answersLogoWhite

0

Answer A: From Muslim perspective:

* For purposes of clarity, there is no old testament in Islam. Islam has since its inception preached one word or rather one book which has never been edited.

The Old Testament recognized no inheritance rights to widows. Accordingly, widows were among the most vulnerable of the Jewish population. The male relatives who inherited all of a woman's deceased husband's estate were to provide for her from that estate. However, widows had no way to ensure this provision was carried out, and lived on the mercy of others. Therefore, widows were among the lowest classes in ancient Israel and widowhood was considered a symbol of great degradation (Isaiah 54:4).

However, the plight of a widow in the Biblical tradition extended even beyond her exclusion from her husband's property. According to Genesis 38, a childless widow must marry her husband's brother, even if he is already married, so that he can produce offspring for his dead brother, thus ensuring his brother's name will not die out. "Then Judah said to Onan, 'Lie with your brother's wife and fulfill your duty to her as a brother-in-law to produce offspring for your brother' " (Genesis 38:8). The widow's consent to this marriage is not required. The widow is treated as part of her deceased husband's property whose main function is to ensure her husband's posterity. A childless widow in Israel is bequeathed to her husband's brother. If the brother is too young to marry, she has to wait until he comes of age. Should the deceased husband's brother refuse to marry her, she is set free and can then marry any man of her choice. It is not an uncommon phenomenon in Israel that widows are subjected to blackmail by their brothers-in-law in order to gain their freedom.

The pagan Arabs before Islam had similar practices. A widow was considered a part of her husband's property to be inherited by his male heirs and she was, usually, given in marriage to the deceased man's eldest son from another wife.

The Quran scathingly attacked and abolished this degrading custom: {And marry not women whom your fathers married--Except what is past-- it was shameful, odious, and abominable custom indeed} (Quran, chapter 4, verse 22). Widows and divorced women were so looked down upon in the Biblical tradition that the high priest could not marry a widow, a divorced woman, or a prostitute: "The woman he (the high priest) marries must be a virgin. He must not marry a widow, a divorced woman, or a woman defiled by prostitution, but only a virgin from his own people, so he will not defile his offspring among his people" (Lev. 21:13-15)

In Israel today, a descendant of the Cohen caste (the high priests of the days of the Temple) cannot marry a divorcee, a widow, or a prostitute. In the Jewish legislation, a woman who has been widowed three times with all the three husbands dying of natural causes is considered 'fatal' and forbidden to marry again.

The Quran, on the other hand, recognizes neither castes nor fatal persons. Widows and divorcees have the freedom to marry whomever they choose. There is no stigma attached to divorce or widowhood in the Quran, [nor is there any attached to widowhood in the Bible]. {When you divorce women and they fulfil their terms [three menstruation periods] either take them back on equitable terms or set them free on equitable terms; But do not take them back to injure them or to take undue advantage, If anyone does that, he wrongs his own soul. Do not treat Allah's signs as a jest} [Quran, chapter 2, verse 231]. {If any of you die and leave widows behind, they shall wait four months and ten days. When they have fulfilled their term, there is no blame on you if they dispose of themselves in a just manner} [Quran, chapter 2, verse 234]. {Those of you who die and leave widows should bequeath for their widows a year's maintenance and residence. But if they [the widows] leave (the residence) there is no blame on you for what they justly do with themselves} [Quran, chapter 2, verse 240].

Answer B: from Jewish perspective:

The above comments about women in Judaism are completely wrong.

1. In matters of inheritance, even in ancient times women could inherit the property of her husband. The only time that wouldn't happen would have been if she returned to her father's home and her father belonged to a different tribe from her husband. The reason for this is that land ownership was tribal based and land owned by one tribe couldn't be transferred to a different one. Tribe is determined by biological father but if a woman marries a man from a different tribe, she becomes a part of the husband's tribe. Of course, today there is no issue of tribal association with land.

2. In regard to brothers marrying a deceased brother's wife where there were no children from that marriage. The brother was required to offer marriage to the widow but it was the widow's choice to accept the marriage proposal. If she refused the proposal, the marriage didn't happen. There is NO practice of blackmailing widows to marry a brother in modern Israel.

3. There is no stigma attached to divorce and being a widow and never has been.

4. There is no Israeli legislation that bans a woman who's been widowed 3 times from marrying again.

Answer C: Comment on Answer BThe views in answer B are fully agreed upon as the current civil rights assured for women; whether Christians, Jewish, or any other religion followers. However, the sayings in answer A reflects the Jewish and Christian woman status; religiously; in time of Quran revelation to prophet Muhammad in the seventh century and how Islam teachings assured woman rights at that time and long before the countries woman right laws and UN human rights laws. We all agree that the current civil laws in Israel and in Euorope and other parts of the world assures human rights for woman as that for man. Answer D: Comment on Answer C

Answer C implies that the information provided in Answer B reflect only modern Judaism which is false. The information provided in Answer B reflects attitudes held in ancient Judaism going back over 3000 years. At no point in history were the claims made in Answer A about Judaism true.

User Avatar

Wiki User

13y ago

What else can I help you with?

Related Questions

What are the three great monotheistic faiths?

Islam, Judaism and Christianity.


What three religions claim palestine as the Holy Land?

Judaism, Christianity, and Islam have all claimed the Holy Land for themselves.


What are the Abraham faiths?

Judaism, Christianity, and Islam religions.


Where is the central location now of Christianity Judaism and Islam?

For Judaism and Christianity it is Jerusalem. For Islam it is Mecca.


What are three prominent religions in the Middle east?

-- Islam -- Judaism -- Christianity


Which religions were founded in the Europe and southwest Asia?

Christianity and Judaism


Which major religions trace their origins back to Abraham?

Abraham is considered the father of Judaism, Christianity and Islam as the Old Testament's 5 books of Moses - The Pentateuch (books are: Genesis, Exodus, Leviticus, Numeri and Deuteronomy) are included in the Holy Book of Judaism that is Torah. Eventually he is considered as the father of Islam basically claims entire religions of Judaism and Christianity as "prophets" and predecessors of Islam.


What do Jews have to do with Chrisitanity?

The question should be " What does Christianity have to do with Jews (or Judaism)?" Judaism is like a tree where Christianity is its branch and Islam is it leaves. Christianity is based on Judaism and Islam is based on Christianity. The major difference between the three is that Judaism doesn't have jesus in it unlike Christianity and Islam.


The beliefs of Judaism helped to shape What are the two religions that came from Judaism?

Christianity and Islam both trace their roots to Judaism.


A religion that has similarities with judaism and Christianity?

Islam. It claims that it is the continuEation of Judaism and CHRISTIANITY


Is there a link between Christianity and Islam?

Both Islam and Christianity originated out of Judaism.


Who was the God of Christianity and Judaism?

There is only One God in Christianity, Judaism and Islam.