save edward, in a way no one else could, carlisle thought she knew he was a vampire but before he could ask she was dead. So edward had no one in the world at all, he was dying and carlisle had no companion. so carlisle changed him into a vampire witch is very very very hard.


Why did carlisle turn edward into a vampire?

Edward was suffering from a very serious disease and Carlyle was his assigned doctor. Edward's mother found out what Carlyle really was and begged him to change Edward so that Edward would survive. Also keep in mind that Edwards mother was very sick too.


What is the resolution in twilight eclipse?

The resolution to the first book, Twilight, is the destruction of James and the rescue of Bella. From there, the resolution is expanded upon by the prom scene in which Bella expresses her desire to be like Edward, and Edward makes his first statements of opposition.


How does Edward Cullen propose to Bella?

In the Twilight Series Edward Cullen and Bella Swan love each other so much. Because Bella loves him she wants to become a vampire and stay with him forever. At the end of New Moon Edward promised to change her only if she marries her. In the movie she doesn't give an answer but in Eclipse when they are alone in the Cullen's house Edward ask's again. He does it again because Bella wanted to make-out with him but Edward stops her and makes another promise. He promised to make-out with Bella after the wedding and to change her into a vampire after that. But of course after that he showed Bella the ring. He knelt down on one knee and said: "Isabella Swan? I promise to love you forever - every day of forever. Will you marry me?" And of course Bella says "Yes!"


In what words does edward propose to Bella in eclipse?

duhhh...y wouldnt she get married to edward? Yes, Edward proposed to Bella in Eclipse and marries her in Breaking Dawn. Yes, and they get married i think on August 13th. Yes, they do and Bella gets changed by Edward afterward.

Related questions

How did Edward Cullen change in twilight?

He was dying of the Spanish Influenza, Carlisle saved him.


In the movie twilight how long will it take when Bella gets like one of the cullens hales in what book and does carlisle Esme and every one else in the family know or find out?

Edward change Bella in Breaking Dawn, and the Cullens are one hundred percent aware of it, I'm not going to give too much away.


What does Edward mean in Twilight when he says to Carlisle 'She only has minutes left'?

Edward is talking about how Bella only has 1 minute left until she will start to change into a vampire.


What scean is after the piano in twilight?

Well the only scene in which there is a piano is when Bella is at the Cullens' house, meeting the Cullens. While she is at the Cullens' she and Edward are talking in his room and Alice and Jasper come in to invite them to a game of baseball(Cullen style). Bella goes home to change, introduces Charlie to Edward as her boyfriend and they meet the rest of the Cullens' at the clearing for the infamous baseball scene.


Why is Edward a vampire in twilight?

He is a vampire because Carlisle was asked to change him by his dying mother. Edward, like his parents, was also dying from the Spanish influenza and Carlisle was working as a doctor at the hospital that his family were being treated at so he could see that Edwards condition was deteriorating rapidly.


What year did carlisle change edward into a vampire?

1918


Why does Carlisle change Edward?

to save Bella swan


Who all did carlisle change?

Carlisle Cullen, a character from the Twilight series, changed Edward, Esme, Rosalie, Emmett, and Alice to become vampires. Later, he also changed Jasper and Bella into vampires.


What movie did carlisle change edward?

Technicly, the first one.


When does carlise change someone?

In the Twilight Saga, Carlisle Cullen changes Edward into a vampire in 1918 when he was on the brink of death due to Spanish influenza. Carlisle also changes Esme, Rosalie, Emmett, Alice, and Jasper into vampires at different times and circumstances.


What colors do edward collen's eyes change to?

In the "Twilight" book series, Edward Cullen's eyes change from golden to black depending on his emotions or hunger level. Golden eyes indicate he is feeling calm or content, while black eyes suggest he is experiencing strong emotions or thirst for blood.


What is Edwards past in twilight?

Edward had a human life in Chicago during WWI, it was happy yet slightly boring. His father was a lawyer and his mother a housewife. In September 1918, when Edward was 17, influenza killed both of Edward's parents, and nearly killed him, too. Edward's mother's dying wish was for Carlisle Cullen, the doctor who cared for the family, to save Edward. She seemed to suspect Carlisle was a vampire and could save Edward by changing him. Carlisle did change him. Edward usually pretends to be Carlisle and Esme's adopted son, but before the familly was so big, he was Esme's "younger brother."He's been through Medical School twice, but he never actually used his degrees and became a doctor. His hobbies were, and are, collecting cars nad driving fast. 1927-1931 he left Carlisle and Esme. Deciding he would drink the blood of only the truly evil, he used his special talent and read everyone's minds to avoid good people. He eventually decided to come back in 1931, knowing what he was doing was wrong. In 1936 the family all moved to Forks and met the Quileute Indians, who could turn into wolves. This made them werewolves, the natural enemy of vampires. The Cullens made a treaty with them, the Cullens stayed off their land and bit no one, and the Quileutes would leave them alone. The Cullens eventually all moved away. In 2003, they all moved back to Forks. Then, in 2005, so did Bella. That's when Edward met her.