answersLogoWhite

0


Best Answer

The same way anybody can break any law: illegally.

If you're alleging that this has occurred and you want to know why it was allowed in a particular instance that you consider to be a violation, you'll have to be more specific.

However, there are two basic ways the federal government could justify actions that some people might consider a violation of the tenth amendment.

One would be by passing another amendment granting itself the specific powers it wants. Doing so automatically squares such actions with the tenth amendment, as they then become "granted to it by [an amendment to] the Constitution." A good example of this would be prohibition... nothing in the constitution expressly allowed the Federal government to prohibit alcohol entirely (the "interstate commerce" clause gave it the power to prohibit transporting alcohol from one state to another, but not to do so within a single state) until the 18th amendment was passed, at which point it explicitly was granted that power.

The other would be to argue that the actions in question are in fact implicit within the scope granted to it by the constitution. For example, the power to "regulate interstate commerce" has occasionally been interpreted as the power to intervene in local affairs which have an impact on interstate commerce.

User Avatar

Wiki User

13y ago
This answer is:
User Avatar

Add your answer:

Earn +20 pts
Q: How can the government violate or break the Amendment X to the US Constitution?
Write your answer...
Submit
Still have questions?
magnify glass
imp
Related questions

What is the only condition specified by the constitution concerning the nature of state governments?

The only guaranteed condition specified by the Constitution concerning the nature of state governments was a Republic Form of government. The Constitution also states that each state will be protected from invasion as well.


Which branch of your government decides if laws break rules of your constitution?

Judicial Branch


What does fract mean?

To break or to violate.


What is the meaning of fract?

To break; to violate.


Why was there a deadlock over the form of the new government how did the constitution convention break that deadlock?

Connecticut compromise


Is it illegal to break a amendment?

I think so


To break as a law or promise?

To break, as a law or promise is to violate something. EX: Telling your friends a secret was a *violation* to your other friend.


What is The Woman's Suffrage Amendment to the US Constitution?

The 24th amendment grants women the right to vote. This amendment was ratified in 1920. It reads:The right of citizens of the United States to vote shall not be denied or abridged by the United States or by any State on account of sex.Congress shall have power to enforce this article by appropriate legislation.This right was one of the first break throughs for women's equality. Before this amendment, women were not allowed to vote or have any impact on government or politics. Only white, land owning men were allowed to have any say in governmental matters.


What would happen if you break the fifth amendment?

How you would break it down is very simple. If a police officer suspects you of something then they need to obtain a search warrant. If they get the search warrant then they can barge into your home.


Who is allowed to break the rules of the constitution?

no one is


Did Mother Teresa break any laws?

If she did break any laws, there is no record of it that might be public. It is highly unlikey that she would intentionally violate any just law.


Which factors caused the enforcement of the Eighteenth Amendment to break down?

1)lack of government agents to control illegal liquor-related crimes 2)people opposing Prohibition who did little to help authorities